Justin Franklin wrote:
I am not sure pulling an entire other earth pantheon whole sale is a good idea. I think it worked for the Egyptian one since they are all anthropomorphic.
Also remember that the rumor is that like the Dragon Empires, Casmaron will have a different core 20 deities. I would guess most of the newer gods, except for Irori won't have a place in Casmaron. Abadar, Desna, Irori, Lamashtu, Pharasma, Sarenrae, and Shelyn all seem like safe bets since they are in the Dragon Empires as well.
All of the important greek gods are anthropomorphic. It's only once you start reaching back into the family tree, with the protogenoi where they start getting weird. I'd also point out that while the vast majority of the egyptian gods are anthropomorphic, there is a notable exception in Apep.
It's also entirely possible to have a separate 20 core deities like the Dragon Empires had while still giving Iblydos it's unique greek pantheon, just like the inner see has it's twenty core and Osirion happens to have twenty extras that fell out of worship before being picked up again. Iblydos is one small part of Casmaron, not the whole thing.
I'm simply of the opinion that having the egyptian pantheon being the one real world pantheon to have a presence while having the greek pantheon be co-opted by the pathfinder core would be rather jarring. I don't think it's the kind of trick you get to do just once.
On the subject of Casmaron's pantheon, I'd like it if it has a few different carry overs from the Inner Sea core than the Dragon Empire carry overs. Having the same deities appear in all three pantheons gives the impression that they're a step above the others.
At the very least, I'd switch out Lamashtu for Asmodeus.
Since Lamashtu has already been mentioned as being in Iblydos, I have a feeling we know which way Paizo is planning to go with her. See the Baphomet article in Herald of the Ivory Labyrinth.