|12 people marked this as a favorite.|
I'm glad to hear that the wonky subsystems on some of these APs can be removed or altered if necessary. I'm trying not to ignore anyone and definitely don't want anyone to be labeled as a "whiner".
Switching gears, and I understand this is very subjective, but which APs have consistently been praised by the community and which have received worse reviews?
Rise of the Runelords
Curse of the Crimson Throne
Middle of the road:
Skull and Shackles
Reign of Winter
Legacy of Fire
Love it or Hate it (i.e. very polarised)
Wrath of the Righteous
Too Soon to tell:
Generally Panned (for various reasons):
Council of Thieves
That's my general take on it - if you want to get a better idea of the most loved take a look at the 'which AP should be made into a hardcover' threads.
I will note that the polarizing AP's tend to be so because of overwhelming love or hate of specific themes and elements the AP uses throughout the entire story (i.e. travel/oriental, mythic, tech) and people who enjoy and or really like these elements have rated them in the 'top tier' category - so it comes down to your preferences. The 'generally panned' seem to have some serious clunks in them that take either a very skilled GM to make work, or quite a bit of rework to 'work around'.