Azrael Lukja's page

67 posts. No reviews. No lists. No wishlists.



1 person marked this as a favorite.

The only evil thing you can do in such a situation is enforcing your point of view on others and treating them as "bad evil people" for playing the game in a way that's fundamentally different than yours.
In the end, it really boils down to the "nature vs nurture" argument. And as far as Golarion is concerned, I'd say that it's not even that easy because the setting has a bit of both. Those trying to advocate the absolutes of the spectrum as the only meaningful way to play the alignment dispute are willingly ignoring some important objections of the other side. Where Golarion as a setting falls on this spectrum is ultimately subjective (I, for one, think that it slightly tends towards the "nurture" argument, at least for Humanoid beings).
The most important fact to keep in mind, though, is that at the end of the day even if we were to solve the dispute and determine that Golarion is completely sided with "Evil by nature" or "Evil by nurture"...
It still wouldn't matter.
And that's because every gaming table is free to reinterpret the setting to meet the needs of the participants. Some people like to apply modern-day morality and values to fantasy settings, other people don't: they want to play in a world with little-to-no grey areas. They are looking for a different experience.
And that's fine. Because you *can* play a game in which you kill people without condoning murder. I'm a really peaceful and non-violent person, still, I grew up playing rpgs and video games. If this were to be true, I would be an assassin because I played Hitman, a mass murderer because I played as Arthas in Warcraft 3, a mutilator because I played Surgeon Simulator 2013 and a plumber because I played Mario. And I'm not falling for all the bad press that the entertainment industry gets, as much as I didn't fall for the "D&D is satanic" thing of the 80s.
Judging other people from the characters they interpret in a roleplaying game is... fundamentally flawed. At the right table, I can save all those goblin babies and raise them myself. At another, I can play a close-minded dwarven ranger and kill all of them with a glee, and make jokes about it too. It doesn't mean in the slightest that I condone baby murder and it should be obvious, but people here are reacting like it isn't.
I can certainly find Mikaze's point of view logic and understandable... In modern world. Still, the straight-up refusal that someone might enjoy things differently (or simply, with a differ variety) strikes me as odd.
It's a game, folks. It's meant to be entertaining, whether it's grimdark or noblebright.