Paizo Top Nav Branding
  • Hello, Guest! |
  • Sign In |
  • My Account |
  • Shopping Cart |
  • Help/FAQ
About Paizo Messageboards News Paizo Blog Help/FAQ
Goblin

Comrade Anklebiter's page

7,510 posts. Alias of Doodlebug Anklebiter.


RSS

1 to 50 of 7,510 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | next > last >>

Forgot to mention that at the conference I met Howie Hawkins, whom, if memory serves me correctly, Comrade Fergie voted for in the last New York gubernatorial election.

We discussed our common employer.


Anarchists for Bernie on May Day


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Happy May Day!

Going down to a rally for Verizon strikers before I head off to work.

Yesterday's Boston Socialist Unity Conference was fun. Ran into a lot of old friends and new, including a guy I was in the Sparts with 20 years ago.

Haven't done the leftist bingo tally yet, but I'm sure there were lots of points, especially since celebrity leftist Vijay Prashad is reported to be a member of the Communist Party of India (Marxist).

U.S. Imperialism: Past and Present


Comrades of Mine in the News, or; More Professors

Comrade Anklebiter wrote:

VIDEO: 41 People Arrested Protesting CUNY Cuts at Cuomo's Midtown Office

Which, I've heard, led Governor Cuomo to reverse himself and fully fund CUNY. Don't quote me on that, I haven't really been following it, but one of La Principessa's NYC professor comrades was involved in organizing it, so I've heard bits.

Gettin' published in Truthout.

Sanders May Be All but Finished, but the Fight for a Better Future Is Not

[DJdD]Decided not to go to Lawrence due to, a) fidelity; and, b) I'm broke.[/DJdD]


Commie article on Verizon


Robert Hawkshaw wrote:

Comrade Anklebiter, is it true what they say? Is support for trump rising amongst the union rank and file?

http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/apr/26/us-unions-donald-trump-us-el ection-2016?utm_source=fark&utm_medium=website&utm_content=link

Hello, Comrade Hawkshaw!

Beats me. I only know of one Trump supporter in my shop (and one Kasich supporter), but, then again, I work in Massachusetts, "bluest of the blue." I have heard The Black Goblin opining that if it comes down to the Donald versus Killary, he'd rather vote for Trump based on his anti-NAFTA, anti-TPP position, but I've noticed him veering to the right under the influence of his Dreadlocked Libertarian Wife who was devastated when Rand Paul dropped out. He did, however, DM my first game of 5th edition last Saturday. He ruled that I couldn't be a nobleman, so I dropped Aloysius Ambrose d'Abelmarle and instead created Piter Pettigrew, a paladin blacksmith.

As for populism, it can go either way. Quite instructive would be the example of Tom Watson and the Southern Populists who initially, in the late 19th century, forged a heroic alliance of poor white and black sharecroppers but later became a virulent white supremacist.

As for this week...tomorrow going to a rally for Verizon strikers before work and then over to Lawrence for another possible Amy Dube sighting (La Principessa decided to celebrate our getting back together by not coming up during her vacation and, instead, cry in bed and not leave the apartment for seven days straight); Friday will see me at a rally for UMass Lowell adjunct faculty (please sign the petition!); and Saturday will see me travelling down to Boston for the
Building Socialism, Building Our Movements Conference.
I am most excited to see Vijay Prashad speak and Comrade Gerry from Workers World giving his "Red, Black, and Queer" slideshow presentation.

Sunday, of course, is May Day, so look for a Verizon rally or immigrant rights demonstration near you! I'll be at work, alas. I already banged out one Sunday in the past month.


[Vo Giap, Ambassador of Bachuan]I don't think the albino sea cucumber says anything. It just shows up and shines its heavenly mandate on the next Kim.[/VG,AoB]

Anyway, the Occupy NH alumni were showing the new Michael Moore flick at the UU church in Manchester. I went, but I missed a bunch of the movie because I was dirty texting La Principessa and then had to sneak out into the lobby to finish the job. They had an impressive turnout, about 80 ppl, but I suspect half of them were the regular parishioners. Handed out a bunch of Jeffrey Pendleton leaflets. (Oh yeah, forgot to mention, the authorities are claiming he died from a fentanyl overdose. Haven't seen the family's response yet.)

