Paizo Top Nav Branding
  • Hello, Guest! |
  • Sign In |
  • My Account |
  • Shopping Cart |
  • Help/FAQ
About Paizo Messageboards News Paizo Blog Help/FAQ

Jiggy's page

RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32. RPG Superstar 2013 Marathon Voter, 2014 Dedicated Voter, 2015 Dedicated Voter. FullStarFullStar Pathfinder Society GM. 18,448 posts (20,368 including aliases). 17 reviews. 4 lists. 1 wishlist. 13 Pathfinder Society characters. 16 aliases.

1 to 50 of 379 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | next > last >>

The normally-quiet rural village of Linhaus has been full of excitement since sunrise. Today is the annual Gordon Lightfoot Celebration, a festival held to honor the town's local hero and commemorate the day, three years ago, that he tracked down the mayor's lost daughter in the forest and saved her from a whole pack of wolves that had been killing livestock and keeping people in their homes after dark for nearly a year.

After a morning of games and pie auctions, the townsfolk begin to gather in Town Square, where food tents have been set up for lunch and sweets. Having won a raffle, two elves and a tiefling share a table with the hero Gordon, and are just about to begin eating.

Then, a swift blur and a loud noise stun the group. As your brains catch up to your senses, you realize that a human man has fallen from above and landed in your midst, shattering the table around which you all sit. The man is obviously dead, though it's less obvious whether the cause of death was the fall or the large dagger lodged in his chest.

The excited chatter of the festival is quickly replaced by unsettled murmurs and nervous whispers.

Obviously, the people at the table are you guys. What would you like to do?

Discussion thread created!

Hello gamers,

I'm recruiting for a new homebrew 5E campaign. It's going to be kind of "open-ended", with me starting us off with a plot hook and then crafting the campaign based on what happens and what the PCs decide to do. (That's not to say you'll never run into a dead end, just that I won't have pre-planned rails.)

Even the setting itself will be something we create together as we play. When it becomes relevant to encounter or hear about a given location, religion, creature, artifact, etc; I'll come up with something and that becomes canon.

So, that's the general idea. Here's the starting point:

Our initial "blank slate" will be a fairly generic pseudo-european medieval fantasy setting. The PCs will be starting in a mid-sized town. The campaign will open with one or more events happening, the PCs will respond, and the rest is up to us to create. :)

Character creation parameters:
No evil characters.
PHB only.
This stat array: 15/14/13/12/10/8
All PHB races are allowed (even drow), but be aware that some of the more exotic ones might draw attention.
No pets (animal companions, familiars, etc).
Feats are allowed (including the version of humans that gets one at 1st level, though the standard human is available too).
Your choice of standard gear or gold/purchase (for the latter, pretend all your d4's rolled 3's).
You can either take one of the standard backgrounds, or you can just come up with a pair of values and a flaw and pick some combination of four (total) relevant skills/tools/languages.
Characters will be starting at 1st level.

Gameplay notes:
I don't know the D&D pantheon. Combined with the "create as we go" style of this campaign, this means in-world religion will mostly be generic references to "the gods" until such time as greater specificity is needed. As such, clerics need not pick a deity; you can be a "concept cleric" who is passionate about some particular virtue/domain.
I don't have the MM. I also don't like the possibility of "[MONSTER] would be thematically appropriate here but is too weak/strong for this fight." Therefore, I will be pulling monster stats/abilities out of my arse. Hopefully the result is a renewed sense of exploration and the unknown. :)
Everyone should put a line containing their HP (current and max), AC, and saves into the "Classes" line of their character's profile. This makes it appear under your name in your gameplay posts, so I can see it during play without having to open your profile. Seriously, keep this up to date.

Other considerations:
I want a good pace of posting; at least once per day. I get that sometimes things come up, but if you don't think you can establish a "norm" of at least 1/day, then please don't ask for a spot. Even if it's just "Doofus nods in agreement and follows Buttface into the room," get in there and be a part of the momentum that you want to see. If you anticipate a lapse (due to travel, holidays, etc), please announce it in the discussion thread.

Keep rules discussions in the discussion thread rather than the gameplay thread.

Be a team player, be a part of the fun!


I'm sure I probably missed something obvious. Feel free to ask questions!

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

I'm pondering starting up a new PbP, and wanted to see how much interest there would be, before I start putting any real work into it. Here's the idea:

It would be D&D 5E, and characters would be PHB-only.

The campaign would be something of an experiment in open-ended storytelling, with a story arc not fully formed in advance. That is, you would encounter a plot hook or two, you would decide what you want to do, and I would sort of form the campaign around you. So I guess you could call that kind of "sandboxy".

The setting would be created/discovered together by players and GM as a joint narrative. Things not relevant to the story don't exist yet; existence of setting elements begins as said elements become relevant.

Monsters would all be custom-made (partly because I don't have the MM, partly because "[MONSTER] would be thematically appropriate here but is too weak/strong for the party" is lame).

No idea where this would end up. It'd be a shared spontaneous creation of a story and world, where I create things as you explore them.

Does that sound like something I could get a full four(ish) people to play? Let me know if you're interested, and feel free to ask any questions. :)

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Anybody else watching this show? My wife and I are following it, and it's been pretty good so far.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

2 people marked this as a favorite.

Hi there,
So, Chris just (understandably) locked a thread in the PFS forums regarding the recent SLA FAQ reversal and its implementation in PFS. The thread has indeed gotten pretty nasty at times. By this time yesterday, I'd have totally agreed with the decision to lock it.

Since then, however, the tone has shifted significantly. Some truly calm and well-reasoned posts have been made, and there are some folks really listening to each other. Heck, there's even been more than one person self-initiating apologies for their own behavior—on the internet!

I feel like we were just starting to get some traction on helpful dialogue when the thread got locked. For that reason, and maybe I'm being too hopeful for the thread here, but I'd like to humbly beg you to consider reopening that thread. Thanks.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

1 person marked this as a favorite.

I'm wondering if, via Style Feats and the Brawler class, it might be possible to make a PFS-legal character reasonably close to the CP9 characters from One Piece.

Here's my thoughts so far:

Human (for now)

STR 18
DEX 14
CON 14
INT 10
WIS 10
CHA 10
(Stats could change, that's just a starting point.)

Brawler1: Weapon Focus (unarmed strike), Toughness (or something)
Brawler2: Flurry, Pummeling Style
Brawler3: Snake Style <-- Piercing damage for Finger Pistol
Brawler4: Knockout (not really relevant to conversion, but whatever)
Brawler5: Weapon Spec, Tiger Style <-- Slashing damage for Tempest Kick
Brawler6: Not much here
Brawler7: Power Attack
Brawler8: Pummeling Charge

Any thoughts to boost the concept and/or power level? This is just kind of a first draft at the moment.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32 , Marathon Voter 2013, Dedicated Voter 2014, Dedicated Voter 2015 aka Jiggy

Tomb of the Mad Elementalist

Silver Crusade

Hey all,
Just hit 4th level with my human bloodrager (arcane bloodline). Here's what I look like so far:

STR 18 (15 + 2race + 1lvl)
DEX 14
CON 14
INT 10
WIS 10
CHA 13

Traits: Indomitable Will, Friend in Every Town

Feats: Improved Initiative, Power Attack, Improved Sunder (also Eschew Materials as a bonus feat)

I have the Spelleater archetype, replacing Uncanny Dodge (and Improved) and my normal DR with getting Fast Healing while raging. Later I'll also be able to "eat" spell slots for some minor, swift-action self-healing.

Anyway, the big thing right now is I need to pick two spells known. With my CHA score, I get 2/day, so I shouldn't pick spells I'll want to cast repeatedly. I also won't have high save DCs (only DC 12 for my 1st-level spells), so "save negates" spells don't seem like a good idea. On the other hand, bloodragers (unlike rangers/paladins) have a full CL instead of level—3, so effects that scale with level are more usable.

