paizo.com Recent Posts by Cole Cummingspaizo.com Recent Posts by Cole Cummings2024-02-15T15:39:18Z2024-02-15T15:39:18ZRe: Forums: Starfinder General Discussion: Crafting Robots and other ConstructsGy Aldrin (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs42v92?Crafting-Robots-and-other-Constructs#52024-01-05T15:20:58Z2024-01-05T15:14:00Z<p>Here's the formula I came up with:
<br />
1000 credits per CR + Whatever integrated weapons it has cost + Half CR cost per special ability.</p>
<p>So a typical CR4 Security Robot (AA pg. 94) would cost 4000 credits + 750 for the gun (arc admitter) + an additional 2000 credits for the Jolting Arc special ability + 2000 credits for this ability to be reusable + 2000cr for the 1/day heal "Nanite Repair".
<br />
For a whopping 10,750 credits!</p>
<p>To be honest, letting the PCs have robots is unbalancing to the game. So making robots ridiculously expensive is a game balance thing.</p>Here's the formula I came up with:
1000 credits per CR + Whatever integrated weapons it has cost + Half CR cost per special ability.
So a typical CR4 Security Robot (AA pg. 94) would cost 4000 credits + 750 for the gun (arc admitter) + an additional 2000 credits for the Jolting Arc special ability + 2000 credits for this ability to be reusable + 2000cr for the 1/day heal "Nanite Repair".
For a whopping 10,750 credits!
To be honest, letting the PCs have robots is unbalancing to the game. So...Gy Aldrin (alias of Cole Cummings)2024-01-05T15:14:00ZForums: Advice: Dynamic Skill ChecksGy Aldrin (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs43r4h?Dynamic-Skill-Checks#12023-02-12T20:26:31Z2023-02-02T23:42:24Z<p>Being a Technician in real life I found the Skill check mechanic very unrealistic in my Starfinder game. I created the "Project Skill Check" to create a more in-depth technical feel to common skill checks.</p>
<p>A "Project Skill Check" consists of 4 phases:
<br />
Diagnose
<br />
Access
<br />
Repair (Manipulate)
<br />
Complete</p>
<p>I apply this to nearly every technical skill use in my game, from Computers to Medicine checks. My experience with this method has been that skill checks are more challenging and feel more rewarding. As most technical challenges will take at least 4 combat round to complete (hopefully). And as GM I do my best to describe the challenges the PC faces at each phase which creates a deeper connection with the PCs chosen profession. And also has the protentional to create some truly memorable moments in the game.</p>
<p>Thoughts?</p>Being a Technician in real life I found the Skill check mechanic very unrealistic in my Starfinder game. I created the "Project Skill Check" to create a more in-depth technical feel to common skill checks.
A "Project Skill Check" consists of 4 phases:
Diagnose
Access
Repair (Manipulate)
Complete
I apply this to nearly every technical skill use in my game, from Computers to Medicine checks. My experience with this method has been that skill checks are more challenging and feel more...Gy Aldrin (alias of Cole Cummings)2023-02-02T23:42:24ZRe: Forums: Rules Questions: Non-Drift, In-System Space TravelGy Aldrin (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2v5ay?NonDrift-InSystem-Space-Travel#82023-01-06T17:50:34Z2023-01-06T17:48:53Z<p>Each planet (or orbit) is relatively 1d6+2 days travel apart from each other. So you would calculate it; Absalom Station to Akiton 1d6+2 days. Then Akiton to Verces 1d6+2 days.</p>Each planet (or orbit) is relatively 1d6+2 days travel apart from each other. So you would calculate it; Absalom Station to Akiton 1d6+2 days. Then Akiton to Verces 1d6+2 days.Gy Aldrin (alias of Cole Cummings)2023-01-06T17:48:53ZRe: Forums: Dead Suns: Money in the Adventure PathGy Aldrin (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs42lae?Money-in-the-Adventure-Path#122022-12-20T23:19:30Z2022-12-20T23:19:30Z<p>I just looked at it realistically. Professional mercs who risk their lives get paid a lot of money. Usually around $200-$300k/year + bonuses for specific tasks. For that pay they give up to the patron all loot. So any high priced items like vehicles, powered armor, etc. are owned by the patron. </p>
<p>I translate that to (PC lvl)x($1000/wk). 1st lvl PCs get paid $4000/month. 10th lvl PCs get paid $40,000 a month
<br />
Vehicles and such are just signed out at item level as Security Clearance or Underworld Reputation level.</p>
<p>This keep the players from Murderhoboing to make a living and is frankly more realistic to a future economy. Because people don't make a living looting the bodies of the people they kill. And. It's important to have a patron because killing people is ILLEGAL.</p>I just looked at it realistically. Professional mercs who risk their lives get paid a lot of money. Usually around $200-$300k/year + bonuses for specific tasks. For that pay they give up to the patron all loot. So any high priced items like vehicles, powered armor, etc. are owned by the patron.
I translate that to (PC lvl)x($1000/wk). 1st lvl PCs get paid $4000/month. 10th lvl PCs get paid $40,000 a month
Vehicles and such are just signed out at item level as Security Clearance or Underworld...Gy Aldrin (alias of Cole Cummings)2022-12-20T23:19:30ZRe: Forums: Homebrew: Elder ThingsGy Aldrin (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs43pyv?Elder-Things#22022-12-20T19:12:28Z2022-12-20T18:15:24Z<p>I've been using Elder Things and other Cthulhu mythos things from the start of Starfinder as kind of a "price for coming out here" kind of background threat.</p>
<p>In my take on the Mythos the Elder Gods were the first sentient things to exist after the Elemental Gods shattered the elemental chaos to create the ordered universe. It was the Elder Gods that first pooled wriggling proteins together to create biological life. And with no template of form just let that life evolve into all manner of aberrant shapes.</p>
<p>Finally Trillions of Eons later the Elemental Gods realized their place for Order was teeming with horrors, and they created the Dragons to destroy them. (that's why dragons are so powerful and they also have an elemental theme to them) And they started to take a more active role in the direction of the universe.</p>I've been using Elder Things and other Cthulhu mythos things from the start of Starfinder as kind of a "price for coming out here" kind of background threat.
In my take on the Mythos the Elder Gods were the first sentient things to exist after the Elemental Gods shattered the elemental chaos to create the ordered universe. It was the Elder Gods that first pooled wriggling proteins together to create biological life. And with no template of form just let that life evolve into all manner of...Gy Aldrin (alias of Cole Cummings)2022-12-20T18:15:24ZForums: Rules Discussion: Overall Class BalanceCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs43l02?Overall-Class-Balance#12022-02-23T18:29:21Z2022-02-23T18:29:21Z<p>Out of curiosity, with no opinion of my own presently. What is the balance between classes looking like in PF2? </p>
<p>For instance: With two primarily high damage output classes, How does the Wizard scale with the Barbarian in damage output? Is it a fair balance?</p>
<p>Or</p>
<p>How does the Bard, Rogue & Investigator scale for utility and skill monkeying? </p>
<p>Thought?</p>Out of curiosity, with no opinion of my own presently. What is the balance between classes looking like in PF2?
For instance: With two primarily high damage output classes, How does the Wizard scale with the Barbarian in damage output? Is it a fair balance?
Or
How does the Bard, Rogue & Investigator scale for utility and skill monkeying?
Thought?Cole Cummings2022-02-23T18:29:21ZForums: Pathfinder Adventures: Roleplaying Romance How Do You Do ItCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs43epx?Roleplaying-Romance-How-Do-You-Do-It#12021-07-22T15:11:28Z2021-06-22T18:10:33Z<p>So here is the situation. This is a Pathfinder-1e/D&D-3.5 game. I came into the game playing a dwarf bard who was awesome fun to play and likable. Then the person playing the 3.5 Healer quit because she got a new work schedule. We needed the Healer desperately. So I retired my bard and took over the Healer.</p>
<p>Well because of events that transpired in the game the Healer, Manika, became extremely enraptured with her god Ilmater. Inspiringly so. Manika was sweet, tender, caring, artistic and above all courageous and self sacrificing. (Oh yes, and a stunningly powerful healer pacifist)</p>
<p>Well we all, ended up trapped in the Darklands. Without Manika the party was doomed. (We were 4th lvl). And the campaign went on. The group rallying around Manika as their sole hope of survival. Their rock of faith and motherly safety. In such desperate straights the group began developing real feelings towards my character. The female Ranger saw her as a teacher. The Magus as a person who had his back no matter what. The swashbuckler as the one person that would always believe in her. But the rogue has truelly started to fall in love with Manika. Real love for this woman that has saved his life more times than he can count. Who has braved a Hezru Demon (at 4th lvl) to save him. </p>
<p>So now things are getting a bit awkward. I talked to one of female players to see if she would be interested in swapping characters, but she's not. So how do you all handle romance between characters? Mind you. Our group is very much into drama and deep RP. Also, we're all trapped in the dark with each other so there is no downtime to "fade to black". I have a feeling the the rogue very much wants to grab my character and kiss her and it's weird.</p>
<p>help...</p>So here is the situation. This is a Pathfinder-1e/D&D-3.5 game. I came into the game playing a dwarf bard who was awesome fun to play and likable. Then the person playing the 3.5 Healer quit because she got a new work schedule. We needed the Healer desperately. So I retired my bard and took over the Healer.
Well because of events that transpired in the game the Healer, Manika, became extremely enraptured with her god Ilmater. Inspiringly so. Manika was sweet, tender, caring, artistic and...Cole Cummings2021-06-22T18:10:33ZForums: Advice: Roleplaying Romance How Do You Do ItCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs43epw?Roleplaying-Romance-How-Do-You-Do-It#12021-07-23T22:34:34Z2021-06-22T18:10:33Z<p>So here is the situation. This is a Pathfinder-1e/D&D-3.5 game. I came into the game playing a dwarf bard who was awesome fun to play and likable. Then the person playing the 3.5 Healer quit because she got a new work schedule. We needed the Healer desperately. So I retired my bard and took over the Healer.</p>
<p>Well because of events that transpired in the game the Healer, Manika, became extremely enraptured with her god Ilmater. Inspiringly so. Manika was sweet, tender, caring, artistic and above all courageous and self sacrificing. (Oh yes, and a stunningly powerful healer pacifist)</p>
<p>Well we all, ended up trapped in the Darklands. Without Manika the party was doomed. (We were 4th lvl). And the campaign went on. The group rallying around Manika as their sole hope of survival. Their rock of faith and motherly safety. In such desperate straights the group began developing real feelings towards my character. The female Ranger saw her as a teacher. The Magus as a person who had his back no matter what. The swashbuckler as the one person that would always believe in her. But the rogue has truelly started to fall in love with Manika. Real love for this woman that has saved his life more times than he can count. Who has braved a Hezru Demon (at 4th lvl) to save him. </p>
<p>So now things are getting a bit awkward. I talked to one of female players to see if she would be interested in swapping characters, but she's not. So how do you all handle romance between characters? Mind you. Our group is very much into drama and deep RP. Also, we're all trapped in the dark with each other so there is no downtime to "fade to black". I have a feeling the the rogue very much wants to grab my character and kiss her and it's weird.</p>
<p>help...</p>So here is the situation. This is a Pathfinder-1e/D&D-3.5 game. I came into the game playing a dwarf bard who was awesome fun to play and likable. Then the person playing the 3.5 Healer quit because she got a new work schedule. We needed the Healer desperately. So I retired my bard and took over the Healer.
