Paizo Top Nav Branding
  • Hello, Guest! |
  • Sign In |
  • My Account |
  • Shopping Cart |
  • Help/FAQ
About Paizo Messageboards News Paizo Blog Help/FAQ

GarnathFrostmantle's page

FullStar Pathfinder Society GM. 343 posts (709 including aliases). 4 reviews. No lists. 1 wishlist. 1 Pathfinder Society character. 1 alias.


1 to 50 of 343 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | next > last >>
Grand Lodge

No problem. Never took it as argumentative!

Looking at the gunslinger this week.

Grand Lodge

@GM_Solspiral - As I mention in my review, it's just my POV. As a review who received a free copy, I fulfilled my obligation.
1. Layout. Two columns is fine. It was the paragraph, dead space, paragraph, dead space. Every publisher has their style. I don't like this one. As i mention it's just my taste.

Dodge This: does not state that you need to have Call the Firing Line as a prerequisite. ...EDIT: nor does it list Group Fire which would have been also acceptable.

My review starts with stating the core feat is Group Fire which a couple of feats build off that. I like it and wanted to point out this is where you start. I do not make mention of anything being out of order, except the grey box for the Volley Fire rules or condition. I didn't like that it is at end of the book. I felt it should have been the very first thing. Again personal opinion.

As far the location of the VF feat, some people don't use a third party site for their information. My table doesn't use laptops or hyperweb at the table. A simple hyper link or or mention in the OGL I think would have cleared up my opinion.

This book is good for GMs as we all have stated, and Orc bandits will surely use some of these feats in a future game.

Grand Lodge

Raw review posted.

Grand Lodge

I'll step in. I don't have anything from your company yet, and I am more than willing to review.

Grand Lodge

The history is fine. What is lacking is what this adventure is going to do for my PCs, without giving away the spoilers, of course.

From what I can make out (correct me if i am wrong) is that god was born, god went crazy, god caused destruction.
Current Day: You play a PC in a world were evil cult is reworking the god's plans.

I encourage you to do an update on the prologue module and what it entails.

Is this a neutral setting AP campaign or does it relay on your world setting specific?

Will you be giving NPC previews?

Grand Lodge

maybe liz could poke them with a stick (email) to see if she can get them to respond to that post.

Grand Lodge

Can anyone from Black Flame step in and tell us about this product. Is it a class or is it attachable arms for any character?

I would proudly work on better descriptions. But I am curious.

Grand Lodge

Maximum Xcrawl. Can't recommend that enough.


Grand Lodge

Syphon - its a psionic class Amora Game

Grand Lodge

If you look at 3rd party publishers, there is actually a "breaker" PrC.

I've played it a few times on top of a barbarian.

Grand Lodge

I did just find this over at MCA (multi class archetypes)

Grand Lodge

I think it all depends on what you or the GM allows in the game. I think if it progressed normally it would be fine.

Grand Lodge

OR spell progression could be that of a ranger/paladin allowing you to move spellstrike and such around to free up some spots.

Grand Lodge

Why not go with the Unchained Version of the Monk?
You might want to check out the shinobi by Purple Duck Games or even the Talented Monk by Rogue Genius. They are closer to a monk though.

So if we want more ninja/magus hybrid, let's start with a fresh build. How does this look so far

Shinobi 1.2:

1st - Cantrips, Improved Unarmed Strike, Spell Combat
2nd - Spellstrike (unarmed strike), Ki Arcana
3rd - Shinobi Talent
4th - Sneak Attack +1d6
5th - uncanny dodge, Cunning knowledge
6th - Light Steps, Shinobi Talent
7th - Sneak Attack +2d6
8th - Improved uncanny dodge
9th - Shinobi Talent
10th - Sneak Attack +3d6
11th - Cunning Breach
12th - Shinobi Talent
13th - Sneak Attack +4d6
14th -
15th - Shinobi Talent
16th - Sneak Attack +4d6
17th -
18th - Shinobi Talent
19th - Sneak Attack +5d6
20th - Shinobi Talent

Weapon Prof: either or is fine
Armor Prof: Light armor, not with shields -
Spell progression as normal

Ki Arcana: The Shinobi receives a combined ki arcana pool that progresses as an aracan pool. S/he may spend this pool to fuel arcana and Ki pool description such as that of a monk (such as getting one extra attack even without flurry or unarmed attack.) For using ki powers/ninja tricks that are fueled by ki cost 1 extra.