So far, I've considered blade lash for some extra combat versatility, burning hands for swarm-killing, feather fall for the occasional "oh crap" moment, shield for tough-looking fights if I don't think my rage-blur will cut it...

I dunno, it seems like there are lots of reasonable options, so I'm having trouble picking. Any thoughts? Thanks!

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Pathfinder has a long list of conditions, such as fatigued, exhausted, shaken, entangled, and grappled. Each of these has different effects, but those effects are pre-defined. That is, a spell or ability can simply say "fatigued" without having to spell out the actual mechanical implications of that effect. However, the downside to that is that until you've memorized all these conditions, you have to go look something up every time such an effect is implemented (or use the handy-dandy Condition Cards).

Now imagine a hypothetical universe in which none of those terms were pre-defined, and instead, any given effect simply told you exactly what it did (such as "you get –2 STR/DEX and can't run or charge"). This would lengthen the word count of new spells/feats/etc, but a given player never has to learn more than what currently is affecting him, and doesn't need to follow up being told a condition with a second step of having to look up what it actually means. But, that also means there could be a potentially infinite variety of conditions, along with some inconsistencies among what it means to, for instance, be magically made tired.

I can see pros and cons to both models. What are the community's thoughts on the topic?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32 , Marathon Voter 2013, Dedicated Voter 2014, Dedicated Voter 2015 aka Jiggy

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Soulshifter Staff
Aura strong necromancy; CL 13th
Slot none; Price 90,000 gp; Weight 5 lbs.
This smooth, unadorned staff is carved of pristine ivory on one end and dark onyx on the other. It allows the use of the following spells:

  • Vampiric touch (1 charge)
  • Breath of life (2 charges)
  • Slay living (2 charges)

Additionally, this staff’s power can be used to control the flow of life energy beyond the normal limits of the spells listed above. When using the soulshifter staff to cast vampiric touch, the wielder may spend 1 additional charge to divide the temporary hit points evenly among any number of allies within 30 feet. Whenever the wielder kills a creature with slay living, he may spend an immediate action to cast breath of life, targeting any creature within 30 feet. Conversely, if the wielder successfully revives a slain creature via breath of life, he may spend an immediate action to cast slay living against any target within 30 feet, using a ranged touch attack instead of a melee touch attack. Spells cast as immediate actions in this way consume 1 more charge than normal.

Requirements Craft Staff, Quicken Spell, breath of life, slay living, vampiric touch; Cost 45,000 gp

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

By that I mean, sometime in the last day or two I've noticed that whenever I'm viewing a thread, the page is wider than normal. I end up having to scroll back and forth to read posts. No idea why.

If it matters, I'm using IE.

Grand Lodge ** RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

4 people marked this as a favorite.

Why do you roleplay? Why do you GM? What aspects are important to you? Why? Please try to stick to "I prefer" and not "This is The Way". It's okay for people to want other things, and your desires are no more important than theirs. This is an opportunity to learn about each other, to discover the ways in which we might not be as much the "norm" as we think we are, and thereby grow. :)


My interest in Pathfinder includes some of the same things that motivate all my pastimes: having fun, socializing, etc. But the reason why I spend a given block of time playing Pathfinder instead of doing other things I enjoy is largely my ability to influence how the story plays out. I love movies, but PFS is my chance to switch from "Why didn't they just do X?" to "I do X." Although I love and embrace classic storytelling tropes, roleplaying is my chance to turn those tropes on their heads, to make the story actually play out differently for a change. It's the only story-related experience where I get to help shape it. It's also the only story-related experience that I can't predict (at least, without turning my brain off, which I often do during movies so I can experience "the ride").

It's my only outlet to combine storytelling and agency. I can get the former with movies and the latter with other games, but roleplaying is the sweet synthesis of the two. :)

When I GM, my main goal is that the players are free to enjoy the game for their reasons, not mine; though I do always hope to see a little of "my kind of stuff" if I'm lucky. :)

That's me. How about the rest of you?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Not sure if this is the right place for this sort of question, but here goes:

I'm writing a new d20 fantasy roleplaying system. It was originally intended to be somewhat Pathfinder-compatible, but it's evolved to be so much of its own thing that it couldn't possibly be considered such.

Even so, there are a few basic similarities, and I want to make sure I don't run afoul of the OGL.

1) My game's core mechanic for success/failure is rolling a d20 and adding modifiers, trying to meet or beat a target number. Do I need to worry about OGL stuff for that concept?

1a) Does it make a difference whether I say "roll" or "check"?
1b) Does it make a difference whether I say "difficulty" or "DC"?

2) My game uses six stats: three physical, three mental, like Pathfinder. How does that relate to the OGL?

2a) Does it make a difference whether I say "attribute" or "ability score"?
2b) Does it make a difference whether I say "Dexterity" or "Agility" (and so forth with the other stats, though I'm not sure of an alternate word for "Strength")?

3) Characters grow in power by gaining "levels". Is that OGL, or is it generic enough to not matter?

4) Certain noncombat activities involve what I'm currently calling "skills", which are similar in concept to Pathfinder's skills (and still use the "d20+mods vs target number" mechanic), but it's a different list of skills and their implementation is different. OGL?

4a) Does it make a difference if I come up with a term other than "skill"?
4b) Does it make a difference if some of the skills do or do not have the same name as a Pathfinder skill? (Frex, I'm not sure of an alternate word for "Acrobatics".)

Aaaaand that's about where the similarities to Pathfinder end. I want to do this proper, so any guidance is appreciated. Thanks!

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

1 person marked this as a favorite.

I think that the ACG finally adds enough tools to let me make a non-small lance-wielding combatant on a flying mount from level 1. Let's see what we can do here:

I'm liking the giant wasp's 60ft fly speed with good maneuverability. So to make that work, I'll be a human with Eye for Talent, sacrificing my bonus feat to raise the wasp's INT to 2 (losing the mindless quality, but letting him learn enough tricks to actually be usable).

The wasp is only medium, so my 1st-level feat is going to be Undersized Mount so I can ride him.

That leaves his carrying capacity; if memory serves, he needs to be within a light load in order to fly. As a hunter, I'll get animal focus, which will let me grant the wasp a constant +2 STR (and more later). Since he's a quadruped (well, more than that, but we only have rules for quadrupeds) he gets 1.5x carrying capacity. That puts him in the 60s for a light load.

So my first spell known will be ant haul, tripling his carrying capacity (into a comfortable 190-ish) for 2 hours per level. At 1st-2nd level, I'll probably be carrying scrolls of that. Soon I can just get by on spell slots, though.


At first level, my stats will be:
STR 18 (16+2)
DEX 14
CON 12
INT 08
WIS 14
CHA 10

Or something in that neighborhood. Not sure.

Then I can cast A.H. on my wasp and mount up, performing 120ft flying charges with a lance for 2d8+12 damage.

Now, here's the tricky part:
That means that at first level I'm functional, but haven't even gotten started on real feats yet.

So do I stay mono-hunter and take Mounted Combat at 3rd, Power Attack at 5th, and so on?

Or do I go like this:
Hunter1: Undersized Mount
Fighter1: Boon Companion, Mounted Combat
Fighter2: Power Attack
Fighter3: Ride-by Attack
Fighter4: Spirited Charge

Basically, a 4-level fighter dip starting at 3rd nets me two extra feats (gain 3 combat feats, but lose a feat to Boon Companion). Is that a good idea?

Any other ideas to make this build work out?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

I could swear I've heard of a feat that allows you to ride a mount that's the same size category as you, instead of needing it to be bigger. Could somebody point me in the right direction?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

I have another task for those forumites who enjoy mathy stuff. :)

So let's say I have a character named Alice. She attacks once per round at +15 to hit and deals 2d6+20 damage on a hit. (For my reference: 10+5+5)

Now let's say I also have a character named Bob. He can attack twice per round. Each attack is at +11 to hit for 1d6+14 damage.