Well because of events that transpired in the game the Healer, Manika, became extremely enraptured with her god Ilmater. Inspiringly so. Manika was sweet, tender, caring, artistic and...Cole Cummings2021-06-22T18:10:33ZRe: Forums: Community Use: Official Roll20 Module GraphicsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs42wi0?Official-Roll20-Module-Graphics#72020-05-08T11:29:52Z2020-05-08T11:29:52Z<p>Well I certainly hope Piazo allows streamers to use their content. Lord knows Paizo could use all the marketing it can get! All I hear anymore from gamers is D&D5E.</p>Well I certainly hope Piazo allows streamers to use their content. Lord knows Paizo could use all the marketing it can get! All I hear anymore from gamers is D&D5E.Cole Cummings2020-05-08T11:29:52ZRe: Forums: Skills, Feats, Equipment & Spells: Druid: Wild Shape FeatCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2vbjt?Druid-Wild-Shape-Feat#32018-08-11T19:53:08Z2018-08-11T19:53:08Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Blave wrote:</div><blockquote> <div class="messageboard-quotee">Cole Cummings wrote:</div><blockquote><p> I'm trying to figure out what forms this feat allows. It doesn't seem to alter the 1st level Druid's stats in any way. That comes later with Animal Form Feat. But there doesn't seem to be any limitation on size or duration of the Power. </p>
<p>"You are one with the wild, always changing and adapting to meet any challenge. You gain a pool of wild energy, called your wild shape pool, with 1 use that you can use to cast a spell to shift your form; if you have at least four wild order feats, increase your pool to 2 uses. <b>You can spend a use of your wild shape pool to cast pest </b>form. All spells
<br />
you cast using Wild Shape function as if heightened to the maximum spell level you can cast,
<br />
unless stated otherwise.
<br />
Special If you are a druid of the wild order, you instead gain a number of uses of Wild Shape equal to your Strength modifier (minimum 1), and an additional use if you have at
<br />
least four wild order feats". PF2 PT Core </blockquote></blockquote><p>OOOhhhh!! Never heard of Pest Form. ThanksBlave wrote:Cole Cummings wrote:I'm trying to figure out what forms this feat allows. It doesn't seem to alter the 1st level Druid's stats in any way. That comes later with Animal Form Feat. But there doesn't seem to be any limitation on size or duration of the Power.
"You are one with the wild, always changing and adapting to meet any challenge. You gain a pool of wild energy, called your wild shape pool, with 1 use that you can use to cast a spell to shift your form; if you have at least...Cole Cummings2018-08-11T19:53:08ZForums: Skills, Feats, Equipment & Spells: Druid: Wild Shape FeatCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2vbjt?Druid-Wild-Shape-Feat#12018-08-11T18:33:14Z2018-08-11T18:33:14Z<p>I'm trying to figure out what forms this feat allows. It doesn't seem to alter the 1st level Druid's stats in any way. That comes later with Animal Form Feat. But there doesn't seem to be any limitation on size or duration of the Power. </p>
<p>"You are one with the wild, always changing and adapting to meet any challenge. You gain a pool of wild energy, called your wild shape pool, with 1 use that you can use to cast a spell to shift your form; if you have at least four wild order feats, increase your pool to 2 uses. You can spend a use of your wild shape pool to cast pest form. All spells
<br />
you cast using Wild Shape function as if heightened to the maximum spell level you can cast,
<br />
unless stated otherwise.
<br />
Special If you are a druid of the wild order, you instead gain a number of uses of Wild Shape equal to your Strength modifier (minimum 1), and an additional use if you have at
<br />
least four wild order feats". PF2 PT Core</p>I'm trying to figure out what forms this feat allows. It doesn't seem to alter the 1st level Druid's stats in any way. That comes later with Animal Form Feat. But there doesn't seem to be any limitation on size or duration of the Power.
"You are one with the wild, always changing and adapting to meet any challenge. You gain a pool of wild energy, called your wild shape pool, with 1 use that you can use to cast a spell to shift your form; if you have at least four wild order feats, increase...Cole Cummings2018-08-11T18:33:14ZRe: Forums: Advice: Frontline Control Fighter BuildCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2v8dm?Frontline-Control-Fighter-Build#142018-07-10T22:58:17Z2018-07-10T22:51:26Z<p>The point to pole-arm and shield is battlefield control. The reach from the pole-arm give you a greater threat range. The Shield bash gives you a close in attack. </p>
<p>You thrust then step forward and bash. Or you bash and then thrust. Once you have bull rush on your bash you can step into the vacated space after a bash to push the battle wear you want. Or hold the line and thrust.</p>The point to pole-arm and shield is battlefield control. The reach from the pole-arm give you a greater threat range. The Shield bash gives you a close in attack.
You thrust then step forward and bash. Or you bash and then thrust. Once you have bull rush on your bash you can step into the vacated space after a bash to push the battle wear you want. Or hold the line and thrust.Cole Cummings2018-07-10T22:51:26ZRe: Forums: Advice: Frontline Control Fighter BuildCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2v8dm?Frontline-Control-Fighter-Build#72018-07-09T04:32:56Z2018-07-09T04:25:56Z<p>That's just silly.</p>
<p>So you have a two handed polearm in your hands and your shield is strapped to your arm and you get the shield bonus. You couldn't control the polearm or the Shield properly like that.</p>
<p>No, you are using your Shield as your 2nd hand to stabalize the polearm. That would be the way I would read this. You're not changing the handedness of the polearm. You're using your shield as a hand.</p>That's just silly.
So you have a two handed polearm in your hands and your shield is strapped to your arm and you get the shield bonus. You couldn't control the polearm or the Shield properly like that.
No, you are using your Shield as your 2nd hand to stabalize the polearm. That would be the way I would read this. You're not changing the handedness of the polearm. You're using your shield as a hand.Cole Cummings2018-07-09T04:25:56ZRe: Forums: Advice: Frontline Control Fighter BuildCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2v8dm?Frontline-Control-Fighter-Build#42018-07-08T18:14:20Z2018-07-08T18:14:20Z<p>I'm not seeing that in the text. "You’ve mastered the art of balancing a polearm’s weight against a shield’s stability". This is essentially using your shield as your 2nd hand. Its why phallax shields have the recesses in the sides. You set the shaft into the recess thrust and bash thrust and bash. That's how you move forward.</p>I'm not seeing that in the text. "You’ve mastered the art of balancing a polearm’s weight against a shield’s stability". This is essentially using your shield as your 2nd hand. Its why phallax shields have the recesses in the sides. You set the shaft into the recess thrust and bash thrust and bash. That's how you move forward.Cole Cummings2018-07-08T18:14:20ZForums: Advice: Frontline Control Fighter BuildCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2v8dm?Frontline-Control-Fighter-Build#12018-07-08T17:54:32Z2018-07-08T17:08:20Z<p>Building a frontline control fighter using the Shield Brace feat and a Bill (polearm)</p>
<p>So far the build looks like this:
<br />
Human STR 17 DEX 16 CON 14 INT 10 WIS 10 CHR 8</p>
<p>1st lvl
<br />
Multiweapon Fighting
<br />
Shield Focus
<br />
Shield Brace</p>
<p>So he walks onto the field with a large steel shield and a Bill wielded in 1 hand braced against his shield (if you ever wondered what that little notch in the Shield is for, that's what it's for).</p>
<p>He takes the Shield ACP -2 to his attack roles with the polearm and he takes the two weapon fighting penalties if he decides to bash with his shield and attack with the Bill -2/-4</p>
<p>His backup weapon is a Scimitar And/Or Kukri</p>
<p>2nd lvl
<br />
Combat Reflexes</p>
<p>This his primary battlefield control element. He now has 4 attacks of op at reach.</p>
<p>3rd lvl
<br />
Improved Shield Bash</p>
<p>Armor Training I reduces his ACP by 1. He now only has a -1 to hit with the Bill.</p>
<p>4th lvl
<br />
Weapon Focus: Bill</p>
<p>Now he has no penalty with the Bill</p>
<p>5th lvl
<br />
Stand Still</p>
<p>Successful Op attacks stop movement</p>
<p>Weapon Training I: Polearms</p>
<p>Now he's +1 to hit with the Bill</p>
<p>6th lvl
<br />
Shield Slam</p>
<p>Pushing people back out to range for the Bill</p>
<p>7th lvl
<br />
Iron Will</p>
<p>A little sustain at this level now that spells are flying around a lot more.</p>
<p>Armor Training II. I'll skip the Advanced Training this time around because the reduced ACP also increases my attack. Bill attack is now +2</p>
<p>At this point the primary build is complete. I was thinking of adding Improved Critical to the Bill. Or going for Greater Two Weapon Fighting or Specialization with the Bill. I could also keep stacking Shield tree feats.
<br />
I'd like to improve damage output but I'm not sure what the best way to do that is.</p>
<p>Possibilities
<br />
8th lvl
<br />
Defended Movement</p>
<p>9th lvl
<br />
Vital Strike</p>
<p>10th lvl
<br />
Weapon Speclization: Bill</p>
<p>11th lvl
<br />
Shield Master</p>
<p>Any suggestions Would be appreciated.</p>Building a frontline control fighter using the Shield Brace feat and a Bill (polearm)
So far the build looks like this:
Human STR 17 DEX 16 CON 14 INT 10 WIS 10 CHR 8
1st lvl
Multiweapon Fighting
Shield Focus
Shield Brace
So he walks onto the field with a large steel shield and a Bill wielded in 1 hand braced against his shield (if you ever wondered what that little notch in the Shield is for, that's what it's for).
He takes the Shield ACP -2 to his attack roles with the polearm and he...Cole Cummings2018-07-08T17:08:20ZForums/Pathfinder First Edition: General Discussion: Gods I Hate Confirming Critical Hits!Cole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2uot7?Gods-I-Hate-Confirming-Critical-Hits#12017-10-25T04:16:19Z2017-10-25T03:43:22Z<p>Please get rid of this massively stupid rule! You're rollin in combat and BAM! A Nat20 is rolled and everyone is excited and happy. Then the excitement gets ruined by the confirm. Its just garbage.</p>Please get rid of this massively stupid rule! You're rollin in combat and BAM! A Nat20 is rolled and everyone is excited and happy. Then the excitement gets ruined by the confirm. Its just garbage.Cole Cummings2017-10-25T03:43:22ZRe: Forums: Advice: Is There A List of "Cold" Spells?Cole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2ubd9?Is-There-A-List-of-Cold-Spells#42017-10-15T17:09:29Z2017-10-15T17:09:29Z<p>Your going to have to pick up Elemental Bloodline for the energy type switch ability. Coldball for 6d6 dmg anyone?</p>Your going to have to pick up Elemental Bloodline for the energy type switch ability. Coldball for 6d6 dmg anyone?Cole Cummings2017-10-15T17:09:29ZRe: Forums: Starfinder General Discussion: Sheerin CultureKolek Ztardok (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2une5?Sheerin-Culture#172017-10-11T12:43:47Z2017-10-11T12:43:23Z<p>Imagine living the rest of your life in terror or losing your control to some random person... </p>
<p>In regards to killing my Shirren would see killing as better. It's more like the difference between Murder and Rape. A murder victim is dead. Done and over with. And in a world where the afterlife is a Know Fact. Not so bad. A rape victim however continues to suffer, often for the rest of their lives. Mind control to my Shirren would be the Greater of the two evils.</p>
<p>A good depiction is the Netflix series Jessica Jones.</p>Imagine living the rest of your life in terror or losing your control to some random person...
