The creatures in this scenario are fantastic. A thrill to run and the players enjoyed besting them and the trials it took to do so. They were let down by the story though. Since Pathfinder is all about the story I cannot suggest a GM pick this adventure as written.

This is no reflection on Adam’s work over-all which I enjoy.

The story in this scenario is a lot of fun and the scenario does a great job bringing it to life. There are a few mechanical issues which made the final encounters a bit of an anti-climax, some due to the encounter design and some due to our party mix.

Overall, I highly recommend the module, particularly if you can play the higher tier which I think offers more challenge and a more interesting final encounter.

I have extraordinary mixed feelings about this module. This module breaks a cardinal sin I have in good module writing - the ability to make people sit around and do nothing for more than a few rounds.

Early on the encounters were moderately interesting and the group enjoyed both the role-play and hack-and-slash fights presented. There was a pretty descent story and we were moderately pleased with the module. I do though need to mention that like a lot of mediocre modules, the module as-written does not do an adequate job telling the creative backstory involved, a good GM is required to set the elements of the story that make it as unique as it is. Then came the climax, and in one set of dice rolls, half the players stopped playing the module. I don't care if the mechanics are legal, that does not make for fun for the table.

I wish I could have given the module a better review, as it did start out on a good foot, but the end was just so non-entertaining for a number at the table I cannot in good conscience give it a positive review.

I have had to edit my original review of this scenario.

I still feel that this scenario has a great story. I had talked with many players who had experienced this scenario and I was expecting a couple knock-down and drag-out fights. What I got was a cake walk that let me down.

Part of the blame goes to a poorly planned encounter. A fighter should have at least one back-up weapon. Part of the blame goes to a player using a witch that was able to put the last two encounters to sleep which resulted in no fun on my part.

I would recommend that anyone looking to judge this scenario should take into account your player's spell DC's and plan accordingly.

This module was a lot of fun for me. There were times when it was dangerous, but it required good tactics on unusual battlegrounds, which I love. It also had a very in-depth story that the players actually got to see through gameplay.

Overall this scenario is fun to run if you're properly prepared. The story is unique and the role playing opportunities are bountiful. There are a couple of encounters that can turn deadly. For details check out the GM discussion thread. It doesn't get much better than a Hag on Harpy love affair!

The whole party agreed that this was a horrible mod. Because you have two monsters that do both strengh and con damage. One of the wizards used control undead on the hag ghost. Yet the mod didn't have any thing to cover that. So the gm had to run it, as it was written. Most of the party was made up of Pathfinder Gms. So they caught things like that Harpie can't use that spell, because it's a ranger spell and it is a sorceror.
Overall, the story is well done, but it is a tough mod and you are going to need a lot of lube. Because the monsters in this mod are way overpowered.