Now suppose I have a third character, this one named Charlene. She can attack four times per round. Each attack is at +11 to hit and deals 1d6+8 damage.

Against target ACs of 15, 20, and 25; what is the average damage per round for each of these characters? Please do not factor in crits.

Thanks in advance!

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

That is all.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

I'm hoping someone would be willing to do some hypothetical math for me.

Let's suppose that we've got a character, call her Alice, who can attack once per round at +15 to hit for 6d6+21 damage. (Just go with it, okay?)

Now let's suppose we have a second character, call him Bob, who can attack twice per round at +10 to hit, with each hit dealing 3d10+15 damage.

Now let's further suppose we have a third character, call her Charlene, who can attack four times per round, at +13 to hit, each time dealing 3d8+9 damage.

Finally, let's suppose we have a fourth character, call him Dan, who is exactly like Charlene except for an unfortunate -2 penalty on all attack rolls.

Against various target ACs, and without factoring in crits, how does the DPR compare on these four characters?

Thanks in advance for the math!

Silver Crusade

Hello all,

Just hit 3rd level in PFS, and I'm looking for some advice on feat selection. Here's my build so far:
Human (Varisian)
STR 17
DEX 14
CON 14
INT 10
WIS 10
CHA 13

Bloodrager 3 (Spelleater archetype)

Traits: Friend in Every Town (+1Diplo/class skill), Indomitable Will (+1 Will)

Feats: Improved Initiative, Power Attack

Bloodline: Arcane

I fight with a longsword; I can two-hand for the same damage bonuses as a two-hander, but I'm not hosed if I get grappled or need to fight while carrying a macguffin or whatever.

(You can also click my name to get an idea of my concept/backstory.)

I'm planning on my first bloodline feat being Iron Will. And once I get an item to boost my CON (possibly an ioun stone, since I'll want my belt in STR), I'll spend my next feat on Raging Vitality, which I don't currently qualify for. That'll likely be at 7th level.

So for right now, here's what I'm considering:
Cosmopolitan: Grabbing a couple of languages and class skills could help make him more versatile. But which skills would I pick?
Toughness: Make up for not having the d12 HD that normally comes with the rage penalty to AC.
Steadfast Personality: Extra buffer on those Will saves (at least, the ones that really count). Only +1 at the moment, but will scale up a bit.

Thoughts? Thanks!

Silver Crusade

Hello! I just hit 8th level in PFS, so I need to pick my first 4th-level spell. And since I'm a human taking the alternate FCB, I also need to pick a 3rd-level spell. Bloodline is Elemental (Primal [electricity]) and my CHA is currently 26.

Going from memory on existing spells known:

3rd level
Protection from Energy (bloodline)
Lightning Bolt
Hold Person

2nd level
Scorching Ray (bloodline, electricity only)
Burst of Radiance
Pilfering Hand
See Invisibility

1st level
Burning Hands (bloodline, electricity only)
Mage Armor
Magic Missile
Silent Image
Liberating Command
????? (can't remember)

So I need a 3rd- and 4th-level spell. I see several juicy options, so I'm a bit indecisive. Also, since I'm hitting an even level, should I make a swap somewhere?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

(Players in my Impact at Woodhaven campaign, stay out!)

So I'm running a homebrew campaign for a party of four. The two frontliners use exotic weapons: one a katana, the other a two-bladed sword. I want to drop my players some cool loot, but somehow, finding the specific exotic weapon you specialize in as loot feels a bit... contrived compared to finding, say, a +3 longsword or a ring of protection.

Any suggestions on how to work in cool exotic weapons as loot without it straining credulity?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Hey all,

I'll be going to GenCon for the first time, and it's right around the corner! It has now occurred to me that I'm signed up for a couple of Tier 1-5 scenarios, and currently all I have in-tier is a 3rd-level cleric.

In case I'm at an otherwise low-level table, I'd like to have another low-level PC available.

I have a 3XP GM credit baby, so I could start a new PC at 2nd level. The downside is that I don't have much time to prepare, and whatever I threw together would be locked in permanently. Also, with tieflings and aasimar going away, that slot is my last chance at such a race, so it's a bit valuable to potentially lose. But on the plus side, he'd end up very close to 3rd level, the point where I actually have a good chance of playing him in the foreseeable future. (I've played most low-level scenarios, and my local PFS scene tends to keep re-running the old favorites, so some of the older ones I missed come up so rarely that all it takes is one scheduling conflict to keep me locked out of it for another year or longer.)

Alternatively, I could just start a totally fresh PC with 0XP. This has the advantage of being able to still change things after the fact, but on the downside, it means that at the end of GenCon I have two different slots at 3XP or less, and not very many low-level scenarios to play them in. Given that I recently retired a character at 13.2, will be retiring another after GenCon, and my next will be 7th and then the next 3rd; having two characters stuck at bottom tier means they won't be played for a long time.

Any suggestions/advice?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

The Paizo PRD has a handy page of monsters by CR, but it's limited to the first Bestiary. Is there another site somewhere that has multiple Bestiaries compiled into a single list that is (or can be) sorted by CR?


Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

I'm working on a massive set of houserules (to the point of really being more like a new game), and right now I'm looking at the concept of being denied your DEX bonus to AC.

I like the idea of having a mechanic that represents the ability to catch your opponent unawares (or in a position where their defense is compromised, such as while climbing). However, I'm not sure I like it being a denial of DEX to AC.

This is in part because of how it affects characters differently based on DEX score. Someone with 10-11 DEX is identically easy/hard to hit regardless of whether they saw you coming or not? Really?

Additionally, my new system involves a scaling defense based on your combat ability. Thematically, that would have to go away if DEX went away, which would be HUGE, but if I didn't do that it'd be kind of a weird thematic disconnect.

What I'm thinking of instead is having a "condition" of sorts (maybe called "off-guard" or something) where the attacker gets a flat bonus (maybe +2?) against you if you're "off-guard" against their attack.

Any thoughts? Thanks!

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

1 person marked this as a favorite.

I've recently decided to see what happens if I re-write most of Pathfinder from the ground up. Since I'm starting from scratch on almost everything, I have the opportunity to examine not only the "issues" that inspired me to attempt this in the first place, but also things that are probably okay but I now have room to change.

One such topic is the role of armor. Some systems (like Pathfinder and D&D) represent armor's effect on combat by having it simply reduce the chances of an enemy successfully landing a meaningful blow. This is somewhat backed up by a very brief look at Wikipedia, where I learned that (at least with some armors) enemies would respond to it by simply aiming for the joints or other weak spots rather than trying to punch through it. Thus, they're aiming for a smaller target: you have a higher AC.

Other systems (as well as a set of variant rules for Pathfinder in UC) have armor simply absorb some of the damage you would have taken from a blow. This seems to assume that an attacker would try to hit you in exactly the same manner as they would if you were unarmored, and the armor simply gets in the way. This idea goes contrary to what I learned above, but on the other hand, certain piercing weapons (such as especially thin swords) were developed for breaking chainmail; similarly, while plate armor was apparently nigh-impervious to slashing weapons and highly resistant to piercing weapons, apparently heavy blows still hurt and so people developed heavy hammers/polearms/maces to just beat you to death inside your plate armor. Additionally, flexible armors like chainmail, while unlikely to be cut, often simply converted slashing damage to bludgeoning, so you still got hurt.

Seems there's support for either method.

Part of me wants to go the direction of armor absorbing damage, and maybe even make combat a little more dynamic by having certain weapons (or types of weapons) reduce or bypass that DR for certain armors. Like, maybe rapiers and arrows face reduced resistance from chain, while certain heavy bludgeoning weapons are less affected by plate.