In regards to killing my Shirren would see killing as better. It's more like the difference between Murder and Rape. A murder victim is dead. Done and over with. And in a world where the afterlife is a Know Fact. Not so bad. A rape victim however continues to suffer, often for the rest of their lives. Mind control to my Shirren would be the Greater of the two evils.
A good depiction is the Netflix...Kolek Ztardok (alias of Cole Cummings)2017-10-11T12:43:23ZForums: Starfinder General Discussion: Sheerin CultureKolek Ztardok (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2une5?Sheerin-Culture#12017-10-05T16:37:42Z2017-10-05T03:41:46Z<p>We're running into some fun cultural quirks with Sheerin characters that I thought might be fun to talk about here. The Sheerin are extremely communal. So communal that they have a racial trait for it. How do you all think this plays out in game? </p>
<p>I play a Sheerin Mystic and in the Starfinder scenario we were in there was a Sheerin in a bar with two mean looking Vesk guards. I saw what the author was trying to do but didn't think they thought it through. Since My Sheerin and the NPC Sheerin were the only two Sheerin in the place it just seemed completely natural for my character to simply walk over and be NEAR the other Sheerin. No words needed to be said. I played it off as simply a natural inclination of the species.
<br />
Also, when drinks were ordered my Sheerin ordered a Bowl of what I ad-libbed as "Zil" (a drink Sheerin like) with five straws, one for each person at the table and 1 extra in case someone wanted to join. I saw this as mimicking the act of sharing resources in a matter of fact way.</p>
<p>How would you interpret Sheerin culture? Ideas? I'd love to hear them.</p>We're running into some fun cultural quirks with Sheerin characters that I thought might be fun to talk about here. The Sheerin are extremely communal. So communal that they have a racial trait for it. How do you all think this plays out in game?
I play a Sheerin Mystic and in the Starfinder scenario we were in there was a Sheerin in a bar with two mean looking Vesk guards. I saw what the author was trying to do but didn't think they thought it through. Since My Sheerin and the NPC Sheerin...Kolek Ztardok (alias of Cole Cummings)2017-10-05T03:41:46ZForums: Pathfinder Society: ID Card Faction ChangeCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2umfl?ID-Card-Faction-Change#12017-09-22T11:41:43Z2017-09-22T11:41:43Z<p>Hi</p>
<p>I want to change the faction symbol on my ID card but can't seem to find a way to do it. Is this even possible? Or am I stuck with Liberty's Edge?</p>Hi
I want to change the faction symbol on my ID card but can't seem to find a way to do it. Is this even possible? Or am I stuck with Liberty's Edge?Cole Cummings2017-09-22T11:41:43ZRe: Forums: Homebrew and House Rules: A Druid Who Loves Nature Would Not Use Summon Nature's Alley Unless DesperateCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2trhc&page=2?A-Druid-Who-Loves-Nature-Would-Not-Use-Summon#652016-08-07T20:00:03Z2016-08-07T20:00:03Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">dragonhunterq wrote:</div><blockquote> <div class="messageboard-quotee">Cole Cummings wrote:</div><blockquote><br />
<br />
I LOVE druids (I am one) </blockquote><p>I see where you are going wrong. Your DnD druid is NOT the same thing as your modern day doodad.
</p>
</blockquote><p>I assume your trying to insult my religion (we get so much of that it's just par for the course honestly •yawn•), but to be honest I don't get your point. I'm talking about Pathfinder druids as described in the Core Rulebook. Not actual druids. Last I checked I couldn't summon a pack of deer to stampede people I didn't like. Not that I would, I have too much respect for the deer.
<p>However the thread has given be some ideas on how to handle this issue. My friends and I are (as you can imagine) respectful of nature on our various paths and the desire to play a true champion of nature in a fantasy setting is something we enjoy.</p>
<p>Here are the helpful suggestions you all have provided:</p>
<p>Spontaneous Casting of all spells
<br />
Spontaneous Casting of a domain spell
<br />
Choosing a different spontaneous spell from the druid list</p>
<p>So what I'm looking for is helpful suggestions. Not Hate.</p>dragonhunterq wrote:Cole Cummings wrote:
I LOVE druids (I am one)
I see where you are going wrong. Your DnD druid is NOT the same thing as your modern day doodad.
I assume your trying to insult my religion (we get so much of that it's just par for the course honestly *yawn*), but to be honest I don't get your point. I'm talking about Pathfinder druids as described in the Core Rulebook. Not actual druids. Last I checked I couldn't summon a pack of deer to stampede people I didn't like. Not...Cole Cummings2016-08-07T20:00:03ZRe: Forums: Homebrew and House Rules: A Druid Who Loves Nature Would Not Use Summon Nature's Alley Unless DesperateCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2trhc&page=2?A-Druid-Who-Loves-Nature-Would-Not-Use-Summon#582016-08-07T19:23:51Z2016-08-07T19:23:51Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Claxon wrote:</div><blockquote><p> Yeah that's not how Summoning spells work. The create a copy of a creature, or at the very least it isn't the "real" creature because it can't die and doesn't take any actual injuries. </p>
<p>Planar Binding and Planar Ally spells are calling spells which actually bring the real creature, but summoning spells are not.</p>
<p>If anything, maybe feel bad about the animal companions which are sent into battle. Of course, the Druid is right there along with them and generally speaking the druid does try to take of his animal companion, even though they often have missions which means risking danger for both of them.</p>
<p>Frankly, any ruling you make which would strip away a classes powers for using them as intended is simply a bad ruling. I don't say this to be rude, but if you really stick to such a ruling you probably shouldn't bother being a GM because you're punishing people for using things as the game intended. </blockquote><p>I LOVE druids (I am one) I just think that they didn't consider what they were doing when they created them. I'm saying that like a Paladin or Cleric they have something they revere and would not simple throw it to the lions. If forced to defend nature. Sure, sacrifice some soldiers. But for treasure, or xp, or a princess etc. Nope.
<p>Personally I would fix this with wild shape at 1st level. Then the only life/pain the druid is risking is their own.</p>Claxon wrote:Yeah that's not how Summoning spells work. The create a copy of a creature, or at the very least it isn't the "real" creature because it can't die and doesn't take any actual injuries.
Planar Binding and Planar Ally spells are calling spells which actually bring the real creature, but summoning spells are not.
If anything, maybe feel bad about the animal companions which are sent into battle. Of course, the Druid is right there along with them and generally speaking the druid...Cole Cummings2016-08-07T19:23:51ZRe: Forums: Homebrew and House Rules: A Druid Who Loves Nature Would Not Use Summon Nature's Alley Unless DesperateCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2trhc&page=2?A-Druid-Who-Loves-Nature-Would-Not-Use-Summon#542016-08-07T19:15:20Z2016-08-07T19:15:20Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Nohwear wrote:</div><blockquote> If one were to follow this logic, then Druids and Hunters should be mortal enemies. After all, Hunters not only dedicate their career to ordering around a displaced animal, but they steal other powers of nature that they clearly have no respect for. </blockquote><p>I also hate animal companions and never opt for this feature for that very reason. I've see so many bosom buddy animal companions scarified in a oh s@$& that sucked guess i'll get another fashion that they are more like edilons (sp) with a longer casting time.Nohwear wrote:If one were to follow this logic, then Druids and Hunters should be mortal enemies. After all, Hunters not only dedicate their career to ordering around a displaced animal, but they steal other powers of nature that they clearly have no respect for.
I also hate animal companions and never opt for this feature for that very reason. I've see so many bosom buddy animal companions scarified in a oh s+$# that sucked guess i'll get another fashion that they are more like edilons (sp)...Cole Cummings2016-08-07T19:15:20ZRe: Forums: Homebrew and House Rules: A Druid Who Loves Nature Would Not Use Summon Nature's Alley Unless DesperateCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2trhc&page=2?A-Druid-Who-Loves-Nature-Would-Not-Use-Summon#532016-08-07T19:12:28Z2016-08-07T19:12:28Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Jeff Morse wrote:</div><blockquote> guessing you feel the same for animal companions, so why not let them spontaneous cast there domain spells. </blockquote><p>Jeff Morse wrote:guessing you feel the same for animal companions, so why not let them spontaneous cast there domain spells.Cole Cummings2016-08-07T19:12:28ZRe: Forums: Homebrew and House Rules: A Druid Who Loves Nature Would Not Use Summon Nature's Alley Unless DesperateCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2trhc&page=2?A-Druid-Who-Loves-Nature-Would-Not-Use-Summon#522016-08-07T19:11:34Z2016-08-07T19:11:34Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">QuidEst wrote:</div><blockquote><p> Whoa there, ease up on the poor Druid. That's not how summoning works. The rules don't really specify where animals being summoned come from exactly, but they are actually safer while being summoned than any other time in their life (assuming they have one and aren't pulled from some Platonic ideal catalog).</p>
<div class="messageboard-quotee">Quote:</div><blockquote>A summoned creature also goes away if it is killed or if its hit points drop to 0 or lower, but it is not really dead. It takes 24 hours for the creature to reform, during which time it can't be summoned again.</blockquote><p>They're about as immortal as the Terrasque for those few rounds of summoning.
<p>Moving on, though, if you're going to make Druid fall for using a class feature as intended, definitely trade it out. Druids already get Wild Shape at 4th level, so maybe you're thinking of an archetype. If the player does take one of those archetypes, moving it back to 4th isn't a bad idea. In most cases, though, I'd recommend allowing spontaneously casting from the <a href="http://www.d20pfsrd.com/feats/general-feats/fey-spell-lore" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">Fey Spell Lore</a> feat's list. While the spell level is a little delayed, the lower level spells stay more useful than the summons do. </blockquote><p>Still causing them Pain. It's unnatural and cruel. Better would be to spontaneously summon human peasants to die horrible deaths for some treasure.QuidEst wrote:Whoa there, ease up on the poor Druid. That's not how summoning works. The rules don't really specify where animals being summoned come from exactly, but they are actually safer while being summoned than any other time in their life (assuming they have one and aren't pulled from some Platonic ideal catalog).
Quote:A summoned creature also goes away if it is killed or if its hit points drop to 0 or lower, but it is not really dead. It takes 24 hours for the creature to reform,...Cole Cummings2016-08-07T19:11:34ZForums: Homebrew and House Rules: A Druid Who Loves Nature Would Not Use Summon Nature's Alley Unless DesperateCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2trhc?A-Druid-Who-Loves-Nature-Would-Not-Use-Summon#12016-07-16T23:14:08Z2016-07-02T17:15:24Z<p>I hate the spontaneous cast of "Summon Nature's Alley". It's just morally wrong to force animals that having nothing to do with you and your situation to fight and potentially die for you. Sure it works mechanically, but if a nature focused druid ever used this spell in my campaign without really good reason, I would slam her like a paladin that throws children at an charging dragon.</p>
<p>My question is:
<br />
Should I replace "Summon Nature's Alley" with another spontaneous cast spell?
