So I'm pretty far into the Shackled City path, and I've read the criticisms of it: "The villains aren't foreshadowed" and "It's a meatgrinder" are the two I've heard the most (and also "The Starry Mirror is impossible to figure out").
I love this path, but as I prepare for what comes next, I am wondering what you all think are the best paths out there and how they stack up against The Shackled City. I think the one I will run next will be another conversion to 4e (ohh joy!) - Rise of The Runelords. It just looks awesome.
But I am wondering how you'd rank Shackled City among the others. Here's the main options and my brief, ignorant thoughts on them:
Age of Worms - This looks really, really good. But I've read that it, like the Shackled City, feels like it's not very connected.
Savage Tide - Supposedly in this one, the adventures flow together beautifully. But I personally don't like the "pulp" style, and I hear this is pulp-y.
Rise of The Runelords - Again, awesome. Though I've never seen a serial killer work in d&d.
Scales of War - I am actually running this for another group, but it's too early to say how good it is. I like running something in actual 4e, but wizards hasn't released much of an over-all plot. It's pretty generic thus far.