Additionally/alternatively, what if different types of armor granted different mixes of AC/DR? Like, maybe chain is mostly just DR because it just cushions/protects, while plate offers more deflection because a glancing blow can slide off of it?

And then of course that's just the "realism" side; there's also the "game" side. Which methods are more fun? Does watching damage types or having different effects for different armor add too much work to combat?

What are folks' thoughts on the role of armor in a d20 system?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

After our second TPK in Mummy's Mask, my group brought in replacement characters on the fly so we could finish our session. Because of the semi-rushed circumstance, the GM is allowing us to make tweaks to our builds before the next session.

Not knowing what to make, I reached for nostalgia: my first RPG character, the character for which I bought my first mini, translated from a 4E swordmage to a Pathfinder magus.

His name is Khaved, and he's a tiefling who highly values magic and intellect, preferring them over things he would call brutish. Please keep this in mind when making suggestions.

So here's what I originally cobbled together:

STR 12
DEX 18 (16+2)
CON 14
INT 16 (14+2)
WIS 10
CHA 06 (8-2)

Stats use a 20pt buy, and I went with my personal default of 16/14/14/12/10/8 because it's as close as a 20pt array can get to the Heroic NPC stat array of 15/14/13/12/10/8 (since that represents a "real" person in the game world). However, I'm open to the possibility of tweaking these numbers slightly.

I'm not interested in any of the magus archetypes, so no worries there.

Alternate racial traits include Prehensile Tail (because I'm not a sorcerer) and Scaled Skin (traded out non-fire resistances for +1 natural armor).

Character traits include Sphinx Riddler (campaign trait, don't even remember what it does, but it's related to intellectualism) and Clever Wordplay (to use INT for Diplomacy; very on-theme).

He's at 2nd level (where he started), with his first and only feat being Weapon Finesse. Currently uses a shortsword and a chain shirt.

Seems like the conventional wisdom assumes that 3rd level brings Dervish Dance; are there any other schools of thought for a DEX magus? (Partly because he's more of a Nethys guy than a Sarenrae guy, and the GM hasn't decided yet whether he'd let me apply it to a longsword instead.)

Should I tweak STR up to 13 so I can take Power Attack later? Should I go non-Dervish so I can use an actual light weapon and take Piranha Strike? What should I be building toward in the future?

All guidance appreciated, thanks!

This morning passed like any other morning in Woodhaven; you woke up, had some breakfast, maybe prepared spells, and went about your daily business. Noontime came and went, you hit up the Befuddled Bugbear for a sandwich and a drink, chatted with the locals for a while, and went back to the daily grind.

Then you heard something like a clap of thunder, followed by another similar rumble. Or maybe two more? It was hard to tell. Running out into the street, you saw chaos. Somewhere several blocks away, smoke was beginning to rise into the air. Screams could be heard, first from a distance but quickly spreading.

No sooner have you begun to wrap your head around the town's sudden frenzy than you notice Guard Captain Arriaga—the dwarven woman who leads the town guard and manages most of Woodhaven's daily affairs—walking briskly and pointedly toward you.

"You lot, there!" she says, pointing at you and a few other bystanders. "I've got a job for you. Something hit the city; I'm thinking at least two impacts. We don't know yet if it's natural or some kind of attack, but I've got to get the citizens under control before panic takes too strong a hold. I'm short-staffed as it is, and I still need someone to go check on the mayor at his estate. Since you seem to be the only non-guards who don't need immediate wrangling, I'm drafting the lot of you for the task. Here."

She pulls a folded piece of paper from her pocket and hands it to one of you.

"Give that to the man stationed at the north gate, and he'll give you a supply pack, in case you run into trouble. Exit through that gate and follow the footpath northeast. The mayor's house is just on the other side of the first hill; you can't miss it. Verify his status, secure the estate if need be, then report back to me. Now move!"

With that, she hustles in the direction of the screams and begins barking orders at the guards who have begun arriving in the area.

Discussion thread is up! :D

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Prerequisite: Fighter level 11th
Benefit: When you drink a potion of fox's cunning, you can choose to replace its effects with the following:
You become a casting machine—smarter, fiercer, and more skilled in spellcasting. Your mindset changes so that you relish arcane magic and you can't use weapons (except rays), even if you're proficient with them.
You gain a +6 enhancement bonus to Intelligence (though you gain no additional skill ranks or languages from this increase), a +5 competence bonus to Will saving throughs, and the effects of darkvision, mirror image and overland flight. You gain the following spell-like abilities, each usable once, using your fighter level as your caster level and your (boosted) Intelligence modifier to determine saving throw DCs: magic missile, true strike, touch of fatigue, blindness/deafness, glitterdust, scorching ray, dispel magic, hold person, stinking cloud, black tentacles, dimension door, enervation, cloudkill, dominate person, and baleful polymorph. When you reach fighter level 14th, add plane shift and finger of death to this list. At fighter level 16th, add horrid wilting. At fighter level 18th, add dominate monster.
Your base attack bonus becomes equal to half your character level, you lose your armor and shield bonuses to AC, and your current and maximum hit points are reduced by 2 per character level.
The effects of this feat last for 1 round per character level. You may use this feat once per day at fighter level 11th, twice per day at fighter level 13th, and three times per day at fighter level 15th.


Whaddya think, balanced?

Hi folks,

I have an idea for a homebrew Pathfinder campaign. I have the beginning and the overall premise/background, but I'm having trouble mentally fleshing it out. So what I'd like to do is just start it up and let the action drive the creation of the next step. Little bit risky, as it's always possible that it could get big and complicated enough to require retcons or even just completely implode. But hopefully, it will be a fun and (for me) informative experience. :)

If you're still interested while knowing the above, here are the parameters you need to know if you want to play in this campaign:

    PCs begin at 2nd level, with 1,000gp for starting gear.
    Everyone uses the Heroic NPC stat array of 15/14/13/12/10/8.
    Max HP for 1st level, average (rounded up) for each level thereafter (i.e., d10 is 6HP, d6 is 4HP, etc).
    No gunslingers, summoners, or alchemists.
    No item creation feats except Scribe Scroll or Brew Potion, but even for those I make no promises regarding how much downtime you'll have for your scribing and brewing.
    Core races only.
    No evil PCs.
    No traits. Instead, pick one save to get a +1 bonus and one skill to make a class skill. Feel free to swap one of those options for a second helping of the other (including the possibility of boosting the same save twice).
    PCs must be the kinds of people who would get involved upon seeing an emergency happen, but feel free to get creative as to why.
    Most stuff from the core hardback line is probably fine, but nothing setting-specific (except the CRB deities) and no 3.5 or 3PP stuff.
    If your build centers around something that you'd feel cheated if it got vetoed down the line, ask about it upfront. I reserve the right to change my mind if something causes unforeseen issues.
    Make sure you check out the houserules below!
    Please only submit if you're confident that you can with reasonable consistency post at least once each day.

I *think* that's everything. If you're interested in playing, then post a reply under a character alias, including a little idea of who the character is and what they're doing in a smallish rural town that I'll call... um... Woodhaven. Yeah, Woodhaven. Sounds good. :)




For the most part, there's no such thing as a full-attack. Instead of gaining more attacks from a high Base Attack Bonus, you gain more damage on your existing single attack. As a standard action (the "Attack" action), you make a single attack. When your Base Attack Bonus reaches +6, your standard attack (but not things like Attacks of Opportunity or special attacks like Spring Attack) deals additional damage. Roll your weapon damage dice and add your Strength-based damage, then add this total to your normal damage to get your final damage total. At BAB +11 and BAB +16, your damage further increases in the same way. For example, if you were wielding a greatsword (2d6 damage), had 18 STR (bonus +4, damage +6 due to being a two-handed weapon), and attacked with BAB +11, your attack would deal 6d6+18 damage. Any additional damage (from weapon enhancements, feats, etc) is then added to the total a single time.