<br />
Or just make "Wild Shape" available at lower level (6th lvl is way too long to wait in my opinion for such a core class ability)</p>I hate the spontaneous cast of "Summon Nature's Alley". It's just morally wrong to force animals that having nothing to do with you and your situation to fight and potentially die for you. Sure it works mechanically, but if a nature focused druid ever used this spell in my campaign without really good reason, I would slam her like a paladin that throws children at an charging dragon.
My question is:
Should I replace "Summon Nature's Alley" with another spontaneous cast spell?
Or just make...Cole Cummings2016-07-02T17:15:24ZRe: Forums: Rules Questions: Sundering Armor (HPs?)Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2kr0h?Sundering-Armor#42020-03-30T23:48:58Z2016-04-10T15:05:06Z<p>I've been looking into this myself. The rules are obviously written with things like Doors in mind.</p>
<p>I am Society for Creative Anachronism heavy fighter who fights in steel (Pathfinder) "Half-Plate". I can tell you, my plate armor is not even a 1/4" thick (If it was, I wouldn't be able to move!)</p>
<p>Typically steel body armor is made from 20gauge steel 3/80" (.0375) thickness. But since it's heroic fantasy and we're dealing with medieval steel we'll jack the thickness up to 16gauge 1/16" (.0625) thickness.
<br />
(1/4" would be 3gauge (.25))</p>
<p>Armor hit points is: 5xAC bonus for each INCH of thickness </p>
<p>This would mean that 16gauge Full Plate Armor would be 5x9x.0625"=3HP rounded up.
<br />
1/4" Full Plate (which btw is heavy enough to stop a .45caliber bullet at 20', we tested it :D ) would have a whopping 11hp but only a Dwarf could fight in it. </p>
<p>Plate Armor is very complicated. It's put together with rivets, leather straps, precisely articulated joints and sliding services and is designed to distribute weight across the body so it doesn't unduly hamper movement, or pull swings with momentum. (mine still does, its a huge disadvantage in speed to fight in steel vs. lighter materials)</p>
<p>So Heavy Full Plate Armor, the kind a Jousting Knight would wear, which weighs around 90lbs (from Claude Blair's European Armour Circa 1066-Circa 1700.) but since we've added thickness we'll just say 100lbs. Would be rocking 3HP and a Hardness of 10. </p>
<p>This is more accurate. It reflects the historical movement in tactics, once heavy plate armor was introduced, of attacking a knight's Armor instead of trying to kill the knight himself. Footmen employed Heavy Maces, Picks and Bec de Corbin type weapons specially designed to break the armor of these battlefield juggernauts. Once you get past the Hardness of the armor and damage it the Knight would have to retire from the field to repair his armor.
<br />
Keep in mind that a Heavy Mace does 1d8dmg, a Heavy Pick does 1d6dmg and even the highly specialized 2-handed Bec de Corbin does 1d10. That means only an attacker's STR modifier would have a chance of dealing damage to Full Plate, and only if Max Dmg was rolled on the die.</p>I've been looking into this myself. The rules are obviously written with things like Doors in mind.
I am Society for Creative Anachronism heavy fighter who fights in steel (Pathfinder) "Half-Plate". I can tell you, my plate armor is not even a 1/4" thick (If it was, I wouldn't be able to move!)
Typically steel body armor is made from 20gauge steel 3/80" (.0375) thickness. But since it's heroic fantasy and we're dealing with medieval steel we'll jack the thickness up to 16gauge 1/16" (.0625)...Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)2016-04-10T15:05:06ZRe: Forums: Pathfinder Society: Is PFS roll-play, or role-play?Cole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2puf1&page=2?Is-PFS-rollplay-or-roleplay#512016-02-11T20:06:52Z2016-02-11T14:55:21Z<p>My experience is that PFS has no TIME for role-playing and no rewards for it, so role-playing only makes the run-as-written scenarios likely failures. Your basically snatching defeat from the jaws of victory when you role-play in PFS.</p>My experience is that PFS has no TIME for role-playing and no rewards for it, so role-playing only makes the run-as-written scenarios likely failures. Your basically snatching defeat from the jaws of victory when you role-play in PFS.Cole Cummings2016-02-11T14:55:21ZRe: Forums/Pathfinder First Edition: General Discussion: Which rules (if any) do you find absurd and/or unnecessary?Cole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2qr61&page=25?Which-rules-do-you-find-absurd-andor#12302016-01-02T17:33:05Z2016-01-02T17:33:05Z<p>So far this is what I have for feats for a Shield/Spear fighter, using the large steel shield and a ranseur (reach, disarm) or longspear (reach, brace):
<br />
suggestions are appreciated.</p>
<p>Feat lvl 1
<br />
•Shaft and Shield:• Allows you to wield a "spear-like" two handed weapon in one hand without penalties.
<br />
•Shield Focus:• +1AC with shield, for sustain
<br />
•Combat Reflexes:• to take advantage of the reach of the spear and threaten a huge swath of ground</p>
<p>2nd lvl
<br />
•Improved Shield Bash:• do not lose AC bonus from shield when bashing</p>
<p>3rd lvl
<br />
•Two Weapon Fighting:• now we're doing the "300" thing</p>
<p>4th lvl
<br />
•Lighten Weapon:• reduces the weapon weight class by one. This sharply reduces penalties for 2WFighting by reducing your spear from medium to light.</p>
<p>5th lvl
<br />
•Open slot• (probably add some dmg if your role isn't strictly defensive)
<br />
Personally I want my shield to be my main weapon (so no matter what weapon I'm using I always have my best weapon with me), so I go with Weapon Focus Shield for the +1Att and to optimize my next feat. </p>
<p>6th lvl
<br />
•Shield Slam:• free bull rush with shield bash. Now everyone who gets close gets knocked back and I get a free move if I want to move with them.</p>
<p>So with this progression you should be pwning the (stuff) out of everything in a 10' radius of you.</p>So far this is what I have for feats for a Shield/Spear fighter, using the large steel shield and a ranseur (reach, disarm) or longspear (reach, brace):
suggestions are appreciated.
Feat lvl 1
*Shaft and Shield:* Allows you to wield a "spear-like" two handed weapon in one hand without penalties.
*Shield Focus:* +1AC with shield, for sustain
*Combat Reflexes:* to take advantage of the reach of the spear and threaten a huge swath of ground
2nd lvl
*Improved Shield Bash:* do not lose AC bonus...Cole Cummings2016-01-02T17:33:05ZRe: Forums/Pathfinder First Edition: General Discussion: Which rules (if any) do you find absurd and/or unnecessary?Cole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2qr61&page=25?Which-rules-do-you-find-absurd-andor#12292016-01-02T16:55:47Z2016-01-02T16:55:47Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Lemmy wrote:</div><blockquote><p> There's still a huge difference between "effective" and "possible". Besides, it's not like PF has the most realistic rules for combat.</p>
<p>But whatever, I'm bored with this discussion... Let's move on to the next absurd/unnecessary rule. </blockquote><p>I can tell you from experience (Euro Martial Arts) that 1v1 the shield spear combo is craptastic. And that to have any chance at all you better be wielding a short spear. I have seen pretty effective short shaft polearms (halberds and bills). But that's essentially an Ax with a long handle.Lemmy wrote:There's still a huge difference between "effective" and "possible". Besides, it's not like PF has the most realistic rules for combat.
But whatever, I'm bored with this discussion... Let's move on to the next absurd/unnecessary rule.
I can tell you from experience (Euro Martial Arts) that 1v1 the shield spear combo is craptastic. And that to have any chance at all you better be wielding a short spear. I have seen pretty effective short shaft polearms (halberds and bills). But...Cole Cummings2016-01-02T16:55:47ZRe: Forums/Pathfinder First Edition: General Discussion: Which rules (if any) do you find absurd and/or unnecessary?Cole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2qr61&page=25?Which-rules-do-you-find-absurd-andor#12282016-01-02T16:52:10Z2016-01-02T16:52:10Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">DrDeth wrote:</div><blockquote> <div class="messageboard-quotee">Lemmy wrote:</div><blockquote> <div class="messageboard-quotee">DrDeth wrote:</div><blockquote>Stuff</blockquote><p>There's a pretty large gap between learning the hoplite formation and using spears one-handed.
<p>While that may have been the most effective formation for spear and shield, I doubt every 2nd level Warrior who ever lived would simply forget how to hold his shield and spear because he doesn't have his friends around him.</p>
<p>Even if hoplite troops were the only ones to use spear and shield, I doubt all, or even most of them were 3rd level fighters with one very specific archetype. </blockquote>Again, we're not talking just spear & shield, we're talking LONG spear and shield. </blockquote><p>Shield and Spear was standard gear for a Zulu Warrior.DrDeth wrote:Lemmy wrote: DrDeth wrote:Stuff
There's a pretty large gap between learning the hoplite formation and using spears one-handed. While that may have been the most effective formation for spear and shield, I doubt every 2nd level Warrior who ever lived would simply forget how to hold his shield and spear because he doesn't have his friends around him.
Even if hoplite troops were the only ones to use spear and shield, I doubt all, or even most of them were 3rd level fighters with...Cole Cummings2016-01-02T16:52:10ZForums: Pathfinder Society: Why are Scenarios So Easy?Cole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2rk99?Why-are-Scenarios-So-Easy#12014-10-08T01:32:39Z2014-10-04T14:45:34Z<p>Either I and my players are amazing or these scenarios are really really easy. </p>
<p>I admit I don't play PFS a whole lot. I started back again at a Sci Fi Convention recently were I played my 5th lvl Steel Falcon/Paladin. We were in a house defending a noble from waves of attackers. We spent a good deal of time devising defenses, talking it out and building things to help us. When the bad guys attacked we had one party member who is from what I'm told very experienced with PFS. That party member simply ignored everything we had done and engaged the waves directly, alone. And so we had to join the melee to support. We killed them all. Wave after wave. And barely lost a hit point doing it. Bosses lasted maybe three hits. Minions two at best. It was down right boring and a little annoying to see all that time prepping for the battle have no effect.</p>
<p>I played again last night, a pre-gen Kyla the cleric and it seemed no matter what I did every encounter devolved to combat as the more experienced players ignored the "danger" of the situations and waded in and lopped off heads in a couple of rounds. Again...boring. </p>
<p>Perhaps things will get more interesting past 6th lvl, which my Eagle Knight is now...</p>Either I and my players are amazing or these scenarios are really really easy.
I admit I don't play PFS a whole lot. I started back again at a Sci Fi Convention recently were I played my 5th lvl Steel Falcon/Paladin. We were in a house defending a noble from waves of attackers. We spent a good deal of time devising defenses, talking it out and building things to help us. When the bad guys attacked we had one party member who is from what I'm told very experienced with PFS. That party member...Cole Cummings2014-10-04T14:45:34ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Eagle Knight BusinessSir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2ppo1&page=2?Eagle-Knight-Business#812014-01-03T21:50:14Z2014-01-03T21:50:14Z<p>In gleaming plate and blue and white accented in gold tabard the very image of an Andoran Eagle Knight mounts the steps down from the upstairs private rooms.</p>
<p>"So it is my understanding that the undead are to be "freed" by whatever means necessary.