Yesterday walked the Verizon lines in the rain for about an hour before we went out to eat with newly-graduated comrade who just got back from partying for a month in Guatemala.

Back to the lines after another comrade gets out of work. Phone worker picket lines are fun, it's, like, all mommies, who make sure you have a poncho and an umbrella.


Ciao! Tried clicking on yr link, paisan, but my computer said it wasn't safe. :(

I will forward it to my all-purpose Asian Stalinist friend, however.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Well, all my local environmentalist buddies who've been working on this are calling it a success:

Kinder Morgan Suspends Work, Spending On Pipeline Project


Five Hundred Years of Utopia


Comrades of Mine in the News

I didn't really pay attention to the second Million Student March, but during the first one Neil Cavuto from Fox Business News interviewed one of my Boston students comrades and pretty much wiped the floor with her.

They must've thought they'd have as easy a time the second time around because they invited us back and the resulting video has apparently gone viral.

Cavuto and 'Million Student March' Organizer Clash on Education, Free College

I haven't watched the whole thing yet, but the last five or so minutes are fun.


There's a pic of her out there using a Socialist Alternative bullhorn.

The Jeffrey Perry event went off like gangbusters whether it was because we brought La Principessa's Single Mother, etc., or whether it was because we were the only people in the room under sixty. Said he'd come up to Lowell anytime, even if only to talk to a few people.

Then we went to a Regional Debate on feeling the bern, but I missed quite a chunk of it due to ADHD-diagnosed 8-year-olds. I later confessed to his mother that I wished it was the fifties when you could smack other people's children. She laughed. Also, picked up a copy of a nerdy comrade's new pamphlet, a Game of Thrones-inspired publication called "The Committee for a Westeros International."

Later, had phone sex with La Principessa, because, you know, we need more emotional confusion in our lives.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Fergie wrote:
This one was very different because the NYPD had the WHOLE area blocked off for the Bernie rally that was going on nearby in Washington Square Park

Comrade Kshama and La Principessa's Union Sister with the Impressive Collection of Dick Pics were among those opening for him in Foley Square today.

La Principessa's Single Mother Comrade and Her ADHD-Diagnosed 8-Year-Old Son came up to visit and tomorrow we're going down to hear a guy named Jeffrey B. Perry lecture on Hubert Harrison.

We've been trying to get him to come up to Lowell and we feel we've got a better chance if we bring La Principessa's Single Mother Comrade who used to date one of his union brothers back in the 80s when they were taking their postal workers union local back from the mob.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

[Shrugs]

I like hip hop, bubblegum pop and country.


I'm Hiding In Your Closet wrote:

*sigh* Am I the only liberal who abhors hip-hop, and considers it something that shouldn't be endorsed in this fashion, or something?

I wouldn't know, I'm not a liberal.

But hip hop is the shiznit.

Here's a prominent Bernie supporter


Comrade Anklebiter wrote:


More of La Principessa's Union Sisters In the News

Labor Notes Conference Gathers Over 2,000 ‘Troublemaker’ Workers and Organizers in Chicago

I've gotten drunk with the one in the middle more than a few times....
New York teachers are weird.

She just posted pix of her running into fellow Labor-for-Berniers on the street in Manhattan outside of the Corrosion of Conformity show.


Then, in one of those rare moments of congruity, me and my long lost spawnmate agree: Strike! Strike! Strike!

WHAT TIME IS IT? STRIKE TIME!

The brothers and sisters in Lowell were very friendly even though we only walked their lines for 20 minutes before hopping on the bus and going to Boston.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Fast-food protesters gather in Manchester

Here’s What You Need To Know About Today’s Nationwide Strikes

Photo by former Khmer Rouge enthusiast

Got to Ms. Dube's presentation an hour late. I went in with the Nigerian Princess while Mr. Comrade ordered dinner downstairs. The NP observed her for a while and then whispered, "This isn't good, Doodlebug, she's a La Principessa clone, if La Principessa was taller and a redhead. But she looks great." Later, the NP introduced herself, but Ms. Dube avoided eye contact with me, so I let the moment pass, and then she bolted and escaped. "Why didn't you say anything?!?" the NP chided on the way home. I hemmed and hawed and she said "You're shy, she's shy, this is never going to work. But she has amazing legs."