If you have Two-Weapon Fighting, Rapid Shot, or Flurry of Blows; your standard attack action lets you perform two attacks (with appropriate penalties as defined by these abilities), and each deals damage according to the above progression. Strength-based damage is NOT halved for your off-hand weapon.

If you have two claw attacks, you can attack with both as a standard attack action. Certain monsters can attack with more natural weapons (possibly as a full-round action, depending on the monster). Natural attacks never get increased damage from a high BAB.

Class abilities or feats that specify needing a full-round action (such as Spring Attack or Whirlwind Attack) still require a full-round action; they are not reduced to a standard action. However, if an element of that action emulates a full-attack (such as the attacks granted by Spell Combat), the ability grants a single attack with damage that increases with BAB instead of multiple attacks.


Arcane Armor Training/Arcane Armor Mastery/Arcane Strike: These feats do not require swift actions to activate. They're simply always in effect.

Double Slice: This feat does not exist, as it is not needed due to other houserules.

Improved Two-Weapon Fighting: This feat does not exist, nor do any feats which list it as a prerequisite.

Power Attack: The damage gained from this feat does not change based on whether your attack is two-handed, an off-hand, etc. It is always +2 damage for –1 attack (scaling with BAB as written).

Vital Strike: This feat does not exist, nor do any feats which list it as a prerequisite.

Weapon Finesse: This feat also applies to the quarterstaff.

Whirlwind Attack: This feat does not include Combat Expertise as a prerequisite.


Being on fire: In addition to the normal 1d6 fire damage taken each round when you're on fire, you also take 1 point of Constitution damage. If you take no fire damage from being on fire (such as through magical protections or other resistances), you also do not take the CON damage.
This only applies to actually being on fire, not special fire effects that simply last more than 1 round. For instance, a direct hit from a flask of alchemist's fire deals 1d6 fire damage for two rounds in a row, but does not deal any CON damage.

Falling: For every 5 points of lethal falling damage taken from a fall, you also take 1 point of Dexterity damage.

Smashing into stuff: If you get slammed into a wall, smashed through a table, etc; you take damage equal to the unarmed strike damage of the guy who threw you into said obstacle, plus additional damage equal to the obstacle's hardness. This damage might increase or decrease based on the specific obstacle, or if atypical means are used to toss you into an obstacle. How do you accomplish this yourself? A bull rush or reposition that involves moving the target at least 10 feet will do it. Or, if you maintain a grapple, you can select (instead of one of the normal options) to move the victim at least 10ft into an obstacle within your reach.


Base Attack Bonus: Nothing requires a Base Attack Bonus of +1. If something says it requires BAB +1, ignore that requirement. Whether it's a feat like Exotic Weapon Proficiency with a prerequisite of BAB +1, or the rule stating that you can draw a weapon on the move once you have BAB +1, that requirement is waived.

Swift and immediate actions: These action types are completely separate. Instead of an immediate action costing you your next swift action, you simply get one of each action type each round.

Grand Lodge ** RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

I know we talk a lot about trying to reduce table variation, but sometimes it's a built-in part of the ruleset. As such, sometimes it's good for a player to find ways to work with table variation instead of chafing against it.

Case in point: I've been kicking around the idea of making an illusionist. It would be a fun use of my boon allowing a Thassilonian specialist, it would be unique because most folks locally don't play illusionists, and there's potential room for creativity/humor/fun.

Of course, part of the reason I don't see a lot of illusionists running around is probably because of all the table variation on how illusions and disbelief work.

And that's okay. :)

So I was thinking, how could I work with my GM if I'm going to be bringing the disbelief rules into every session? I came up with an idea, and I'd like feedback on it from the PFS community.


Before the session starts, I approach the GM. I say something along the lines of: "Hi! I'm playing an illusionist. I know everybody runs illusions and disbelief a little differently, so I wanted to get an idea of how you run them at your table before we start. After all, my character would know how his spells work, so it's best if I do too. Here:"

I then hand him a card I will have prepared. It's divided into three boxes, each labeled with a quote from the illusion rules:
Box 1: "Creatures encountering an illusion usually do not receive saving throws to recognize it as illusory..."
Box 2: "...until they study it carefully or interact with it in some fashion."
Box 3: "A character faced with proof that an illusion isn't real needs no saving throw."

Upon handing him the card, I explain: "If you could jot down a basic example of each of those three situations from the illusion rules, then I wouldn't need to pester you with questions during the game. I'll know what to aim for and what to avoid, without having to waste table time asking about every single illusion I cast. Sound good?"

Lots of smiling and friendly tone, of course. :)


So what does everyone think? Is that a reasonable, concise way of getting enough of an idea of a GM's interpretation of illusions to make for a smoother game? Does it need work? Any feedback?


Scarab Sages

Seeking some advice.
This profile is my 2nd-level PFS cleric. The concept is a bit of a cerebral type, interested in knowledge and learning and secrets and such. Likes to find stuff out.

He's more of a reader/learner than a fighter. But of course, combat is inevitable. The plan is to focus on spellcasting rather than weapons, which will be fine later, but right now I get 3 non-domain spells per day.

With a wizard or sorcerer, I could be spamming ray of frost or daze or something. But I get no such cantrips as a cleric. I could have taken one of the domains that gives you a laserbeam 3+WIS/day, but I didn't.

So that leaves me with a crossbow. :/

Here's a rundown of the character at the moment:

STR 09 (11-2)
DEX 14 (12+2)
CON 12
INT 14
WIS 18 (16+2)
CHA 10

Domains: Knowledge (Memory), Trickery
Traits: Seeker, Birthmark
Feats: Toughness

My ultimate issue here is figuring out what to spend my actions on in combat at low levels. Later I'll be casting SoS spells (hold person, sound burst, plane shift, etc) all day, but what about for right now?

Obviously, I'm not hitting anything with my crossbow. I could stand behind people and spam guidance, but that's gonna get boring a couple levels in. I could get a wand/some scrolls of bless, but that really only gives me something to do on round 1. Maybe run around buffing people with a wand of shield of faith? By the time people have their rings, I won't be needing a fallback plan as much, so maybe that would work? Or are there some interesting (perhaps alchemical?) items I could be using? Not counting situational stuff like anti-invisibility measures or whatever, I'm looking for bread-and-butter actions.


Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Continuing what I started with Swordsmanship and Hammer Mastery, here's a line of feats for fighters who specialize in piercing weapons, whether rapiers, spears, picks, or whatever else. Let me know what you think!

Piercer (Combat)
When you take this feat, choose a manufactured piercing melee weapon for which you have Weapon Focus. This feat's effects only apply to the chosen weapon.
Prerequisites: Weapon Focus, fighter level 2nd
Benefit: Whenever you score a critical hit with your chosen weapon, your strike wounds the target, dealing 1 point of bleed damage for a number of rounds equal to half your fighter level. Multiple critical hits against the same creature do not increase the bleed damage.

Improved Piercer (Combat)
Prerequisites: Piercer, fighter level 5th
Benefit: Whenever you score a critical hit with your chosen weapon, you may twist your weapon as a swift action. If you do, the target takes 1d4 Dexterity damage. This is in addition to the bleed damage inflicted by the Piercer feat.

Greater Piercer (Combat)
Prerequisites: Improved Piercer, fighter level 10th
Benefit: The bleed damage from your Piercer feat now functions as the wounding weapon special ability; it applies to each hit, multiple hits increase the amound of bleed damage, and it lasts until stopped instead of for a fixed duration. Additionally, the Dexterity damage dealt by Improved Piercer increases to 1d6.

Elder Piercer (Combat)
Prerequisites: Greater Piercer, fighter level 14th
Benefit: The Dexterity damage dealt by your Improved Piercer feat increases to 2d4. Alternatively, you may choose to deal 1d6 Constitution damage instead. This choice is made each time you use this feat.

