|Mike Bramnik RPG Venture-Captain, Indiana—Bloomington aka CanisDirus|
|8 people marked this as FAQ candidate.|
Since there have been at least /two/ /different/ posts in recent memory about these sorts of issues, I wanted to present the question in the most general sense possible, and check to see if there is (or can be) an official PFS ruling on the matter.
The Question: If Source X and Source Y both have Item Z, but each source has different "stats" or other information for Item Z, AND if a Player owns both sources, which one takes precedence?
(Obviously, if Player A only owned Source X and not Source Y, they would only use the stats from Source X. If Player B owned Source Y and not Source X, they would only use the stats from Source Y.)
Options I can see from my chair:
A - The most recent of the conflicting sources
B - The oldest of the conflicting sources
C - Submit each item on a case-by-case basis for a ruling from the PFS Team (currently John, Linda, and Tonya).
My guess would be A, and as a GM that's how I would proceed if presented with this at a table, but this is one I'd love to find/get an official ruling on, if possible.
Thanks very much for reading!