Paizo Top Nav Branding
Welcome, guest! | Sign In | My Account | My Subscriptions | My Downloads | My Wishlists | Shopping Cart   Shopping Cart | Help/FAQ
About Paizo   Messageboards   News   Paizo Blog   Help/FAQ  
Search
Links
Shop

Messageboards

Harrow Gambit, by Karlgamer

Bestiary 4 Wish List, by Winterthorn

How should a party handle loot distribution?, by Wiggz

Should the Synthesist be banned?, by GnomePaladin

Removing Perception as a Skill, by Parka

Save or Die Spells: Keep Them Out of PvP Please, by Davor

Savant trait - class skills, by kageseishin

Ring of Sustanance: Gimmick or Awesome Sauce?, by Laurefindel

Opalescent White Pyramid cracked Ioun Stone and guns., by blackbloodtroll

Help me munchkin it up!, by BigCoffee

Can I get a volunteer? Elemental Bending Monk, by zerzix

Number given at con used by someone else at another con, by Doug Miles

A compromise for friendly fire that should make EVERYONE happy, by Onishi

OMG! I'm actually going to get a chance to play a full campaign!, by lastblacknight

Increasing intelligence retroactively grant bonus languages?, by William Ronald

Online Campaigns

Her Dark Majesty Trilogy part 1: Where The Fallen Jarls Sleep Discussion, by Curvlk Wyrdon

DM Voice's Envoy of Geb - Game Thread, by DM - Voice of the Voiceless

The World Serpent Inn, by Dalnen Vasir - The Crimson Duke

DM Carbide's Through a Cracked Mirror: The Dark Road, by DM Carbide - Dark Road

The Pact Stone Pyramid, by Breach Shattershield aka Javell

Elton's Curse of the Crimson Throne, by GM Elton

Motteditor's Kingmaker campaign, by Orin Ro

The Sunless Citadel PBP, by Wareagle

Kyrademon's Transnational PBP -- Discussion, Description, and Preparation, by Kyrademon

Elton's Curse of the Crimson Throne Discussion, by GM Elton

DM Carbide's Through a Cracked Mirror: The Dark Road Discussion, by DM Carbide - Dark Road

PF Shackled City SCAP, by Broccan Dunchad

GM Tordek's Souls for a Devil PBP, by GM Tordek

Dream of the Red Chamber: Kyrademon's Jade Regent PBP, Part IV, by Kyrademon

FuriousPhil's We Be Goblins! PbP Recruitment Thread (New players welcome!), by dbeman

   RSS Recent Posts Facebook Twitter Email
Search
Search this Thread:


I just noticed this the other day, and had not previously been aware that the spell invisibility, and therefore all of it's higher level versions, since they state they act like invisibility, all have a weight limit of 100 lbs per CL. I'm willing to bet this effectively rules out by RAW most large or larger monsters from ever taking advantage of this tactic. Since even if a dragon or a giant or whatever has a decent caster level, the majority of them are going to weigh in excess of 2000 lbs which would effectively prohibit them from gaining any advantage of invisibility even at CL 20.

Any thoughts, ways around this by RAW?

Any interjections by the developers would be appreciated. Was this intentional?

Andoran (Pathfinder Superscriber)

Tilquinith wrote:

I just noticed this the other day, and had not previously been aware that the spell invisibility, and therefore all of it's higher level versions, since they state they act like invisibility, all have a weight limit of 100 lbs per CL. I'm willing to bet this effectively rules out by RAW most large or larger monsters from ever taking advantage of this tactic. Since even if a dragon or a giant or whatever has a decent caster level, the majority of them are going to weigh in excess of 2000 lbs which would effectively prohibit them from gaining any advantage of invisibility even at CL 20.

Any thoughts, ways around this by RAW?

Any interjections by the developers would be appreciated. Was this intentional?

They cast it on themselves. The target is you (no weight restrition) or a creature or object weighting up to 100lb/CL. In othre ords, no matter your weight, you can always make yourself invisible, but making othre things invisible is tricier if they're massive.


If cast on your self no weight limitation applies (and I would be inclined to read it as the weight limitation applies to objects only, and not creatures anyway).