Early morning striking music:

Roll the Union On

[Yawns]

I don't see how I'm going to make it to Ms. Berard Dube's tonight. :(


And one from Gawker that seems in the spirit of things:

If You Want to Be Able to Tell Your Boss to Eat S*+~, Unionize


Shameless socialist self-promotion

"In Manchester on Thursday, fast-food and other low-wage workers are expected to join a nationwide strike at 6 a.m. to demand a $15-an-hour minimum wage and union rights. A rally is slated for the McDonald’s restaurant on South Willow St.

"'McDonald’s, the world’s second-largest employer and industry leader in the fast-food and service economy, is a symbol of what is wrong with the economy,' said a statement issued by the Service Employees International Union. The union is organizing the Manchester event along with the Granite State Organizing Project and Socialist Alternative."

Tax protests planned by those at both ends of political spectrum


2 people marked this as a favorite.

In the fifties, the American capitalist establishment was willing to accept a strong, but defanged, labor movement. Partly because less than 15 years ago, mass class war led by avowed commies had broken out and scared the beejeezus out of them. Partly because they were flush with cash from the uptick in profits from the postwar boom that they could afford them. Partly because, as Comrade Jeff points out, they had defanged the commies in them through McCarthyism, etc. Probably other shiznit, too, but I've been drinking.

What else? In answer to Citizen Moonrunner's first question: Prolly not, although the anti-union offensive at UPS, for example, isn't terribly overt. In answer to Citizen Moonrunner's second question: For me, no, Bernie doesn't make the cut. Nor did Michael Harrington, although I found his The Other America a pretty powerful read and indictment of poverty at the height of the American postwar boom. The Democratic Socialists of America are a part of the Democratic Party and, despite the line coming out of Seattle from leadership, I still can't abide the Democratic Party.

Anyway, stopped by the Lowell Verizon lines on my way home. About 200 strong, shutting down all three entrances to the mall which, is, coincidentally, the same mall where the bus is going to pick up the fast food strikers to go to Boston.

Anyway, last night I played Thunder: Classic Role Playing. I was a hawt female fire mage named Zhasha last night. We had to save a lumbertown that were under siege by faceless grey reavers. At one point, I ended up in the boarded up church with some lumberjacks and I engineered a menage a trois with Sven and Olaf, who, later, received bonuses to their attacks due to the morale boost I gave them.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

Standing up to Verizon's war on unions


1 person marked this as a favorite.

And, to continue a running theme from a ways back, more swords in the news:


Light Rail Avenger

God, I'd hate to have that guy at my table.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Communism:

Showed Let the Fire Burn last night and made $25 for the MOVE 9 (8) which is the least that we've made so far, despite it having almost twice as many attendees as any other film showing this year. Even better, one of the attendees was a dude I almost got into a fight with two Christmases ago.

We have learned that the international fast food workers strike on Thursday is going to be dedicated to Jeffrey Pendleton. On Friday, the Granite State Organizing Project is having a noontime standout in front of the Burger King where he worked and then, later in the afternoon, our rivals in the PSL are having an event in Boston:


From Boston to Brooklyn, From Nashua to New York: Justice for Akai Gurley, Jeffrey Pendleton & all victims of racist police brutality

And if all that wasn't enough, apparently, Wednesday morning, Verizon workers will probably go out on strike.

Verizon Workers Announce Strike Deadline of Wednesday, April 13th
TELECOM GIANT MAKES $1.8 BILLION A MONTH IN PROFIT, BUT SEEKS TO DESTROY GOOD JOBS FOR NEARLY 40,000 EAST COAST WORKING FAMILIES

Oh yeah, there's also a second Million Student March on Wednesday, too. Look for it at a campus near you!

Love:

Got an e-mail from the young Ugandan woman who staffs for the Granite State Organizing Project who wanted to meet up "one-on-one" for a half-hour/forty-five minutes. When I asked her what she wanted to discuss, she replied "I just want to get to know you better and vice versa." Oh yeah.

