Paizo Top Nav Branding
Welcome, guest! | Sign In | My Account | My Subscriptions | My Downloads | My Wishlists | Shopping Cart   Shopping Cart | Help/FAQ
About Paizo   Messageboards   News   Paizo Blog   Help/FAQ  
Search
Links
Shop

Messageboards

Evocation optimization?, by Aravan

BANNED!, by DJ-Bogie

Can the Shadowdancer or Horizon Walker qualify for the Dimensional Agility feat?, by wraithstrike

After initial launch, will more playable races be added?, by TheAntiElite

Weekly Player Character Development (Ideas Welcome!!), by Philip Knowsley

Should the Synthesist be banned?, by Interzone

Wondrous Item: Continuous Summoned Monster / `Nature's Ally` legal?, by harmor

Acererak's Rise, by Adeptus Technicanus

Dispute with DM over a unfair trap, by Sissyl

Can you cast `Surmount Affliction` whlie confused, dazed, or paralyzed?, by Maveten

A new job opening at Paizo!, by Squeatus

Can you `Take 10` using the Merciful Healer's `Combat Medic (Ex)` ability?, by DM_aka_Dudemeister

Wake of the Watcher (GM Reference), by Luther

Head, by Doodlebug Anklebiter

How should a party handle loot distribution?, by BigNorseWolf

Online Campaigns

DM Alexander Kilcoyne's Kingmaker PBP- Chapter 2, by Ricter Vorsk

Tales of Agartha: the Avalon Chronicles, by Lysander Sandwalker

Age of Darkness, by Laithe Greycoat

DM Voice's Envoy of Geb - Game Thread, by DM - Voice of the Voiceless

Hymenopterix's Colonies of the Salt Coast, by Hymenopterix

Jade Regent: With a Single Step [Chapter 1: The Brinewall Legacy] Recruitment, by Liao Que

Kyrademon's Transnational PBP -- Discussion, Description, and Preparation, by Rhost Mab-i-gof

Galahad's Carrion Crown (Team Brawn), by Kayela Rest Bringer

DM Scarogoth's Carrion Crown Adventure Gameplay, by Alessa Velorei

Goblins 2: The Wreckin'-ing!, by Tark Bashflat

Wareagles Legacy of fire, by Pashaj

Chapter 1: Just Beneath the Surface, by Legiald Galsaran

GM Elberion's Council Of Thieves, by Daxius Veronius

Rise of the Runelords Discussion, by Darius Pope

Orlok Jr's Carrion Crown - Game Thread, by Rigor Rictus

   RSS Recent Posts Facebook Twitter Email
Search
Search this Thread:


So, everyone's been talking about the arcane bond: Bow action. So, you have a bow, which in order to be 'readied' needs two hands. Just about every wizard spell requires somatic actions, which require a free hand to cast. So....can you use the hand you're holding your bonded item in cast spells with?


Short answer: Yes.

The wizard waving his staff around and having magic arc out of the tip is classic fantasy, and using a ritual knife in one hand (an athame) is common in ritual magic. You just gesture with the blade instead of your fingers.

Now the ritual choreography with a bow may get a bit wonky to visualize, but if a wizard loves his bow so much he's bonded it in an arcane manner, he probably knows how to do it.

However, a weapon is generally a bad choice for a bonded object since there are lots of places you will not be allowed to take an obvious weapon, let alone wave it around in a threatening manner without attracting the attention of the city watch.


Kevin....

I completely agree with you as far as iconic imagery and thematic intent and RAI. What I'm curious about is there anything in RAW to indicate this?


Exactly. A weapon is great for an aspiring Eldritch Knight, but a less conspicuous, and less easily lost ring or amulet is probably a better choice for a straight caster.


Officially you will need 2 hands to wield a bow.

However, the Arcane Bond ability says the bond must be "in hand", not that it must be weilded as a weapon.

If you can hold a bow in one hand, you can use it as an arcane bond in one hand. Using it as a weapon then requires the other hand.

Clear enough?

Is someone actually arguing the other way on this? If so, send them here, by the rules, they have no leg to stand on.


Farabor wrote:

Kevin....

I completely agree with you as far as iconic imagery and thematic intent and RAI. What I'm curious about is there anything in RAW to indicate this?

I believe the RAW for this is the spellwurm from Magic of Eberron and the good old spirit naga: You do not, repeat, do not, need fingers or even hands to make Somatic components for spells. Wiggling a tail or even writhing your body is apparently more than sufficient, despite the fact that the RAW says you need to have a "hand" free.