Shinobi Talent: allows you to pick ninja trick or magus arcana, but must meet prereq

Is this about what you are looking more in line with? Feel free to modify accordingly or disregard all of it.

Grand Lodge

I'll take the first bite.

1. With regards to the 100 monk variants out there, besides going to the Paizo material, what do you feel is the best feel for the monk/wuxia martial artist that best covers the basic principals of the original Shoalin concept?

2. What of a samurai and/or Youxia?

Bonus: what of a ninja?

Grand Lodge

If you are playing this class with hybrid classes or a gestalt game where you only use this class, it will be fine.

In standard play there is too much going on and is a bit of a cluster. You get a ki pool and an arcane pool. And spells. And spell strike.

are you trying to make Shinobi the the video game character?

1. Shinobi is just another name for ninja. What specifically do you want this class to do?
2. Cut out slow fall. cut out the fast movement, just cut out the monk.
3. What's your flavor text to help guide the route you want to go?
4. Ack! hold off on your iaijutsu focus. You aren't there yet.

We need to have a solid foundation if you are wanting to bring this class together. What story do you want to tell with it.

Right now it makes me go "NOPE!" as a player and GM.

I think what you are wanting is a magus archetype that allows access to ninja tricks in place of arcana

Grand Lodge

This might be a thread to your liking.

This product might be of interest: 3PP though

Grand Lodge

Bandw2 wrote:


Yes & no. A lot of good quality products are not on that site.

Grand Lodge

Start herrah.

Go with compilations. That's the easy way to get more bang for your buck.

What type of character do you play? Flavor wise. What type of caster do u want to make?
Anvil/arm type? Like a Runesmith?

Or like a mosaic mage?

Grand Lodge

Mana Chicken wrote:
So off topic. Is having a level 8 sorcerer with a fire breath weapon that does anywhere between 24-84 damage good? 30 ft. cone.

You are good dude, if that's your focus.

RANT ABOUT 3PP vs Paizo:

Since this topic has derailed into if 3PP publishers are balanced or not let's talk about Paizo being a 3rd party publisher.

Pathfinder is a reincarnation of 3.5. Is it balanced to 3.5 - no it is not. Is 13th Age balanced to 4th Ed D&D and Pathfinder... no

Before someone starts saying "what are you talking about? It's not comparable to or even close to using rules from them... stop...yes it does look at the OGL.

Is advanced class guide balanced to base classes in the core rule book... 60% of the people I game with say no.

Let's all take a moment to stop comparing systems and publishers against one another. Some are "balanced" to your game play style. Several are not.

End result back on topic:

It seems we have identified that Mana Chicken's co player isn't following the rules of his created character.

more ranting crazy talk:

If you only want to use "Official Paizo" products then use the official gosh darn bloody site

People should stop complaining that someone pulled it off It's a 3rd party site. if you use "official" then stick with the "official" site. Do not be surprised is someone pulls something like the " most crazy imbalanced class ever ".

If you want to expand your game (Specifically if it is a homebrew) check out other companies products. IE 3rd Party Publishers, then I strongly encourage*

*I am a 3PP, and in my home tables sometimes its official only, sometimes it's if you brought the book, then you can use it.

Grand Lodge

2 people marked this as a favorite.