And on Thursday, after striking at six in the morning and going down to Boston to demonstrate all day, I have to schlepp back up to Lawrence by seven in the evening to see if I can successfully woo Ms. Berard. I hope I don't fall asleep.

Gaming:

After work tonight I'm gonna stop by a local gaming store to test run some homebrew system. I have no idea what it is. Saturday, hopefully, The Black Goblin will initiate us into the joys of 5e D&D.

I made a human paladin named Aloysius Ambrose d'Abelmarle.


I'm Hiding In Your Closet wrote:
Seen this? Got opinions? Looks like a party.

Yeah, I have. Some local labor types have mentioned it, and some of the local Bernie Democrats/Greens, although one of the few headliners I recognize is Dolores Huerta, who's a noted Hillary supporter. I was down in Brooklyn when she pulled that stunt in Nevada, I believe it was, and La Principessa's Anarcho-Syndicalist Guatemalan Playwright friend vituperated venomously against her and Cesar Chavez's collaborating with the feds back in the day to deport undocumented workers.

Looks like a typical liberal-Dem gathering, although I wish them success on most of their specific agenda points.

More of La Principessa's Union Sisters In the News

Labor Notes Conference Gathers Over 2,000 ‘Troublemaker’ Workers and Organizers in Chicago

I've gotten drunk with the one in the middle more than a few times. She's an elementary school teacher, sciences, I think, and she has the Chinese characters for "butt f*!~" tattooed on her ankle. Last time I saw her she tried to show me all the dick pics she had been receiving on her phone (maybe I should try that with Ms. Berard?) and then told me about an ex-con she was banging who, for protection, had joined a Nazi prison gang and had a swastika tattooed across his chest. They are both Jewish.

New York teachers are weird.


Union Sisters of La Principessa's in the News Which I Found on Ms. Berard's Facebook Page

Some NYC Teachers Defy Schools Chancellor to Critique Common Core, Encourage Opt-Out

I went to Lauren Cohen's birthday party.


3 people marked this as a favorite.

But I did have an amusing conversation with a union brother.

Kemal is a Bosnian who's been in the United States since the '90s. I was his steward a couple of years ago on another shift. He used to be a rigger in a different local, and then he started his own hardwood floor installation business and got a job at UPS part-time to keep his benefits and get pension accrual.

Anyways, Surly Italian Teamster, who's voting for Trump, was ragging on Muslims in the office when it occured to me there was a good chance that Kemal was a Muslim. So I started asking him about it, and he told me that he was, in fact, ethnically, or whatever, a Muslim, but that "Under Communism there was no religion" and he didn't practice or believe.

He talked some more about life in the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia and the conversation turned to me asking him what he thought of Bernie Sanders.

"Too socialist," Kemal said as he frowned and shook his head no. He then launched into a panegyric about the values of hard work and personal initiative, etc., etc., I'm sure you've heard it before.

He then went on to say that he wasn't hard-hearted*; he liked "non-crazy" Republicans like John Kasich, but Bernie Sanders wanted "to give too much away for free". In his opinion, the only things that should be free are: education, health care, and day care. "Day care?" I asked. "Yes, you know, for the kids, so the parents can go to work."

Free education, free health care, and free 24-hour day care. I'm pretty sure Bernie's only calling for two of those.

---
*And it's true. A further irony is that Kemal keeps giving money to Lazy, Hardly-Ever-Comes-To-Work, Probably-A-Welfare-Cheater-But-I-Try-Not-To-Judge Teamster when she gets behind on her bills, even though she hardly ever comes to work and has two grown sons who don't have jobs.


2 people marked this as a favorite.
Conservative Anklebiter wrote:

As a voice of reason, I don't think you're supposed to say your unintelligible word, phrase, and or noise, and then aim it at a current candidate or politicol group or figure as some have. Keep it like this...

Mohebobohip!

[Smacks Conservative Anklebiter]

VIVE LE GALT!!!!


1 person marked this as a favorite.

How the Teamsters pension disappeared more quickly under Wall Street than the mob


2 people marked this as a favorite.

I want to rock and seize the means of production!

Tonight, meeting at the Nashua Labor Coalition to build for Justice4Jeffrey and the April 14th strike, tomorrow the Granite State Organizing Project's Manchester meeting.

