|Jiggy RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32|
Sloppy =/= not the rule.
Maybe they knew and accepted all the differences between what they picked and what they left behind, maybe they didn't. But that doesn't change that they picked what they picked and left behind what they left behind.
In the quote you provided, it states right out in the open that the results of that method aren't quite going to be the same as the "real" 3.5 rules. They couldn't have not known there would be differences. So are you just saying they knew about other differences, but not the difference of how carrying capacity interacts with it? How do you know which differences they knew about and which ones they didn't? Or do you think they managed to read a variant rule that announces its own imperfect results without realizing there would be any differences at all?