<br />
Tombs are to be purged of artifacts when evil and purged of evil when good.
<br />
And fellow Pathfinders that are "neutral" in name only are to be thwarted but not killed.</p>
<p>I apologize for my absence, the hills south of the Aspodell Mountains has been seeing an increase in incursions by my former countrymen. I have pushed the corpse of many a Chelixian naive from my lance the last months. Pah! I hate killing men."</p>
<p>He stops to draw a mug of beer from the casks behind the bar and takes a seat with his fellow knights to join the discussion.</p>In gleaming plate and blue and white accented in gold tabard the very image of an Andoran Eagle Knight mounts the steps down from the upstairs private rooms.
"So it is my understanding that the undead are to be "freed" by whatever means necessary.
Tombs are to be purged of artifacts when evil and purged of evil when good.
And fellow Pathfinders that are "neutral" in name only are to be thwarted but not killed.
I apologize for my absence, the hills south of the Aspodell Mountains has been...Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)2014-01-03T21:50:14ZForums: Andoran: Eagle Knight BusinessSir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2ppo1?Eagle-Knight-Business#12013-04-28T15:41:45Z2013-04-28T15:41:45Z<p>Now, My Fellow Knights. What business have we? </p>
<p>In My travels I have run across various "evil" Pathfinders. I realize that one cannot be truly evil to be in the guild but there are many who are "neutral" in word only. In what way could we possibly bring these wayward souls back into the light?</p>
<p>Another issue; Tomb raiding. Desecration of tombs is sacrilege. However , when one is in the tomb of an evil cult or ancient worshipers of fiends what say we on the subject?</p>
<p>Other Business? Please bring it forward.</p>Now, My Fellow Knights. What business have we?
In My travels I have run across various "evil" Pathfinders. I realize that one cannot be truly evil to be in the guild but there are many who are "neutral" in word only. In what way could we possibly bring these wayward souls back into the light?
Another issue; Tomb raiding. Desecration of tombs is sacrilege. However , when one is in the tomb of an evil cult or ancient worshipers of fiends what say we on the subject?
Other Business? Please...Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-04-28T15:41:45ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Eagle KnightsSir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2phr2?Eagle-Knights#302013-04-28T15:11:15Z2013-04-28T15:11:15Z<p>With the Exploration of the Thessalonian Tomb of Wrath (In Wrath's Shadow) I have been Knighted an Eagle Knight of Andoran!</p>With the Exploration of the Thessalonian Tomb of Wrath (In Wrath's Shadow) I have been Knighted an Eagle Knight of Andoran!Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-04-28T15:11:15ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp&page=3?Run-as-written#1072014-11-05T07:59:17Z2013-04-16T12:54:16Z<p>Just wanted to say I'm taking Brock's advice and bowing out of PFS Gming. I've shut down the event I run at my house (2 Tables weekly) and have let all my players know.
<br />
I'm also shutting down the event I was planning on running at SpoCon 2013.</p>
<p>Instead I'll be running Legacy of Fire adventure path.</p>
<p>Funny...my players don't seem to mind that much. They said PFS was kinda flat.</p>
<p>Now they are trying to convince me to let them run evil characters through the adventure path. Not sure how that would work, but anything is possible with imagination :) Cheerio!</p>Just wanted to say I'm taking Brock's advice and bowing out of PFS Gming. I've shut down the event I run at my house (2 Tables weekly) and have let all my players know.
I'm also shutting down the event I was planning on running at SpoCon 2013.
Instead I'll be running Legacy of Fire adventure path.
Funny...my players don't seem to mind that much. They said PFS was kinda flat.
Now they are trying to convince me to let them run evil characters through the adventure path. Not sure how that...Cole Cummings2013-04-16T12:54:16ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp&page=2?Run-as-written#892013-04-13T01:48:36Z2013-04-13T01:48:36Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Michael Brock wrote:</div><blockquote> <div class="messageboard-quotee">Cole Cummings wrote:</div><blockquote><br />
<br />
<p>Whatever happened to "Story Trumps Rules"? I mean really, that's the whole reason I've played this game for almost 20 years.</p>
<p></blockquote><p>The campaign coordinator started receiving emails every week advising a GM had added stuff to a scenario to make it "more challenging", and it had turned into between 1-6 character deaths. Since the GM had run something that was not in the scenario, the players wanted a free raise dead. After several months and a hundred emails or so, enough was enough. If you want artistic license, play a home campaign. I can't stress this enough. You've advised the same thing several times and it is time to move on. It isn't going to change,
<p>PFS has a stricter set of guidelines. I have a weekly home game I GM and we don't use PFS. I like to use creative license to give my home players a challenge and experience. I don't use that same creative license in PFS. It isn't fair to players and other GMs. </blockquote><p>OK since we're moving on. What's the point of having a discussion on •Run As Written• if someone (I assume with authority) is going to come in put his foot down and say "moving on!"
<p>Why don't you just delete the thread then. If there is no counter point to a discussion there is no discussion. Or do you just prefer we all sit around and agree with each other (and you)?</p>
<p>Your not looking for ideas or solutions. Your just saying "That's it, My Way!" </p>
<p>I kinda see that everyone disagrees with me. I'm not trying to win the debate, I'm trying to present the way people may feel. Maybe get a system in place to allow a GM a little wiggle room. But no. We're going to "move on" and not even allow for discussion. Curious, since this is the "Run As Written" thread, where exactly are we moving on to? Since the discussion is now over.</p>Michael Brock wrote:Cole Cummings wrote:Whatever happened to "Story Trumps Rules"? I mean really, that's the whole reason I've played this game for almost 20 years.
The campaign coordinator started receiving emails every week advising a GM had added stuff to a scenario to make it "more challenging", and it had turned into between 1-6 character deaths. Since the GM had run something that was not in the scenario, the players wanted a free raise dead. After several months and a hundred emails...Cole Cummings2013-04-13T01:48:36ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp&page=2?Run-as-written#812013-04-12T03:23:41Z2013-04-12T03:23:41Z<p>meh...</p>
<p>No artistic license = no fun.</p>
<p>I run a PFS game at my house and everyone (including Fox) enjoys themselves. I really wish you guys hadn't taken the wind out of my sails. I thought I was doing a good job, creating a dramatic in depth experiance for my players. Now, I'm kinda dreading it for fear of screwing up RAW.</p>
<p>Whatever happened to "Story Trumps Rules"? I mean really, that's the whole reason I've played this game for almost 20 years.</p>meh...
No artistic license = no fun.
I run a PFS game at my house and everyone (including Fox) enjoys themselves. I really wish you guys hadn't taken the wind out of my sails. I thought I was doing a good job, creating a dramatic in depth experiance for my players. Now, I'm kinda dreading it for fear of screwing up RAW.
Whatever happened to "Story Trumps Rules"? I mean really, that's the whole reason I've played this game for almost 20 years.Cole Cummings2013-04-12T03:23:41ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Eagle KnightsSir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2phr2?Eagle-Knights#282013-04-12T02:50:47Z2013-04-12T02:50:47Z<p>It is up to the individual to decide what laws are unjust and take what actions, if any, should be taken. And of course bare the responsibility for those actions. That is the price of Freedom.</p>
<p>A "slave" is someone who is being held against their will. If they would rather stay they are not slaves but are choosing to exchange servitude for whatever the "owner" offers. We Eagle Knights seek to free people that wish to be freed. I contend that given the choice, nine people out of ten will choose freedom over servitude. I mean to make sure those nine have that choice.</p>It is up to the individual to decide what laws are unjust and take what actions, if any, should be taken. And of course bare the responsibility for those actions. That is the price of Freedom.
A "slave" is someone who is being held against their will. If they would rather stay they are not slaves but are choosing to exchange servitude for whatever the "owner" offers. We Eagle Knights seek to free people that wish to be freed. I contend that given the choice, nine people out of ten will...Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-04-12T02:50:47ZForums: Shadow Lodge: A New ArrivalLyrin the Archaeologist (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pnru?A-New-Arrival#12017-02-20T15:55:59Z2013-04-12T01:50:53Z<p><i>A tall Linnorm woman uncharacteristically slouched, peering from beneath the cowl of her firm trimmed cloak.</i></p>
<p>Hello? Is anyone here?</p>A tall Linnorm woman uncharacteristically slouched, peering from beneath the cowl of her firm trimmed cloak.
Hello? Is anyone here?Lyrin the Archaeologist (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-04-12T01:50:53ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Loot ListsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pnkw?Loot-Lists#82013-04-11T00:11:44Z2013-04-11T00:11:44Z<p>Thanks.</p>
<p>My Players were looking at me fairly dubiously when I handed them those Chronicler Sheets.</p>Thanks.
My Players were looking at me fairly dubiously when I handed them those Chronicler Sheets.Cole Cummings2013-04-11T00:11:44ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Loot ListsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pnkw?Loot-Lists#32013-04-10T13:07:00Z2013-04-10T13:07:00Z<p>Thanks.</p>
<p>So just to clarify; By defeating an enemy and gaining a magic item there is no reward? No discount on cost? Nothing like that? Seems unfair to the players.</p>Thanks.
So just to clarify; By defeating an enemy and gaining a magic item there is no reward? No discount on cost? Nothing like that? Seems unfair to the players.Cole Cummings2013-04-10T13:07:00ZForums: GM Discussion: Loot ListsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pnkw?Loot-Lists#12013-04-10T12:57:46Z2013-04-10T12:57:46Z<p>I just ran The Devil We Know Part I: Shipyard Rats and my players did excellent although they almost died as a group during one battle, burning a lot of resources to stay alive.
<br />
When the adventure was over I printed off the Chronicler Sheet and it said in the Items Block "No Additional Items". Does that mean there are No Items for the adventure? Or does it mean I have to hand write them in?</p>I just ran The Devil We Know Part I: Shipyard Rats and my players did excellent although they almost died as a group during one battle, burning a lot of resources to stay alive.
When the adventure was over I printed off the Chronicler Sheet and it said in the Items Block "No Additional Items". Does that mean there are No Items for the adventure? Or does it mean I have to hand write them in?Cole Cummings2013-04-10T12:57:46ZForums: Sczarni: We've Been BusyFiadhaich (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pn7l?Weve-Been-Busy#12013-04-07T02:41:43Z2013-04-07T02:41:43Z<p>So much happening all at once it's almost like the Rune Lords have returned to Thassilonia...or have they?</p>
<p>Listen brethren, hear me. We have an opportunity here and we've been quick to grab it. Under the Family's guidance we have made some coin and some friends but what are we really doing helping Pathfinders plunder our lands? While you explore with the southerners don't forget to take back our artifacts. They are ours after all.
<br />
And remember, good help is a Sczarni caravan away. We should push to have every Lodge House staffed by Sczarni. Especially Sczarni women (because who wouldn't want that?)
<br />
With the Pathfinders help we could clear out some more troublesome areas as well...like clearing Korvosa of Cheliax. Especially those annoying Hell Knights.</p>So much happening all at once it's almost like the Rune Lords have returned to Thassilonia...or have they?
