Averil's page

I've read every adventure path so far, and this one was excellent. Brilliant NPCs, varied settings (while still remaining almost all urban), and an excellent plot. My only complaint would be that it wasn't initially advertised that it wouldn't be all urban. While it is almost entirely urban, don't oversell it as such. Edge of Anarchy opens the campaign brilliantly.

Basically, what the title says. The rules are decent, if extremely different. Roleplaying is still possible depending on who is playing. The big problem, though, is that realism in the game is dead. The rules are no longer realistic, even from a "wizards and dragons" point of view.

Perhaps realism is the price of balance. If so, I'll take the realism.

I think the art on the cards themselves is great, but the backs are lacking as far as suspension of disbelief. Putting them in card sleeves solves this problem well.

In third edition, the character sheets were excellent quality four-page, class-specific and impossible to print out at home. What does fourth edition give you? Four two-page generic sheets, not worth any price. This should be a free PDF download. Also, Wizards falsely claimed that it was 32 pages, so it loses more points there.

Another great supplement for the Pathfinder Chronicles line, and one that makes it easy to run the many modules set in Darkmoon Vale.