Nail Down (Combat)
Prerequisites: Improved Piercer, fighter level 9th
Benefit: As a standard action, you may attempt to impale your opponent and pin him to the floor or wall. Make an attack with your chosen weapon. If the attack hits, you deal damage normally and also get to hamper your opponent. If the target is standing, you may pierce his leg. If he is prone, legless, or next to a wall, you may instead choose to pierce his torso.
If you pierce his leg, he cannot move from his space. He is considered grappled, except that he may use both hands freely. He must succeed at a grapple check against you as a standard action to free himself, and the attempt causes him to take 2d6 damage.
If you pierce his torso, he is grappled and cannot move from his space. Any strenuous action he attempts (such as attacking or casting a spell) results in 1 point of Constitution damage. Freeing himself requires a successful grapple check as a standard action, and the attempt results in 1d4 Constitution damage.
In order to use this feat, you must hold your weapon in place with both hands, preventing most other actions you might wish to perform. Holding the weapon in place with only one hand reduces the DC to escape by 5. You may remove the weapon (freeing the opponent without further harm) as a move action.
You may only use this feat against a creature of your size or smaller.

Run Through (Combat)
Prerequisites: Elder Piercer, fighter level 18th
Benefit: As a full-round action, you may attempt to slay your opponent by putting your chosen weapon through a vital spot. If you succeed on a touch attack, you run him through and he must make a Fortitude save (DC 10 + half your fighter level + your Dexterity modifier) or be slain. On a successful save, the target instead takes 2d4 points of Constitution damage. This ability only works against living creatures with discernable anatomy. You may use this ability once per day at fighter level 18th, twice per day at 19th, and three times per day at 20th.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

3 people marked this as a favorite.

In a vein similar to my Swordsmanship feats, here's some ways for a fighter who specializes in things like hammers (or clubs, etc) to be fantastic.

Hammer Mastery (Combat)
You are well-trained in the use of heavy bludgeoning weapons. Select a non-light bludgeoning weapon other than a shield for which you have selected the Weapon Focus feat. This feat only applies to that weapon.
Prerequisites: Weapon Focus, Fighter level 2nd
Benefit: Your blows are so fierce that even a glancing blow can rattle an enemy inside his armor. Attacks with your chosen weapon ignore an amount of the target's armor bonus to AC equal to half your fighter level.

Improved Hammer Mastery (Combat)
Your heavy hammerfalls are too fierce to be stopped by mere metal.
Prerequisites: Hammer Mastery, Fighter level 5th
Benefit: Whenever you make an attack with your chosen weapon and miss by 5 or less, you smash through the target's defenses; if the target is wielding a shield, roll damage as though your attack had hit and apply it to the target's shield (applying hardness as normal). If the target is not using a shield, instead apply this damage to their armor. If the target is using neither armor nor shield, this feat has no effect.

Hammer Arc (Combat)
The momentum of your mighty swings can crash through multiple opponents.
Prerequisites: Improved Hammer Mastery, Fighter level 7th
Benefit: You can swing your chosen weapon in an arc, striking at all enemies in its path. When you use this feat, choose three squares within your reach; each chosen square must border at least one other selected square (not counting diagonals). As a standard action, you can make one attack against each enemy in those squares, rolling separately for each target. At fighter level 13th, 16th, and 19th, increase the number of squares you can select by 1.

Hammer Slam (Combat)
The weight of your blows sends enemies staggering back.
Prerequisites: Improved Hammer Mastery, Fighter level 9th
Benefit: Whenever an attack with your chosen weapon either scores a critical hit or rolls maximum damage on the weapon damage dice, you can choose to knock the target back. The target is subjected to a bull rush maneuver, treating your critical confirmation roll (or attack roll, if the triggering attack was not a critical hit) as your combat maneuver check. This ability does not provoke attacks of opportunity, nor does it require its own action. Successfully pushing a foe with this ability does not allow you to follow them as a normal bull rush would.

Heavy Swat (Combat)
Prerequisites: Hammer Slam, Fighter level level 12th
Benefit: Whenever you push a foe at least 10 feet with your Hammer Slam feat, that foe is also knocked prone.

Rattle the Cage (Combat)
Prerequisites: Heavy Swat, Fighter level 16th
Benefit: Whenever you knock an enemy prone with Heavy Swat, that creature is stunned for 1 round.

Beat the Bolt (Combat)
Prerequisites: Heavy Swat, Fighter level 14th
Benefit: You can deflect magic with a swing of your hammer. As a readied action, you can swing your selected weapon at a spell, spell-like ability or supernatural ability that targets you or includes you in its area. This functions much like using dispel magic to counterspell, using your fighter level as your caster level for the dispel check. This check also gains your bonus from Weapon Focus and (if applicable) Greater Weapon Focus, as well as any enhancement bonus your weapon possesses. This even works against magical effects that normally cannot be counterspelled. If successful, you swat the magic away, leaving you unaffected. In the case of an area effect, your space is no longer considered part of the area.
Should your dispel check result in a natural 20, a targeted effect is sent back at its caster, much like a spell turning effect.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

8 people marked this as a favorite.

Came up with a line of fighter-only feats that allow those who specialize in swords to be "fantastic" without being magical. Curious to know what people think. :)

Swordsmanship (Combat)
You are trained in the way of the sword. When you take this feat, you must select a swordlike slashing weapon (for which you must have already selected Weapon Focus) for this feat to apply to.
Prerequisites: Weapon Focus in a swordlike slashing weapon, fighter level 2nd
Benefit: Damage rolls with your selected weapon ignore an amount of damage reduction equal to half your fighter level. This ability only applies to DR based on damage type (such as DR/piercing). If your target is immune to slashing damage, they are instead treated as having DR 15/bludgeoning or piercing, and you then apply this feat's effects against that DR.

Improved Swordsmanship (Combat)
Prerequisites: Swordsmanship, fighter level 5th
Benefit: Your Swordsmanship feat also applies to DR/magic, DR/cold iron, and DR/silver.

Greater Swordsmanship (Combat)
Prerequisites: Swordsmanship, Improved Swordsmanship, fighter level 9th
Benefit: Your Swordsmanship feat also applies to all material-based DR as well as to hardness. Additionally, attacks with your selected weapon deal half damage to incorporeal creatures, or full damage if using a magic weapon.

Elder Swordsmanship (Combat)
Prerequisites: Swordsmanship, Improved Swordsmanship, Greater Swordsmanship, fighter level 15th
Benefit: Your Swordsmanship feat also applies to alignment-based DR if it matches your alignment. For instance, if you are lawful good, your Swordsmanship applies to DR/lawful, DR/good, and DR/lawful and good. Additionally, when you reach fighter level 20th, you Swordsmanship also applies to DR/— and DR/epic.

Swordsman's Defense (Combat)
Prerequisites: Swordsmanship, fighter level 5th
Benefit: You may use your selected blade to deflect ranged weapons. This functions like the Deflect Arrows feat, except that you do not need a free hand but do need to be wielding your selected blade. Beginning at fighter level 8th, you may deflect additional attacks each round by spending an attack of opportunity for each deflection after the first.

Improved Swordsman's Defense (Combat)
Prerequisites: Swordsmanship, Swordsman's Defense, fighter level 10th
Benefit: Your Swordsman's Defense feat no longer suffers restrictions against magical or natural attacks. At fighter level 14th, it also no longer suffers the restrictions against unusually massive weapons.

Greater Swordsman's Defense (Combat)
Your skill with the sword is so great that you can even cut energy.
Prerequisites: Swordsmanship, Swordsman's Defense, Improved Swordsman's Defense, fighter level 14th
Benefit: Whenever you are within the area of a spell or effect that deals hit point damage (such as a breath weapon, channeled energy, a fireball spell, etc), you may spend an immediate action to cut through the effect. Your space is treated as a solid obstacle for determining the area of the spell or effect. If the spell or effect is a spread or would otherwise be able to fill the space behind an obstacle, it is instead treated as a burst for the purposes of determining the result of this feat. You must be wielding your selected blade to use this feat.