The world was created as a planer cross roads experiment, that is left with magic/psionic residue polluting the environment causing random mutations from the Traveler Wars (travelers are those that tried to steal it from those that created it)... While magic and psionics are present, it is rare and limited to a few who can adapt it. Present yet limited.

Iron Born (Rite Publishing) – created by the creators
Cynean (LPJ Design) - result of magical/psionic pollutions
Manadragoran (Rite Publishing) / Dalrean (LPJ Design) – result of magical/psionic pollutions
Humans - slave race of the travelers, left behind
Half-giant - slave race of the travelers, left behind
Forgeborn - Dreamscarred – travelers and creators experiment

Top Classes:
Demiurge (Amora Game)
Mosaic Mage (Super Genius/Rogue Genius), but expanded flavor and redefined spell list
Wilder (Dreamscarred)
Umbra (Amora Game)
Awalim (Purple Duck Games), but recreated and structure with house rule fixes. (it actually is more of a cultural class of a community in the world.)
Kusa (Rite Publishing)

Most martial classes non magical/psionic class. Anything with sneak attack is out unless it is swapped out and made a different house rule. Sneak attack becomes more of a feat in my world, not a class given.

Um .. imagine a Cynean Demiurge, Iron Born Kusa, Dalrean wilder, and a Human Mosaic Mage. It is a cool campaign so for.

Grand Lodge

I have a few issues with this book, some good some bad. Before I review it, I have to state this book is in violations of the Pathfinder compatibility license.

1. No title page. It goes from "cover" straight to introduction page.
2. Missing items from Exhibit A the license agreement.
3. Doesn't state what is IP based on the OGL license.
4. Same note on what is actually Open Game Content

Technically without 2-4, this book isn't PF Compatible.

5. Semi Dead level at 9 (only 10 ft increase), and 13 which is completely dead.

I will work on a review this weekend.

Grand Lodge

Thank you Malwing! I look forward to it, when you get time.

New Meditation Feat Summary:

Body Mending: Gain fast heal 1 during combat meditation
Chakra Disruption: Deal 1 STR or Dex damage, or cause opponents to be unable to use grit, ki, panache, psionic, quintessence, essence, or conduct points
Center Focus: Gain a Ki point
Circulatory Control: fend off bleed and poison damage
Contemplative Endurance: Transfer Ki to Stamina points
Contemplative Maneuver: Perform a counter maneuver on failed attacks against you
Controlled Emotions: Reroll failed Will save vs Fear
External Power: gain a ki power for the day. Spend grit or ki point to use
Gritty Thoughts: Transfer ki to grit
Heroic Thoughts: Use ki to gain temporary Hero Point
Innate Yang: Gain bonus to attack and confirm critical. Scaling feat on critical confirmations.
Innate Yin: Add wisdom to your AC – scaling.
Last Efforts: High level feat with several feat requirements that let you come back from negative hit points, to take advantage of all of your meditation feats
Living Sword Technique: Use your ranks in craft or profession to instead of your BAB.
Sound of Waves: Gain sonic and force resistance.

Grand Lodge

Simple reasons.

1 dies of a heart attack in his sleep, but isn't found for over a month, because he locked himself away to work on a big project; which s/he is prone to do.

2 got bored and went of vacation never to return in a continent far away.

1 made a deal with the devil to gain his/her power and the devil came to collect. He sacrificed himself instead of 1000s of deaths and souls of his nation. But he deserves it because he cheated to get power.

1 was asked by a god to help defend the world from something from beyond.

1 gets bored of living and says "screw it, i'm out".

1 one wants to live forever, and goes the lich route but doesn't tell anyone. Some random street urchin drops the secret urn that was a phylactery, mean while the lich trips down some stairs, but didn't prepare a fly spell.

1 one is poisoned, but didn't prepare remove disease, or never learned it, dying of his wounds (it could be multiple poisons.

1 is assassinated, easily done, because the mage had hubris and never locked his door, or had guards.