Listen brethren, hear me. We have an opportunity here and we've been quick to grab it. Under the Family's guidance we have made some coin and some friends but what are we really doing helping Pathfinders plunder our lands? While you explore with the southerners don't forget to take back our artifacts. They are ours after all.
And remember, good help is a Sczarni caravan away. We should...Fiadhaich (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-04-07T02:41:43ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Eagle KnightsSir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2phr2?Eagle-Knights#242013-04-07T02:16:27Z2013-04-07T02:16:27Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Vernar wrote:</div><blockquote><p> Eagle Knights !!!
</p>
You never change always to eager to follow orders, never to question or reinterpret them.
<br />
Thats why I left, lets call it a difference of opinion, just because I used fireballs to free slaves from their servitude sending them onto there true reward. They said no you've got to drag them around and tend them, feed them, cloth them.
<br />
Really! who wants those weak willed loosers hanging around if their not prepared to help themselves rise from their situation ,why should I have to be burdened with them.
<br />
The Strong survive and learn to fight for their freedom......
<br />
The lesson is harsh but the rewards are great .</p>
<p>Former Eagle Knight
<br />
Vernar </blockquote><p>A Shame you feel that way. Most slaves just want a chance at a normal happy life. Why not help them achieve that? Are you so busy? Or so cruel.
<p>I agree with you about the following orders though. Sometimes orders, such as in the realm of unjust laws, are not to be followed. Of course there is a price to being part of the organization. Sometimes that is following orders that are against your personal interpretation of the situation.</p>Vernar wrote:Eagle Knights !!!
You never change always to eager to follow orders, never to question or reinterpret them.
Thats why I left, lets call it a difference of opinion, just because I used fireballs to free slaves from their servitude sending them onto there true reward. They said no you've got to drag them around and tend them, feed them, cloth them.
Really! who wants those weak willed loosers hanging around if their not prepared to help themselves rise from their situation ,why...Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-04-07T02:16:27ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Eagle KnightsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2phr2?Eagle-Knights#232013-04-07T02:10:19Z2013-04-07T02:10:19Z<p>Yeah I was looking at it.</p>
<p>I actually can't buy the Prestige class yet.</p>
<p>I'm 4th level and I need to have Diplomacy and Sense Motive 5. Can't get that for 1 more level. Then I'm in the Prestige Class.</p>Yeah I was looking at it.
I actually can't buy the Prestige class yet.
I'm 4th level and I need to have Diplomacy and Sense Motive 5. Can't get that for 1 more level. Then I'm in the Prestige Class.Cole Cummings2013-04-07T02:10:19ZRe: Forums: Pathfinder Society: Where are all the dwarves?Fiadhaich (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2phzb?Where-are-all-the-dwarves#472013-04-06T23:09:59Z2013-04-06T23:09:59Z<p>I'm a dwarf bard. I lobbied for a Nine Kingdoms faction but no one really thought much of it.</p>
<p>I love dwarf adventures. Who else makes the best of the best archaeological dungeon crawls?</p>I'm a dwarf bard. I lobbied for a Nine Kingdoms faction but no one really thought much of it.
I love dwarf adventures. Who else makes the best of the best archaeological dungeon crawls?Fiadhaich (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-04-06T23:09:59ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp&page=2?Run-as-written#582013-04-06T20:45:01Z2013-04-06T20:45:01Z<p>Well it seems the consensus is against me. So run as is... •sigh• and the Bard in me dies a little :(</p>Well it seems the consensus is against me. So run as is... *sigh* and the Bard in me dies a little :(Cole Cummings2013-04-06T20:45:01ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp&page=2?Run-as-written#532013-04-06T17:49:11Z2013-04-06T17:49:11Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Drogon wrote:</div><blockquote><p> So, my reading comprehension skills must be at a low point, today. I can't for the life of me figure out what "mistake" you made that you were able to pull yourself out of by going against the idea of "run as written." </p>
<p>What, exactly, happened? </blockquote><p>I mistakenly set up the encounter with the tier 4-5 encounter instead of the tier 1-3 encounter. So I dropped the monsters hit points and melee attack modifier to compensate. The tier 4-5 monster had already hit them several times so I couldn't tweak that without being obvious so I left the damage the same.Drogon wrote:So, my reading comprehension skills must be at a low point, today. I can't for the life of me figure out what "mistake" you made that you were able to pull yourself out of by going against the idea of "run as written."
What, exactly, happened?
I mistakenly set up the encounter with the tier 4-5 encounter instead of the tier 1-3 encounter. So I dropped the monsters hit points and melee attack modifier to compensate. The tier 4-5 monster had already hit them several times so I...Cole Cummings2013-04-06T17:49:11ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp&page=2?Run-as-written#512013-04-06T17:40:57Z2013-04-06T17:40:57Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Purple Fluffy CatBunnyGnome wrote:</div><blockquote><p> Hey guys ... I get that you're passionate about your positions, however, this may be something better taken to a private conversation :)</p>
<p>kk thanks. </blockquote><p>Actually no Purple. It is exactly in the right place. We're using an example to illustrate both sides of the discussion.
<p>GMs make mistakes sometimes. In the absence of a rules system for guidance we have to wing it. That leaves some players "annoyed". I would prefer there was some kind of guideline that could be redressed in those instances, so my players didn't leave the table unhappy.</p>
<p>Alternatively, I don't want my players leaving the table bored. or leaving it thinking "why do I bother" because some tweaked out optimized character did the whole thing while everyone else just sat there as hero support.</p>
<p>Of course we could just go with your idea of don't mess with it. In that case it's just a matter of not sitting down at the table of a GM you know isn't your type. But, well, isn't the point of PFS to be that games and players are supposed to be interchangeable?</p>Purple Fluffy CatBunnyGnome wrote:Hey guys ... I get that you're passionate about your positions, however, this may be something better taken to a private conversation :)
kk thanks.
Actually no Purple. It is exactly in the right place. We're using an example to illustrate both sides of the discussion. GMs make mistakes sometimes. In the absence of a rules system for guidance we have to wing it. That leaves some players "annoyed". I would prefer there was some kind of guideline that could be...Cole Cummings2013-04-06T17:40:57ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp?Run-as-written#472013-04-06T17:12:01Z2013-04-06T17:12:01Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">The Fox wrote:</div><blockquote> <div class="messageboard-quotee">Cole Cummings wrote:</div><blockquote><p> Was it? Did you feel elation and a sense of accomplishment after the adventure was over?
</p>
</blockquote><p>Actually Cole, no. I have known for a while about the Tier 4-5 thing. I was rather annoyed if you must know. But since you brought it up...
<p>This is exactly what people are trying to warn you against: putting the PCs up against too big of a challenge, then needing to dial the challenge back so that they don't die. That doesn't provide me with a sense of accomplishment. That provides me with a sense of "the GM wanted someone to drop to 0 hp, then declare us the winner." It provides me with a sense of "why am I even here if the GM just wants to tell stories?"</p>
<p>If you want to challenge my characters more, then I won't bring my paladin to your game. I will bring my monk. He has 5 hp, and uses shuriken. </blockquote><p>It was a MISTAKE Fox. I didn't do it on purpose. However I used "tweaking" to fix that mistake without stealing the moment from the players.
<p>Alternatively I could have stopped the combat and reset. Apologized for my mistake and restarted the encounter with the party knowing that there was a monster there and that it was much weaker then the monster they were actually defeating.</p>
<p>Rules wise that's what I should have done.</p>
<p>Of course it would have sucked. Feeling of accomplishment ruined. Atmosphere ruined. </p>
<p>What's more important?</p>The Fox wrote:Cole Cummings wrote:Was it? Did you feel elation and a sense of accomplishment after the adventure was over?
Actually Cole, no. I have known for a while about the Tier 4-5 thing. I was rather annoyed if you must know. But since you brought it up... This is exactly what people are trying to warn you against: putting the PCs up against too big of a challenge, then needing to dial the challenge back so that they don't die. That doesn't provide me with a sense of accomplishment....Cole Cummings2013-04-06T17:12:01ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp?Run-as-written#442013-04-06T16:43:18Z2013-04-06T16:43:18Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Drogon wrote:</div><blockquote><p> Pertinent to this discussion I think is the fact that GMs are <b>supposed</b> to "lose" in order for everyone else to have fun. </p>
<p>If, instead, you find that you are competitive and have a need to win, then GMing (and likely role playing games, in general) are not for you. Luckily, there are tons of good choices for other fun games, many of them games where you can happily pursue the goal of crushing your opponents. </blockquote><p>HA! Ha! yeah...GMs are supposed to lose. I know that. It's only annoying to me when I feel like my losing has stolen the moment from the fun of the players. A too easy encounter can be just as blah as losing the fight.Drogon wrote:Pertinent to this discussion I think is the fact that GMs are supposed to "lose" in order for everyone else to have fun.
If, instead, you find that you are competitive and have a need to win, then GMing (and likely role playing games, in general) are not for you. Luckily, there are tons of good choices for other fun games, many of them games where you can happily pursue the goal of crushing your opponents.
HA! Ha! yeah...GMs are supposed to lose. I know that. It's only annoying...Cole Cummings2013-04-06T16:43:18ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp?Run-as-written#422013-04-06T16:32:29Z2013-04-06T16:32:29Z<p>Was it? Did you feel elation and a sense of accomplishment after the adventure was over? </p>
<p>Here's why (The Veteran's Vault spoilers):
<br />
[Spoiler omitted]</p>
<p>GMs need to have the reigns slacked a bit to make it fun for Them. We're not robots. Well, some of us are, but not me. I'm a story teller. I want my stories to be engrossing. I try to pull my players into the story and create real emotional response. Pathfinder is more then a board game. </p>
<p>That said I realize there needs to be fair rules for GMs to be able to change things as needed to enhance the experience while keeping the rules lawyers happy.</p>Was it? Did you feel elation and a sense of accomplishment after the adventure was over?
Here's why (The Veteran's Vault spoilers):
[Spoiler omitted]
GMs need to have the reigns slacked a bit to make it fun for Them. We're not robots. Well, some of us are, but not me. I'm a story teller. I want my stories to be engrossing. I try to pull my players into the story and create real emotional response. Pathfinder is more then a board game.
That said I realize there needs to be fair rules for...Cole Cummings2013-04-06T16:32:29ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp?Run-as-written#342013-04-06T15:28:41Z2013-04-06T15:28:41Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">The Fox wrote:</div><blockquote> To be fair, Cole, (1) we had a very powerful party, and (2) were it not for a poor roll by Preston in the last round, my character would have been bleeding out. She took 18 damage in those two rounds and was quite lucky to not take 8 more. </blockquote><p>Fox, we had an average party from my experience. Most Players min/max their toons and they are just too much for NPCs. The balance just isn't there. There needs to be an official (since people will otherwise complain) for GMs to tweak the adventures to make them more balanced with optimized characters.The Fox wrote:To be fair, Cole, (1) we had a very powerful party, and (2) were it not for a poor roll by Preston in the last round, my character would have been bleeding out. She took 18 damage in those two rounds and was quite lucky to not take 8 more.