Mystic Blade (Combat)
Your swordsmanship is so keen that you can cut magic.
Prerequisites: Swordsmanship, Greater Swordsman's Defense, fighter level 15th
Benefit: You can attempt to dispel an ongoing spell effect with a swing of your blade. As a standard action, make a melee touch attack with your selected blade against a creature, object or space where a magical effect (whether spell, spell-like or supernatural) is active. If successful, make a dispel check (per dispel magic) using your fighter level as your caster level. Alternatively, any time you score a critical hit with your selected blade against a creature under an active magical effect, you can make the dispel check without spending an action.
This is an extraordinary ability.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

So there's this guy who's suddenly running around in various forums, starting and/or necro-ing threads on a given topic, telling everyone that X sucks, and then disappearing to let the arguments flow. Seems almost like he's crusading against anyone who prefers X, and it's getting a little tiresome. I think he's started/necro'd something like 4-5 threads on the same topic now, and I don't *think* he's replied back to any of them; he just announces who sucks and then disappears. Either he just wants to spread his own True Roleplayer gospel without having actual discussions, or he's deliberately trying to start arguments. Can't really tell which.

How should situations like this be handled by the community? Is it acceptable to make/revive multiple threads on the same topic across multiple forums? If not, what's the appropriate flag? Breaks Other Guidelines? I feel like none of the flagging options really communicate "the reason this post is a problem is because it's one of many that the author is putting up all over the forums". What's the right course of action?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

What are all the feats related to the Aldori Dueling Sword? I ask because I had a goofy idea: being an Ustalavic Duelist (fighter archetype), taking a bunch of Aldori feats, then going into the (Core) Duelist prestige class. Talk about some sword mastery, eh?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

I recently got a small handful of cash as a result of selling some old stuff to a used book store, and immediately thought "Cool! Maybe I can pick up the PDFs of Inner Sea Combat and Inner Sea Gods!"

Then I looked, and there's this huge price gap between them. I had thought that they were comparable hardcover books. Is one of them massively smaller than the other or something? Why the price differential?

(Also, any suggestions on the better one to buy, since apparently I only get to have one?)

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Often, when trying to decide whether to invest more or less into a PC's attacks or armor class, I reference the monster stats by CR chart in the Bestiary. I can look at the CR that matches my level, compare the sample attack/AC to mine, and see what rolls we need to hit each other, and then decide if any of those rolls are higher or lower than I want/need for that particular character.

However, I just noticed that the chart doesn't contain values for typical monster CMB/CMD. It would be nice to have that information, so a player knows how much to invest in things like maneuvers or Acrobatics (for tumbling), or to invest in resisting nasty maneuvers (like getting swallowed whole).

Anyone have an idea of typical monster CMB/CMD by CR?


Grand Lodge

Hey folks,

I have a kitsune bard (arcane duelist archetype) in PFS, which I always play alongside my wife's kitsune magus. Go go twin magical rapier-wielding kitsune!

Anyway, we just hit 5th level, and I'm trying to decide on my feat.

I took Weapon Finesse at 1st (for obvious reasons), got Arcane Strike as a bonus feat from my archetype, took Precise Strike at 3rd (as did my wife's character, since we always play these two together), and at 7th we're looking at Outflank.

We're both DEX-based rapier wielders, with me using my obscene Acrobatics skill to set up flanks for Precise Strike.

So what would be a good option for my 5th-level feat? My first thought was Great Fortitude, since bards don't get a good Fort save. Other possibilities I've thought of are Combat Reflexes, Quick Draw, or Improved Initiative.


Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

13 people marked this as FAQ candidate. 1 person marked this as a favorite.

Casters get bonus spells based on their casting stat.

They often wear stat-boosting headbands for more bonus slots.

If my cleric had 18 WIS and is wearing a +2 headband for a total of 20 WIS, then he has two bonus 1st-level spells prepared.

If he walks into an anti-magic field (or just takes the headband off), his WIS drops back down to 18, and he can no longer have that many spells prepared.

What happens when a prepared caster loses an ability bonus that was granting him a bonus spell slot?

Feels like he should lose a prepared spell, but which one? Were we supposed to be notating which spells were prepared with bonus slots?

Please click the FAQ button, thanks!

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

22 people marked this as FAQ candidate. 1 person marked this as a favorite.

Items like the headband of inspired wisdom grant a bonus to an ability score. Each such item includes this line:

Headband of inspired wisdom wrote:
Treat this as a temporary ability bonus for the first 24 hours the headband is worn.

What does it mean for an ability bonus to be treated as temporary?

Well, according to this FAQ, temporary ability bonuses do everything that permanent ability bonuses do.

This leaves us with a question:
What is the difference in functionality between the first 24 hours of wearing a stat-boosting item, and the time thereafter?

Anyone who can't point to an answer, please click the FAQ button. Thanks!

Grand Lodge ** RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

If this is already answered somewhere, I've overlooked it. Feel free to direct me to any existing info.

Anyway, my Eldritch Knight is playing through Eyes of the Ten and has hit 13th level, gaining access to 6th-level spells. Since he often wants to buff before going into melee, I was thinking of picking up contingency so that I can have it set up to give me heroism when I cast shield, thereby streamlining the buffing process.

Then I looked at the duration for contingency, and lo and behold, it's actually 24 hours per level! So once I cast it, I can have a buffing package ready for nearly two weeks. Neat!

So what I'm ultimately wondering is, can a spell with that long of a duration be "pre-cast"? I mean, if he were a real person using that spell, he'd only be prepping/casting it once every 10-12 days (since you can't have multiples running at once), so whenever he gets called to a mission briefing, there's only like a 10% chance (or less) that that's the day he prepped it.

So is there any chance (even if it's a roll witnessed by the GM to see which day it is) of having such a long-term spell already be cast? Or for PFS do we need to assume that you have absolutely nothing running at the start of the scenario, so contingency and its partner spell need to use up your at-the-table slots (making contingency pretty worthless unless multi-day travel is happening in the scenario)?

I thought about just asking my EotT GM what he thought, but since there might be other long-term spells that I'm not aware of, I thought maybe the topic was worth investigating as a community. :)

Grand Lodge

This EK has hit retirement levels in PFS, and has started playing through the "Eyes of the Ten" retirement arc. I've played parts 1 and 2, so there are 2 sessions left. I've got about 12,000gp or so to spend, and I've also now made it to 13th level. Here's a rundown of my current situation, as best I can remember it:

Divination (Foresight), opposition schools are Necromancy and Illusion
Stats (including items):

STR 20
DEX 18
CON 14
INT 20
WIS 10
CHA 07

Traits: Reactionary, World Traveler (Diplomacy), Magical Knack, Fate's Favored.

Feats: Toughness, Dodge, Improved Initiative, Weapon Focus (longsword), Spell Focus (conjuration), Arcane Armor Training, Empower Spell, Arcane Strike, Additional Traits, Arcane Armor Mastery, Weapon Specialization (longsword), Improved Critical (longsword)

Headband INT +4
Belt of STR/DEX/CON +2
Jingasa of the fortunate soldier
Cloak of Resistance +2
+4 mithral breastplate
Amulet of Natural Armor +3
Ring of Protection +2
Dusty rose prism ioun stone for +1 AC (insight)
Ioun stone for +1 attack (competence)
Ioun stone for +1 to saves (competence)
Wayfinder + Clear spindle ioun stone (immune to mind control ala PfE)
Gloves of Reconnaissance
Adamantine longsword
Lesser Extend Rod
2x Pearl of Power I
3x Snapleaf

That's all I can remember. Note the lack of a magic weapon, because I use an Extended greater magic weapon to keep my adamantine longsword at +3 for 24 hours a day. I also extend a darkvision all day, and save the third Extend for when I decide to cast heroism, making it last 4 hours.