Grand Lodge

My biggest issue is that some of the "religions" don't have a "pantheon". Shinto gods don't count as the same as Buddhist deities, which doesn't count for the various sub Buddhist sects.

Now I see you have a list of people in Chinese and Japanese that are actual people have have been given deification. Like Guan Yu in Chinese. You also have listed Japanese Emperors that are deified.

The thing is with those cultures that have ancestor worship, they become "gods". So the list can be every growing, or you can actually cut them down or in half.

I also see some missing. Like the 7 gods of fortune.

I think you might want to reconsider your list to the most popular of the mythologies.

Grand Lodge

DC 21 Reflex save at 10th level is pretty good.

+ edifice damage (save for half) + possibility prone + absolute difficult terrain + obliterate damage + move backwards 30 feet.

2nd round repeat
3rd round repeat

For a side option, its pretty balanced I felt.

OOOh spend an emulation and combine with thundering chorus.

Grand Lodge

Gander at the inspiration of the wording from barbarian rage power ground breaker. Same rules :)

Grand Lodge

Jacob W. Michaels wrote:
Not a traditional 3PP, Swords for Hire creates products to be published through other companies, including Outland Entertainment. Our projects, aimed at both players and GMs, will be usable in any campaign setting.

Creating things and publishing them through another company... am I wrong or isn't that just called "freelance"?

Beyond that, congratulations. I look forward to see what you folks can come up with.

Grand Lodge

Its in my queue to purchase when i get time. But Unchained is also on the way with a new monk, so its a tough date of timing for my pocket book.

But soon.

Grand Lodge

Welcome Henri Hakl!

Before I shell out the 6$, how many pages is this book?
Who is(are) designers/author(s)?
From your description is this more martial artist then current monk? How is it "invented"?

Grand Lodge

I think you have a fine start. Let me look over it and ponder, but I think its pretty self explanatory. What would Esoterica replace? I think that may be the biggest thing.

Maybe have a larger list of anti schools to balance?

Grand Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Here is a Greek Source Book. It may help in your adventures.

Grand Lodge

1. Far East AP Plug-Ins
2. Far East AP Plug-Ins
3. Far East AP Plug-Ins

Grand Lodge

Oh well have you tried the pathfinder wiki? i forget the web address.

Grand Lodge

Buri Reborn wrote:
So, like for paladins there's a lot of stuff from the CRB, UE, UM, UC, ISG, ISWG, CoP, CotR, FoP, FaP, and ISM. Even the various god articles in APs I see still have tidbits about their faiths that aren't in ISG.

Maybe I'm just a square and not hip to the interweb savvy lingo...

What the HECK are "ISG, ISWG, CoP, CotR, FoP, FaP, and ISM."?

Archives of nethys

D20pfsrd (includes 3rd party)

or just

Grand Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.


Grand Lodge

For those that have asked me, Paizo should have some hardcovers at this point. I have sent them an email inquiring as to when they might ship to the couple that have bought the pre-order.

Grand Lodge


Now the questions:

Who is the designer(s) of the book. What is the page count?

Grand Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.

That was my thought... but I guess if you are going to compare an arm chainsaw to a sword... its cuts it pretty close.

*rim shot*

Grand Lodge

DMJB83 wrote:

Recently started a new ap and the othe GM and I are both players because someone else decided to try thier hand at running the show. A lot of guys showed up with dex builds and as you would suspect our damage output at low levels was pretty bad, but they kept saying wait til lvl 3. When level 3 hit they all took deadly agility and current GM allowed it. That got me reserching the feat.


I was curious how other feel about it. I am currently in the boat that having so many skils and abilites based off one stat is slightly over power.One of them is a twf and this one feat not only changes his prime damage stat but applys it to his off hand as well? Please send me some advice as I will be running things agian one day should I allow this feat.

If Paizo allows something similar (but limited to holding it with one hand) it, why not a 3rd party version.