Fox, we had an average party from my experience. Most Players min/max their toons and they are just too much for NPCs. The balance just isn't there. There needs to be an official (since people will otherwise complain) for GMs to tweak the...Cole Cummings2013-04-06T15:28:41ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Run as writtenCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmxp?Run-as-written#322014-04-03T20:36:01Z2013-04-06T15:07:12Z<p>Well if we HAVE TO run as written, can we get some scenarios that aren't ridiculously easy? I just played a scenario that was "played up" from tier 1-2 to tier 4-5 (average character level 3) and the party smoked it without taking more then 10 points of damage.</p>
<p>So far, what I've seen is "as written" means; "marshmellow walk through." The only thing that keeps it interesting is the role playing parts (incidently the only part of the adventure that I can ad lib for dramatic effect.)</p>
<p>Maybe give GMs a point spread they can spend to "tweak" an encounter?</p>
<p>Maybe give GMs the ability to change one feat on an NPC?</p>
<p>Maybe give GMs the ability to add/subtract identical enemies depending on how easy/hard it is for the party?</p>Well if we HAVE TO run as written, can we get some scenarios that aren't ridiculously easy? I just played a scenario that was "played up" from tier 1-2 to tier 4-5 (average character level 3) and the party smoked it without taking more then 10 points of damage.
So far, what I've seen is "as written" means; "marshmellow walk through." The only thing that keeps it interesting is the role playing parts (incidently the only part of the adventure that I can ad lib for dramatic effect.)
Maybe...Cole Cummings2013-04-06T15:07:12ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Eagle KnightsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2phr2?Eagle-Knights#212013-04-06T06:56:13Z2013-04-06T06:56:13Z<p>OK I've got the 20 Fame/20 Prestige. I can buy Eagle Knight now.</p>
<p>Now what?</p>OK I've got the 20 Fame/20 Prestige. I can buy Eagle Knight now.
Now what?Cole Cummings2013-04-06T06:56:13ZRe: Forums: Pathfinder Society: Table MakeupCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pio9?Table-Makeup#392013-04-05T00:00:08Z2013-04-05T00:00:08Z<p>This one is easy to solve. Play a Cleric. No one will every complain about having too many clerics. Why? Because clerics can do Everything.</p>This one is easy to solve. Play a Cleric. No one will every complain about having too many clerics. Why? Because clerics can do Everything.Cole Cummings2013-04-05T00:00:08ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Are We About Individual Freedom?Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmej?Are-We-About-Individual-Freedom#92013-04-04T13:58:36Z2013-04-04T13:58:36Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Oxirane wrote:</div><blockquote> If I remember right, they were using child slaves to make the drug, so that's certainly a good reason to put a stop to it. And many people would consider addiction a kind of slavery. </blockquote><p>You can not justify curtailing your own people's freedom because Kings elsewhere enslave their children.Oxirane wrote:If I remember right, they were using child slaves to make the drug, so that's certainly a good reason to put a stop to it. And many people would consider addiction a kind of slavery.
You can not justify curtailing your own people's freedom because Kings elsewhere enslave their children.Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-04-04T13:58:36ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Are We About Individual Freedom?Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmej?Are-We-About-Individual-Freedom#62013-04-02T12:03:54Z2013-04-02T12:03:54Z<p>I was born in Cheliax, even served in the Cheliax army. I saw the rise of Thrune. Tyranny often starts with "good" intentions for people who "need to have decisions made for them for their own good". It is a slippery slope.</p>I was born in Cheliax, even served in the Cheliax army. I saw the rise of Thrune. Tyranny often starts with "good" intentions for people who "need to have decisions made for them for their own good". It is a slippery slope.Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-04-02T12:03:54ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Are We About Individual Freedom?Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmej?Are-We-About-Individual-Freedom#32013-04-01T23:41:21Z2013-04-01T23:41:21Z<p>Well I followed orders. But the Faction will get a ear full about this.</p>Well I followed orders. But the Faction will get a ear full about this.Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-04-01T23:41:21ZForums: Andoran: Are We About Individual Freedom?Cole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pmej?Are-We-About-Individual-Freedom#12013-03-30T13:34:32Z2013-03-30T13:34:32Z<p>I just played "My Enemey's Enemy" and My Andoran Faction mission was to help Andoran bust drug traffickers. Huh? Andoran is supposed to be about freedom! What business is it of mine if someone in Andoran wants to take "pesh"? I don't think this faction mission should be in the scenario. It's waaay too close to actual real world politics. </p>I just played "My Enemey's Enemy" and My Andoran Faction mission was to help Andoran bust drug traffickers. Huh? Andoran is supposed to be about freedom! What business is it of mine if someone in Andoran wants to take "pesh"? I don't think this faction mission should be in the scenario. It's waaay too close to actual real world politics. Cole Cummings2013-03-30T13:34:32ZRe: Forums: Pathfinder Society Scenario Submissions: PFS Quests: Rewards & IdeasCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2p4nd?PFS-Quests-Rewards-Ideas#72013-03-29T14:04:59Z2013-03-29T14:04:59Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Curaigh wrote:</div><blockquote><p> I like the quest credits idea (maybe sticking it with three=1 for consistency). Another option would be Prestige points (also 3qc=1pp), but that no fame is earned. That is you get pp up to your fame only & encourage a refilling of the barrel so to speak. </p>
<p>Also quests for smaller groups (or even solo) would be good. Sometimes we end up with odd numbers. </blockquote><p>I like the "refill the barrel" idea A LOT.
<p>I was looking at Quests thinking, this would be a really good way to up the play of Factions in the Society. Creating Quests marketed towards the various Factions for 1pp each and no fame. By being able to refill your PP people would use their prestige instead of just forgetting about it until something horrible happens. With the additional interaction, people would start to identify with their Factions more. 1PP would be a winning concept.
<br />
(it would also cause the factions to start recruiting which could be interesting. "Hey Joe, why don't you make a Taldor character and do this one little mission with me...")</p>Curaigh wrote:I like the quest credits idea (maybe sticking it with three=1 for consistency). Another option would be Prestige points (also 3qc=1pp), but that no fame is earned. That is you get pp up to your fame only & encourage a refilling of the barrel so to speak.
Also quests for smaller groups (or even solo) would be good. Sometimes we end up with odd numbers.
I like the "refill the barrel" idea A LOT. I was looking at Quests thinking, this would be a really good way to up the play of...Cole Cummings2013-03-29T14:04:59ZForums: Pathfinder Society: Quests as Faction MissionsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2pm4l?Quests-as-Faction-Missions#12013-03-27T20:22:41Z2013-03-27T20:22:41Z<p>I just had a interesting idea. What if we set up PFS "Quests" as Faction specific missions that award 1PA?</p>
<p>Then Paizo could market them specifically to the Factions.</p>I just had a interesting idea. What if we set up PFS "Quests" as Faction specific missions that award 1PA?
Then Paizo could market them specifically to the Factions.Cole Cummings2013-03-27T20:22:41ZRe: Forums: Pathfinder Society: Quest rewards seem a bit too weak to be of valueCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2m6ft?Quest-rewards-seem-a-bit-too-weak-to-be-of-value#72013-03-27T20:13:24Z2013-03-27T20:13:24Z<p>I'd say a single one time use item would be a suitable reward.</p>
<p>it would be an oportunity to introduce more scrolls of "X" into the game. I know my Wizard is always searching for scrolls. There just arn't alot floating around.</p>
<p>Or maybe a single potion of "X" useable once then "mark it off your chronicle sheet"</p>I'd say a single one time use item would be a suitable reward.
it would be an oportunity to introduce more scrolls of "X" into the game. I know my Wizard is always searching for scrolls. There just arn't alot floating around.
Or maybe a single potion of "X" useable once then "mark it off your chronicle sheet"Cole Cummings2013-03-27T20:13:24ZRe: Forums: Osirion: Osirion Season 4 Faction GoalsEnslave (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2okv1?Osirion-Season-4-Faction-Goals#272013-03-02T16:09:30Z2013-03-02T16:09:30Z<p>I have recovered a book on Transmutations from the city of Magnimar and sent it off to our esteemed Faction leader.
<br />
I am new to the faction and am at a loss to understand the dynamics of this whole jostling for power. I bear the Ruby Prince no ill will, and hope that he recovers his...composition.</p>I have recovered a book on Transmutations from the city of Magnimar and sent it off to our esteemed Faction leader.
I am new to the faction and am at a loss to understand the dynamics of this whole jostling for power. I bear the Ruby Prince no ill will, and hope that he recovers his...composition.Enslave (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-03-02T16:09:30ZRe: Forums: GM Discussion: Sanctioned Modules QuestionsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2ocgi?Sanctioned-Modules-Questions#92013-03-01T15:11:08Z2013-03-01T15:11:08Z<p>This has been very informative. Thank you all for the discussion. It answered all of my questions on running sanctioned modules (so far)</p>
<p>I'm planning on running Crypt of the Everflame at SpoCon this year. I might run something else. But Crypt is just a really good dungeon crawl. Perfect for new players.</p>This has been very informative. Thank you all for the discussion. It answered all of my questions on running sanctioned modules (so far)
I'm planning on running Crypt of the Everflame at SpoCon this year. I might run something else. But Crypt is just a really good dungeon crawl. Perfect for new players.Cole Cummings2013-03-01T15:11:08ZRe: Forums: Grand Lodge: Grand Lodge Season 4 Faction GoalsFiadhaich (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2okuy?Grand-Lodge-Season-4-Faction-Goals#192013-02-25T10:44:54Z2013-02-25T10:44:54Z<p>I'm new here so let me just concentrate on the work and let all you movers and shakers deal with all your respective rivalries. </p>
<p>Trotter...have I seen you before? You seem familiar.</p>
<p>Hey! I'm Just New Here
<br />
So I'll just concentrate
<br />
I'll go to Magnimar
<br />
Run into the Consortium, maybe</p>
<p>ugh! That's terrible...</p>I'm new here so let me just concentrate on the work and let all you movers and shakers deal with all your respective rivalries.
Trotter...have I seen you before? You seem familiar.
Hey! I'm Just New Here
So I'll just concentrate
I'll go to Magnimar
Run into the Consortium, maybe
ugh! That's terrible...Fiadhaich (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-02-25T10:44:54ZRe: Forums: Qadira: Qadira Season 4 Faction GoalsLyrin the Archaeologist (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2okv2?Qadira-Season-4-Faction-Goals#72013-02-21T21:16:53Z2013-02-21T21:16:53Z<p>Gold can always be found in the company of dwarves even if they grasp it tightly. Count me in.</p>
<p>I'm none to keen on roaming the land of vampires though. The pay better be worth it.</p>Gold can always be found in the company of dwarves even if they grasp it tightly. Count me in.
I'm none to keen on roaming the land of vampires though. The pay better be worth it.Lyrin the Archaeologist (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-02-21T21:16:53ZRe: Forums: Silver Crusade: Silver Crusade Season 4 Faction GoalsVarsteiner (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2okv8?Silver-Crusade-Season-4-Faction-Goals#362013-02-21T16:56:07Z2013-02-21T16:56:07Z<p>I have a friend who is an Andoran. He mentioned that his faction was heading to Magnimar as well. It would seem that our two factions are closely aligned this campaign season.</p>
<p>I know very little of this part of the world. I have heard that Varisia is full of vampires. And Chaliax is full of devils. It would seem that if a people wanted to be good this is a very dangerous place to be. We will need ships to support them. And the good graces of the elves to the north. Perhaps we should first start there with our endeavors.</p>
<p>As it is written in <i>The Birth of Light & Truth</i>; "Let us not falter in the sewing and stewardship of the seeds of mighty oaks."</p>I have a friend who is an Andoran. He mentioned that his faction was heading to Magnimar as well. It would seem that our two factions are closely aligned this campaign season.