Glad to see another J4J event popped up on the coast, even if I can't go:

Justice for Jeffrey Pendleton

and our first Monday Night Movie:

Let the Fire Burn--Monday Night Movies

[DJdD]I invited Ms. Berard[/DJdD]


In its favor was cited the example of the Estates of Languedoc, the provincial assemblies and the assembly of Vizille.

--Georges Lefebvre, The Coming of the French Revolution


Vice News piece about the followers of Juan Posadas:

The Socialists Who Think Revolution Will Come When the Aliens Get Here


April 14, 2016 STRIKE


A member of the Workers World Party came up to Nashua and did an interview with the strikers. Which means that my life's dream of getting Red Steve Kirschbaum and his flatbed truck up to a demo I've organized is one step closer to fruition.

The WW comrade also pointed out an article they ran about police brutality in Nashua a decade and a half ago.

New Hampshire: Unity pushes back police brutality


The Black Panthers: Vanguard of the Revolution


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Think I'm going to skip the events in Boston. Kinda tired, kinda broke, kinda need to do my taxes.

Film showing last night brought in $35 for Ed Poindexter.

The Forgotten Panthers

Wopashitwe Mondo Eyen we Langa, 1947—2016

“When It Gets to This Point” by Mondo we Langa

We're reconsidering Friday Night Films for another day of the week. Maybe Monday Night Movies? Tuesday Night Talkies? Thursday at the Theatre? Not sure yet.

Anyway, after the day of airport worker strikes and the day of Chicago teachers strike (Ms. Berard put a photo out of her wearing red high heels and a sexy red skirt to show solidarity with the CTU--yowza!!!), April 15th is going to be the (inter?)national day of fast food workers strike, except in New England, where we do it on the 14th to not interfere with the Boston Marathon.

This year, we're organizing the bus stop in Lowell.

Get on the bus!


Got my picture in the NYT--

Unable to Pay $100 Bail, Homeless Man Dies in New Hampshire Jail

--and pix AND a quote in The Nashua Telegraph. My mommy bought five print copies and brought them home, but their website is behind a paywall for me.

And now I'll go look at the pictures of the CTU strike.


And one Mr. Comrade pointed out to me on Czechoslovakia 1968:

The Forgotten Workers’ Control Movement of Prague Spring


Comrade Kshama in The New Yorker:

How the Minimum-Wage Movement Entered the Mainstream

Meanwhile, in France...

Protests Erupt in France over Proposed Labor Reforms

Vive le Galt!


Sadly, there was no storming. Rally was in a different city, different set of people came, about the same amount. Nowhere near as intense. A little bit anticlimactic, tbh.

But...two of the new people who came were my Buddhist Monk former player and his wife and their two babies whom I had never met! They're named Aurelia (aged 2) and Barrington (six months) and they are adorable even if they were named by hippies.

Even better, he wants to play D&D again. Huzzah!


2 people marked this as a favorite.

Was scheduled to leave work early today, was kinda panicking, the disc of The Black Panthers: Vanguard of the Revolution that I had ordered from Netflix started skipping around the one hour mark and the replacement disc may (or may not) arrive the day of the film showing. Dropped by Barnes and Noble to hopefully pick one up with the gift card that I got for Christmas. They didn't have it, but maybe their store in Burlington had one. Wait while they make phone call. Clock is ticking to get to work. They're supposed to have it, but the clerk can't find it. Checked at the Newbury Comics and the FYE. Neither of them carry it.

Was racing to get to work on time, got a text from my boss saying take the whole day off. Relief. Still anxiety-ing out about the movie, though, so I drive to Burlington. Clerk asks me if I need any help. I say, "Well, you probably just received a call from Nashua..." "Oh yes, I couldn't find it." He tells me all the places he looked. I tell him thank you, but I'm going to look anyway. Five minutes later, find it. Anxiety level goes way down.

[Exhales]

I saved the film showing!

Now, just chillax until it's time to storm the police department...


Went to the Nashua Public Library sale to pick up books for the Lowell Leftie Lending Library. Found two copies of Lefebvre's The Coming of the French Revolution which I took as a sign and started reading.

Speaking of, the Lowell Leftie Lending Library has loaned out two books*! Woo hoo! Let's see if they bring them back.