Spirit Nagas don't have hands, so it's kind of hard to have them free with which to make the various sacred mudhras and assorted arcane hand gestures a mage would usually make with his hands. It would be rather silly to limit them to only cast spells which do not have somatic components or require them to take Still Spell for everything.

Spellwurms operate the same way, as sorcerers, despite having no hands, until they attach themselves like a leech in place of a missing arm or underneath a present arm, and they are able to then work as a substitute arm for spellcasting despite the fact that the tip of their tail has no actual hand at the end of it either.

Add to that evidence the Hypnotic Pattern spell, which in the current Pathfinder text requires as a material component either a stick of incense or a crystal rod, though doesn't mention what the hell you're expected to do with the damn things. However, in 1st edition, the text was more explicit: the stick of incense was lit or the crystal rod filled with phosphorescent material and the illusionist casting the spell created they hypnotic pattern by gesturing appropriately with the glowy thing.

Yes, this contradicts the current RAW on page 213 Pathfinder which says "hand" twice, but since the Pathfinder Bestiary also included the Spirit Naga with rather obviously has no hands and yet still somehow manages to cast spells, it's fairly obvious that they're using the word "hand" in the main book because it's assumed you're playing a humanoid spellcaster and it takes up less space than saying "appendage capable of fine motor functions." The verbiage on p. 213 that should be paid attention to is "a measured and precise movement" or the very 1st edition term "gesture."

You can gesture or make a measured and precise movement with a hand, a tail, a lit stick of incense, a knife, a staff, or even a large wooden spoon if that's what you currently have in hand. It may look a bit undignified to curse someone with a kitchen implement, but it should certainly work. I can also imagine a Tianese sorceress using a fan to the same effect.

So, in sum, while this may be RAI rather than RAW if you go with an overly literal interpretation of the RAW, the overly literal interpretation doesn't work because it's impossible to square literal "hand" with the obviously handless spirit naga which nevertheless still casts spells. And the spellwurm breaks this even further if you're accepting 3.5 RAW.

And as Hypnotic Pattern shows, we're playing a game where over twenty years of transcription and reinterpretation have left some things less clear, such as what's supposed to be inside the crystal rod and what you're supposed to do with the glow stick.


Paizo / Messageboards / Paizo Publishing / Pathfinder® / Pathfinder RPG / Rules Questions / All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.

Recent threads in Rules Questions

Can the Shadowdancer or Horizon Walker qualify for the Dimensional Agility feat?
Wondrous Item: Continuous Summoned Monster / `Nature's Ally` legal?
Can you cast `Surmount Affliction` whlie confused, dazed, or paralyzed?
Can you `Take 10` using the Merciful Healer's `Combat Medic (Ex)` ability?
Increasing intelligence retroactively grant bonus languages?
druid questions
Fly-By Grapple
Can an alchemist prepare bombs and extracts underwater?
Can an alchemist prepare extracts and bombs while spider climbing via the spell?
Opalescent White Pyramid cracked Ioun Stone and guns.
Quick question - summoning in mid air
Instant Fortress - The most powerful "weapon" in pathfinder?
Sin Magic: How does it work?
Augmented Eidelon Synthesist
Two weapon fighting unarmed
Savant trait - class skills
Spring Attack / Shot on the Run and Acrobatics
Rod of Cancellation vs Eidelon
Sneak attack from Stealth RAW
"Charm Person" and in-Group Fighting



©2002–2012 Paizo Publishing, LLC®. Need help? Email customer.service@paizo.com or call 425-250-0800 Monday–Friday, 10 AM–5 PM Pacific Time. View our privacy policy. Paizo Publishing, LLC, the Paizo golem logo, GameMastery, Pathfinder, Planet Stories, and Undefeated are registered trademarks of Paizo Publishing, LLC, and Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Pathfinder Adventure PathPathfinder Player Companion, Pathfinder Modules, Pathfinder Tales, Pathfinder Society, Pathfinder Battles, PaizoCon, RPG Superstar, The Golem's Got It, Titanic Games, the Titanic logo, and the Planet Stories planet logo are trademarks of Paizo Publishing, LLC. Dungeons & Dragons, Dragon, Dungeon, and Polyhedron are registered trademarks of Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and have been used by Paizo Publishing under license. Most product names are trademarks owned or used under license by the companies that publish those products; use of such names without mention of trademark status should not be construed as a challenge to such status.