I also don't have a shield; typically, if it looks like I'll be fighting in melee, I cast shield first, taking my AC to 37 total.

Now, throughout my first 11 levels of play, the key to this EK has been versatility: since table make-ups are random, it's nice to be able to slide into whichever of the tank, caster, or Knowledge roles happens to be missing. However, I'm now planning on another two sessions with a single group. With that in mind, I feel like I should maybe specialize a little more...?

There's a gunslinger/inquisitor (awesome damage from range, Sense Motive, Survival), a zen archer (awesome damage from range), a druid (casting focused, plus celestial tiger companion), and a wizard (uber damage from range via crossblooded dip and CL boosts, and most Knowledge skills about 7-12 points higher than mine).

As you may have noticed, I'm a mostly-CRB generalist in a stable party of expansion-reliant specialists. This means most of the time, my main contributions have been to supply additional slots of group buffs (like communal resist energy).

If I want to just do damage, I have to spend a round getting into melee (plus either a single attack or a shield, unless I had to double move), during which time the three DPR machines who don't have to move first have been able to spew out around 70-100 damage apiece with full-attacks or spells. On the other hand, my spell save DCs are only so-so, since I don't have the 26 INT that a devoted caster would have.

Hitting 13th level now, I have some options.

First, I could take Power Attack, taking my usual melee damage from +15 to +24. That seems like it could help, but I'll also take -3 to hit, taking me from +20 to +17. At 13th level, that feels a bit low. Heroism helps, but that's not a sure thing.

I guess I could take maybe a level of barbarian instead of EK at 13th, so that when I do attack in melee I can rage for an extra +2 attack and +3 damage. With Power Attack, this would put me at +19 (or +21 if I have heroism up) for 1d8+27. Seems nice, but that also means I don't get 6th-level spells this level. Or rather, I don't get my one 6th-level spell.

Alternatively, I could just say "Screw it, I'm a wizard" and take Persistent Spell, helping to make up for low-ish DCs on some key spells.

Or maybe there's some other option, via spell selections, feat selection, or spending 12k gold?

Any advice welcome, thanks!

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

I'm going to be attending GenCon for the first time ever this August. When I tried to get a hotel, it was a nightmare: I had to be ready and waiting the second they opened up for reservations, and even then I was only able to nab a room 7 miles out.

Event regristration opens on Sunday, as I recall. Can any GenCon veterans tell me whether that's going to be the same kind of mad dash? Do I need to pore through the event catalogue, figure out exactly what I'm submitting, and copy-paste for the fastest submission I can muster? Or is that one a little less crazy than hotel registration? Anything I should be aware of? Any surprises I might encounter as a newbie that I should be ready for?

All guidance appreciated, thanks!

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

So my Mummy's Mask group all died like 3 rooms in. We're planning to start from the beginning with fresh PCs. Originally I'd thought of doing a fighty cleric for divine casting and more melee power (we were a bit lacking in both departments the first time around). However, this is the current lineup for my comrades:

Dawnflower Dervish

Two issues: melee is crowded enough as it is, and there are no full casters to be seen.

Earlier today I was thinking of trying a Mystic Theurge, but I've been giving some thought to someone's suggestion of playing a witch. Seems they have a mix of traditionally arcane and divine spells on their list, I have full casting progression, plus hexes.

Sounds great!

But I've never played one. I know they have a reputation for Misfortune and Slumber "ruining everyone's fun", and I don't wanna be a jerk, but it does seem like they would be a good support character by making things easier for my four fighty friends via debuffs, healing, utility, etc.

So what are the basics of playing a witch? Aside from the infamous slumber and misfortune (and prehensile hair, which is a little too weird for my taste), what are good hexes? How should I view myself and my role as a witch? What would be helpful patrons for my party situation?

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

So, I recently started up a game of Mummy's Mask, but we all died about three rooms in.

So since the plot hadn't even gotten going yet, we're basically just rebooting with a fresh party and starting over from the beginning. I volunteered to play some sort of divine melee character.

Here's the rest of the party as I'm aware of it thus far:

Barbarian (invulnerable rager/urban), probably human
Rogue (prolly our "trap guy", but I have no further details)
Dawnflower Dervish bard
[Undecided - me]

As you can see, we've got 1 dedicated melee, 1 half-melee/half-skills, and 1 half-melee/half-arcane.

Add me into the mix and we'll have plenty of melee plus (at least) half divine. That puts us fairly well balanced before even accounting for the 5th player.

With that in mind, I'm having trouble deciding. For starters, what class? There's like a bajillion ways to get (at least) 3/4 BAB on a divine caster. However, overall I'm leaning toward either cleric or warpriest. Cleric would mean fully-leveled divine spellcasting (and unless the 5th player goes with a wizard or something, that'll be the only full-caster we have), and would also offer channeling which would help out with healing during the poverty-stricken 1st level before we can get a CLW wand, even though the value of channeling drops off after a while. On the downside, wanting to do melee means I need a reasonable weapon proficiency, which either severely limits my deity choices or requires spending a precious feat (and EWP has a +1 BAB prereq, too). Additionally, 3/4 BAB means a reliance on first-round buff spells to keep up my to-hit.

On the other hand, warpriest gets (effectively) full BAB, all martial weapons regardless of deity, bonus feats, and (starting at 2nd) free Quickened buffs. Sounds great! Except I get reduced spellcasting; effectively a half-caster. The idea of a party with potentially no full casters at all is kinda scary. Also, I find it very possible warpriests will get nerfed once the ACG actually comes out, and making adjustments would be a pain. Finally, clerics get some pretty sweet domain powers, and lots of the warpriest blessings aren't nearly as cool.

Additionally, what about deity choice? Pharasma's on-theme for the AP, but her favored weapon is a dagger. On the other hand, the Souls subdomain (basically ghost touch on demand) could be REALLY handy in an AP like this (or so I'm guessing). Sarenrae is also on-theme, has a decent weapon (scimitar), and I can't say I would mind having the Fire and Healing domains (Fire becomes even more appealing if we have no full arcane caster). On the other hand, do we want two Sarenites on the team? Would we step on each other's toes? Another thought is Shizuru; being a Tien deity, that's a good opportunity for the Foreigner (or whatever it's called) campaign trait (we're all required to have a campaign trait), plus he has the katana as his favored weapon. He also has a couple of pretty solid domains/subdomains.

For that matter, what domains do I even really want? Something with overland flight as a domain spell would be awesome, but there's only a couple (I forget which ones) and I don't know if they're worthwhile up to that point. Things like Honor and Liberation have great 1st-level powers, Heroism has a fantastic 8th-level power... Gah! So many options!


1 to 50 of 379 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | next > last >>

©2002–2015 Paizo Inc.®. Need help? Email or call 425-250-0800 during our business hours: Monday–Friday, 10 AM–5 PM Pacific Time. View our privacy policy. Paizo Inc., Paizo, the Paizo golem logo, Pathfinder, the Pathfinder logo, Pathfinder Society, GameMastery, and Planet Stories are registered trademarks of Paizo Inc., and Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Pathfinder Adventure Path, Pathfinder Adventure Card Game, Pathfinder Player Companion, Pathfinder Modules, Pathfinder Tales, Pathfinder Battles, Pathfinder Online, PaizoCon, RPG Superstar, The Golem's Got It, Titanic Games, the Titanic logo, and the Planet Stories planet logo are trademarks of Paizo Inc. Dungeons & Dragons, Dragon, Dungeon, and Polyhedron are registered trademarks of Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and have been used by Paizo Inc. under license. Most product names are trademarks owned or used under license by the companies that publish those products; use of such names without mention of trademark status should not be construed as a challenge to such status.