(I also fished out my copy of The Third Policeman to further the copying-Limey trend.)

*
James M. McPherson--The Negro's Civil War: How American Blacks Felt and Acted During the War for the Union

and

Malcolm X--The End of White World Supremacy


1 person marked this as a favorite.

This op-ed by Norman Finkelstein made me chuckle:

“Why I Oppose Bernie Sanders, and Why I Support Hillary Clinton;”

Spoiler:
Or, Sorry Bernie Bros, Your Candidate Just Doesn’t Have The Foreign Policy Experience Necessary To Prop Up A Pro-Western Dictatorship

Hee hee!


2 people marked this as a favorite.

More locally-produced agitprop:

JUSTICE FOR JEFFREY: The people take the fight to Valley Street

and

Loving father of 3 shot dead by Lowell police: Why?

Also, finally found the article in The Guardian, but I didn't make the cut:

Protesters seek answers after homeless man's death in New Hampshire jail

Tomorrow, getting out of work early so we can storm the Nashua Police Department:

New Hampshire Justice for Jeffrey Pendleton

Last night, we dipped our first toe into Cambodian-émigré politics.

Kind of knew it would be weird, and it was. Turns out, the government of Cambodia was gifting the city of Lowell with a statue of some king of Angkor Wat. A local up-and-coming Cambodian-American Republican turned the issue into a political football in order to attack a standing Cambodian-American Democratic state representative who, if our local contacts are to be believed, had gone to the home country to negotiate the release of some monks. The Repub C-A had allegedly doctored a video of it so that instead of the Dem C-A saying "I have come to learn about why the monks are being held" he said "I am here to learn from you." So scuttlebutt goes, anyway. Beats me.

But it did spur me to learn quite a bit about Cambodia:

30 Years of Hun Sen: Violence, Repression, and Corruption in Cambodia

We left early and then watched as two CAJE members (local teacher who discovered labor theory of value on his own and lone black male member) gave podcasting a trial run. Mr. Comrade and I are certain that the latter is now a candidate member of PSL, but I started crying when they talked about the beginnings of CAJE and he testified to how much he had learned from "[another CAJE member], [the Nigerian Princess], [Comrade Anklebiter] and [Mr. Comrade]." [Sobs]

Anyway, got three contact sessions set up for the rest of this week, including with the NH Bernie supporter who had told Mr. Comrade he was a Massachusetts troll a whiles back, and I hope to make it two events in Boston (NEGROES WITH GUNS: Rob Williams and Black Power - Film and discussion and The Final Aim is Nothing: The Politics of Revisionism and Anti-revisionism) and then maybe put together a demo about this Perez thingy.

And, finally, Ms. Berard accepted my friend request!!!


And, speaking of the Khmer Rouge, the son of the current ruler of Cambodia is visiting Lowell tomorrow and the Khmer community, which is quite large, is supposed to protest. I don't know much about him or his father, but there's always wikipedia:

Hun Sen

EDIT: He's visiting in April, but there's a protest in front of the City Council meeting tonight.


Man shot by Lowell cops dies

1 to 50 of 7,510 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | next > last >>

©2002–2016 Paizo Inc.®. Need help? Email customer.service@paizo.com or call 425-250-0800 during our business hours: Monday–Friday, 10 AM–5 PM Pacific Time. View our privacy policy. Paizo Inc., Paizo, the Paizo golem logo, Pathfinder, the Pathfinder logo, Pathfinder Society, GameMastery, and Planet Stories are registered trademarks of Paizo Inc., and Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Pathfinder Adventure Path, Pathfinder Adventure Card Game, Pathfinder Player Companion, Pathfinder Modules, Pathfinder Tales, Pathfinder Battles, Pathfinder Online, PaizoCon, RPG Superstar, The Golem's Got It, Titanic Games, the Titanic logo, and the Planet Stories planet logo are trademarks of Paizo Inc. Dungeons & Dragons, Dragon, Dungeon, and Polyhedron are registered trademarks of Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and have been used by Paizo Inc. under license. Most product names are trademarks owned or used under license by the companies that publish those products; use of such names without mention of trademark status should not be construed as a challenge to such status.