Having a Dex built character is no different if he was a Str based character with two weapon fighting (minus the off hand damage). The trade off, I don't have to worry about Dex interfering with my armor.

VS. The Dex based character won't have full plate because it limits their dex mod to AC.

Simple trade offs. BUT just my opinion.

Grand Lodge

Was this idea pulled from anywhere or was this purely home brewed?

Only asking because I have seen a lot of similar pieces. Well put together though. Good use of polymorph.

Grand Lodge


Grand Lodge

Is it possible to get a better understanding of the mechanics for the Godai-ken. Breaking down the words, Godai (Japanese) is the equivalent of Wu Xing (Chinese) elements.

How close is it to the Tao? Is it more of an alternate class? Are we looking more at an elemental dragon ball z?

Grand Lodge

You don't need to require a jump check for leaping charge, but something that has jump and leaping in the description and title should have some sort of description as to how I am jumping. You don't have to require a jump check.

I like it so far, but the description is missing a bit. Something needs to be done different, change the name, or require at least jumping off something to get momentum for the charge

If he has the flavor of jumping over enemies and striking down from above, but I don't see the relative mechanics through out the class.

To me, as a player, just saying he jumps to make a leaping strike, doesn't do a visual.... unless we are talking about Achilles from the movie Troy. That's a leaping charge. Even at that, I have to "jump" around the opponent.

Now leaping attack is a decent visual and the wording is okay. However, I think again the words are a little loose for my taste. By threaten, does that mean only adjacent?
Can it be combined as an attack of opportunity if a feat is created?

Does leaping attack provoke?

(not trying to gang up on your class, just fundamental questions I have)

Grand Lodge

Rallaster wrote:

Considering you have to be threatening, not that high.

And for the latter, not that high either.

So how high? 10 feet or 2 feet. You need to define it. A charge is a min of 10 feet to move.

With the current rules, I'm going to hop in the air 1 foot high and stab a guy.

do you need to follow the rules of charge except that I have to jump off something? Your primary rule doesn't function and leaves vague openness to gamer table disputes.

Just call it a powerful charge.

Also I have a huge issue with the scaling d8. Why a d8?

Grand Lodge

Teamwork feats???

Grand Lodge

I will pledge this weekend once the wallet is thicker!

Grand Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Like Armor? Something like this?

Part 2 for helmets and shields are here.

Beast Hunter PrC here.

Grand Lodge

If you have Liber Mechanica it has he rules for Steamjacks. I think it has the bonded rules as well to give them skills/feats.

Grand Lodge

It is a great start. As my alter ego "Amora Game" I am looking at this intently for a possible class for Project HoF. But it needs some definition on its use. What is the purpose and how will it be different from cross classing, or as a magus archetype?

Since it's a monk/magus combo according to your profile, it needs to show a little more monk if it is actually a hybrid class.

Add a touch of qigong monk maybe?

1 to 50 of 343 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | next > last >>

©2002–2015 Paizo Inc.®. Need help? Email or call 425-250-0800 during our business hours: Monday–Friday, 10 AM–5 PM Pacific Time. View our privacy policy. Paizo Inc., Paizo, the Paizo golem logo, Pathfinder, the Pathfinder logo, Pathfinder Society, GameMastery, and Planet Stories are registered trademarks of Paizo Inc., and Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Pathfinder Adventure Path, Pathfinder Adventure Card Game, Pathfinder Player Companion, Pathfinder Modules, Pathfinder Tales, Pathfinder Battles, Pathfinder Online, PaizoCon, RPG Superstar, The Golem's Got It, Titanic Games, the Titanic logo, and the Planet Stories planet logo are trademarks of Paizo Inc. Dungeons & Dragons, Dragon, Dungeon, and Polyhedron are registered trademarks of Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and have been used by Paizo Inc. under license. Most product names are trademarks owned or used under license by the companies that publish those products; use of such names without mention of trademark status should not be construed as a challenge to such status.