I know very little of this part of the world. I have heard that Varisia is full of vampires. And Chaliax is full of devils. It would seem that if a people wanted to be good this is a very dangerous place to be. We will need ships to support them. And the good graces of the elves to the north. Perhaps we should first...Varsteiner (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-02-21T16:56:07ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Andoran Season 4 Faction GoalsSir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2okut?Andoran-Season-4-Faction-Goals#282013-02-21T16:29:39Z2013-02-21T16:29:39Z<p>I always liked that part of the country. Tis cool on the armor.
<br />
I will travel north then to support the Magnimarian's quest for freedom. Already I am aship sailing back from Xian Tia having successfully reactivated the braid of One Hundred Masters (and one dwarf) for the Society.</p>
<p>SWORDS BRIGHT!</p>I always liked that part of the country. Tis cool on the armor.
I will travel north then to support the Magnimarian's quest for freedom. Already I am aship sailing back from Xian Tia having successfully reactivated the braid of One Hundred Masters (and one dwarf) for the Society.
SWORDS BRIGHT!Sir Roland Peredren (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-02-21T16:29:39ZRe: Forums: Osirion: Osirion Season 4 Faction GoalsEnslave (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2okv1?Osirion-Season-4-Faction-Goals#222013-02-21T16:15:57Z2013-02-21T16:15:57Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Amenopheus wrote:</div><blockquote><p> Subject of the Ruby Prince,</p>
<p>It is with a sad and worried heart that I bear to you ill tidings of our most esteemed ruler, the Ruby Prince Khemet III. A month ago, while enjoying a visit to an exhibit of antiquities in Sothis, he stepped away from the many Osirian relics on display and took particular interest in several artifacts from ancient Thassilon. Among them was a statuette of the goddess Lissala—a long forgotten deity of runes, obedience, and fate.</p>
<p>Oh, but was fate not twisted that day. For no sooner had he set the statue down than it crumbled to dust in his hand, seemingly turning the Ruby Prince’s arm to a dried husk in the same instant. Only a moment later, as the Risen Guard rushed to his aid, his face took on a terrible pallor as though it were turning to ash, and flakes of his once radiant skin began to slough from his cheeks like pieces of parchment blown by a raging sandstorm.</p>
<p>Between his own powers of healing and the arcane knowledge of Sothis’s best wizards and sorcerers, the Ruby Prince was able to stave off much of the quickening deterioration, and even restore some of the heavier damage to his mortal form. But to date no cure to his condition has been discovered, and there is only so long he can hold its effects at bay.</p>
<p>But the problem is worse than that, dear friend, for the Lissalan idol that seems to have caused this curse was brought from Varisia to Sothis by a Pathfinder, a promising young agent who I had taken under my wing. It was I who urged her to impress the Ruby Prince with relics of an empire older and ultimately more feeble than Osirion itself. And since I was indirectly the cause of the Ruby Prince’s interaction with that damned idol, he rightfully blames me for his condition. If I am unable to find its source and, more importantly, a cure—and find them quickly—he has promised that my time serving the Osirian throne will be at an end.</p>
<p>Thus I need you, who are more able to explore the ruins of ancient Thassilon, to search for lore on Lissala and the magic she and... </blockquote><p>Do not blame me, I am neither from Varisia or a female.
</p>
However I do have a question. Who replaces the Ruby Prince? Once he's dead. I find human lives so short that it's curious, the scrambling of ants on the ant hill.</p>Amenopheus wrote:Subject of the Ruby Prince,
It is with a sad and worried heart that I bear to you ill tidings of our most esteemed ruler, the Ruby Prince Khemet III. A month ago, while enjoying a visit to an exhibit of antiquities in Sothis, he stepped away from the many Osirian relics on display and took particular interest in several artifacts from ancient Thassilon. Among them was a statuette of the goddess Lissala—a long forgotten deity of runes, obedience, and fate.
Oh, but was fate...Enslave (alias of Cole Cummings)2013-02-21T16:15:57ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Eagle KnightsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2phr2?Eagle-Knights#182013-02-19T18:55:14Z2013-02-19T18:55:14Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">LazarX wrote:</div><blockquote> <div class="messageboard-quotee">Sior wrote:</div><blockquote> <div class="messageboard-quotee">Matthew Pittard wrote:</div><blockquote> Sior: Thanks, I did know that. Im generally not a fan of prestige classes (and in Pathfinder they generally seem weaker than 3.5 varieties). That particular prestige class has limited in game scope (in terms of society play) </blockquote>I just think it's something to note, since I do know some people who will insist you can't call yourself something if you don't have the crunch to back it up. </blockquote>Not all Steel Falcons will be members of the Steel Falcon PrC. But they won't be announcing themselves as such, anymore than someone from the CIA, KGB, or MI6 would. </blockquote><p>I took the Cavalier miniature and painted it in Adoran Eagle Knight Heraldry: https://plus.google.com/117616742805278681834/posts?hl=en
<p>Pretty impossible for anyone that knows the factions to miss me. LOL! :D</p>LazarX wrote:Sior wrote: Matthew Pittard wrote: Sior: Thanks, I did know that. Im generally not a fan of prestige classes (and in Pathfinder they generally seem weaker than 3.5 varieties). That particular prestige class has limited in game scope (in terms of society play)
I just think it's something to note, since I do know some people who will insist you can't call yourself something if you don't have the crunch to back it up. Not all Steel Falcons will be members of the Steel Falcon PrC....Cole Cummings2013-02-19T18:55:14ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Eagle KnightsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2phr2?Eagle-Knights#162013-02-19T14:41:55Z2013-02-19T14:41:55Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">Matthew Pittard wrote:</div><blockquote><br />
<br />
<p>As the Pathfinder Society Field Guide is now part of the 'required' items for play, you should see about getting that asap. </blockquote><p>I can't say I appreciate being 'required' to buy things to play in the society. $20 is a lot of money to an 11 year old with poor parents. It's bad policy.Matthew Pittard wrote:As the Pathfinder Society Field Guide is now part of the 'required' items for play, you should see about getting that asap.
I can't say I appreciate being 'required' to buy things to play in the society. $20 is a lot of money to an 11 year old with poor parents. It's bad policy.Cole Cummings2013-02-19T14:41:55ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Eagle KnightsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2phr2?Eagle-Knights#112013-02-19T03:58:48Z2013-02-19T03:58:48Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">David Haller wrote:</div><blockquote><p> As far as Steel Falcon goes - it's just one branch of the Eagle Knights, so if you should become an Eagle Knight (at 20 fame, with the appropriate PA expense) you can just •be• a Steel Falcon.</p>
<p>I suspect •most• Pathfinder Eagle Knights are Steel Falcons (it seems fitting), but it's worth mentioning that membership to the specific order is •secret•, so you wouldn't be known as Roland the Steel Falcon ;) They're the "Delta Operatives" of Andoran!</p>
<p>FYI my 11th level Ranger, Knight Captain Kyrian Solonor, is a Steel Falcon, so you can consider him one of your contacts in the organization if you like...</p>
<p></blockquote><p>I appreciate that. A Squire, after all, needs a Knight. I'll add him to my address book.David Haller wrote:As far as Steel Falcon goes - it's just one branch of the Eagle Knights, so if you should become an Eagle Knight (at 20 fame, with the appropriate PA expense) you can just *be* a Steel Falcon.
I suspect *most* Pathfinder Eagle Knights are Steel Falcons (it seems fitting), but it's worth mentioning that membership to the specific order is *secret*, so you wouldn't be known as Roland the Steel Falcon ;) They're the "Delta Operatives" of Andoran!
FYI my 11th level Ranger,...Cole Cummings2013-02-19T03:58:48ZRe: Forums: Andoran: Eagle KnightsCole Cummingshttps://paizo.com/threads/rzs2phr2?Eagle-Knights#92013-02-19T03:25:06Z2013-02-19T03:25:06Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">xellos wrote:</div><blockquote> <a href="http://paizo.com/products/btpy8mfq" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">Pathfinder Society Field Guide</a>, Andoran section (page 14), Prestige Awards (2nd column) </blockquote><p>Ah...that explains it. I don't have that book. :(
<p>20 Fame huh?.... 4 more adventures to go.</p>xellos wrote:Pathfinder Society Field Guide, Andoran section (page 14), Prestige Awards (2nd column)
Ah...that explains it. I don't have that book. :( 20 Fame huh?.... 4 more adventures to go.Cole Cummings2013-02-19T03:25:06ZForums: Product Discussion: Pathfinder Tales: Noble Sacrifice ePubCaptain Andoran (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/products/btpy8h59/discuss?Pathfinder-Tales-Noble-Sacrifice-ePub#12012-04-04T04:32:16Z2012-04-04T04:32:16Z<p>Any chance the ePubs will be available for Kindle or Nook?</p>Any chance the ePubs will be available for Kindle or Nook?Captain Andoran (alias of Cole Cummings)2012-04-04T04:32:16ZForums: Forum Games: Pathfinder HaikuCaptain Andoran (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2nvxy?Pathfinder-Haiku#12012-04-04T05:36:53Z2012-04-04T04:19:26Z<p>Goblin carry stone
<br />
Pounds head against Rock
<br />
Goes Up Level</p>Goblin carry stone
Pounds head against Rock
Goes Up LevelCaptain Andoran (alias of Cole Cummings)2012-04-04T04:19:26ZRe: Forums/Pathfinder First Edition: General Discussion: Are rogues as useless as they appear?Captain Andoran (alias of Cole Cummings)https://paizo.com/threads/rzs2kd1j&page=5?Are-rogues-as-useless-as-they-appear#2152011-06-09T00:22:11Z2011-06-09T00:22:11Z<div class="messageboard-quotee">RamboJesus wrote:</div><blockquote> Rogues at a glance look ok but in practice they are bad. They don't do well in combat compared fighters barbs etc they also don't disable device all that well compared to the groups ability to open doors and activate traps. Discuss plox </blockquote><p>I have been all through the books and the discussion forums about rogue skills and it seems that you can indeed take a single level of rogue and then apply your total HD to the acquired skills. This rules discrepancy makes leveling a Rogue a pointless waste of time. Since essentially it is the same as taking 1 level of wizard and gaining every spell and every level. The entire class is bought for a SINGLE level and the only thing left exclusively to the Rogue is a collection of little talents.
<p>This essentially makes Rogues obsolete.</p>RamboJesus wrote:Rogues at a glance look ok but in practice they are bad. They don't do well in combat compared fighters barbs etc they also don't disable device all that well compared to the groups ability to open doors and activate traps. Discuss plox
I have been all through the books and the discussion forums about rogue skills and it seems that you can indeed take a single level of rogue and then apply your total HD to the acquired skills. This rules discrepancy makes leveling a Rogue a...Captain Andoran (alias of Cole Cummings)2011-06-09T00:22:11Z