Tilquinith wrote:

I just noticed this the other day, and had not previously been aware that the spell invisibility, and therefore all of it's higher level versions, since they state they act like invisibility, all have a weight limit of 100 lbs per CL. I'm willing to bet this effectively rules out by RAW most large or larger monsters from ever taking advantage of this tactic. Since even if a dragon or a giant or whatever has a decent caster level, the majority of them are going to weigh in excess of 2000 lbs which would effectively prohibit them from gaining any advantage of invisibility even at CL 20.

Any thoughts, ways around this by RAW?

Any interjections by the developers would be appreciated. Was this intentional?

Target: you or a creature or object weighing no more than 100 lbs./level

The weight is only limited to objects. This was done to stop cheese such as making a building invisible, as an example. If the 100 lbs per level applied to everything it would read more like "Target: you or a creature or object, none of which can weigh more than 100 lbs./level"


Hmm, I guess that makes sense. Perhaps my understanding of the english language and its forms of punctuation just aren't as good as I thought. I still kind of think it could be taken either way. But it certainly wouldn't make sense to have on a larger creatures spell list if they couldn't use it, so your guy's interpretation is probably correct.


It could be read either way in English, normally if it were part of a larger text you could tell what was meant by the surrounding context, but unfortunately in this case it is harder to tell. Don't feel bad.


BTW Invisible Dragon=Awesome!

Osirion (Pathfinder Adventure Path Subscriber)

Jerald Schrimsher wrote:
BTW Invisible Dragon=Awesome!

Yes, but invisibility can be easily foiled with see invisible or even glitterdust. My favorite is a dragon with Hide in Plain Sight and ranks in Stealth. ;)


By splashing the potion under their wingpits, silly.


Tilquinith wrote:
Hmm, I guess that makes sense. Perhaps my understanding of the english language and its forms of punctuation just aren't as good as I thought. I still kind of think it could be taken either way. But it certainly wouldn't make sense to have on a larger creatures spell list if they couldn't use it, so your guy's interpretation is probably correct.

Oh, I think your understanding of English is just fine. It is a crappy sentence. In fact, the way it is worded literally means just what you thought, except it precludes the caster from the weight limit.


concerro wrote:
This was done to stop cheese such as making a building invisible, as an example.

I only tried that once! Gee, people, give it a rest...uh, you never heard me say that. These are not the 'droids you're looking for, move along...


Bwang wrote:
concerro wrote:
This was done to stop cheese such as making a building invisible, as an example.

I only tried that once! Gee, people, give it a rest...uh, you never heard me say that. These are not the 'droids you're looking for, move along...

These are not the droids I am looking for. <moves along>

(Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber)

Paul Watson wrote:
They cast it on themselves. The target is you (no weight restrition) or a creature or object weighting up to 100lb/CL. In othre ords, no matter your weight, you can always make yourself invisible, but making othre things invisible is tricier if they're massive.

Even if it didn't make the dragon completely invisible, would you want to tell them that? I mean, they could get rather peeved ... best just to pretend that you can't see them and go along with it ...


Dabbler wrote:
Paul Watson wrote:
They cast it on themselves. The target is you (no weight restrition) or a creature or object weighting up to 100lb/CL. In othre ords, no matter your weight, you can always make yourself invisible, but making othre things invisible is tricier if they're massive.
Even if it didn't make the dragon completely invisible, would you want to tell them that? I mean, they could get rather peeved ... best just to pretend that you can't see them and go along with it ...

Actually a fine way to treat all dragons. Just act like they are invisible. It works great! ;D


How does a dragon use the spell 'Invisibility'?

Any way it wants!

(Sorry, could not resist)


How long after he swallows the rogue with the healing potion does the dragon disappear?


The sleeping dragon your party is carefully surrounding...

Is an illusion...

The dragon is invisible and levitating above you....

Thought you might like to know!


KenderKin wrote:

The sleeping dragon your party is carefully surrounding...

Is an illusion...

The dragon is invisible and levitating above you....

Thought you might like to know!

Ah, memories. Happened to our group back in high school when we first started playing AD&D. Talk about a real shocker for us.

Was an absolutely brilliant move from our DM back in the day.

Course that was back when a Dragons Breath Weapon damage was equal to his hit points. Dragon had 88 HP's, breath did 88 damage.

Needless to say we were denied saves from the invisible attacker. Was a painful 3 rounds. Dragon's hoard got bigger and we assumed he leveled off of us...


All DMs fit into that "absolutely brilliant" category, at least the good ones....

Nice to know it has happened to more PCs though.

Funny how combined spells power is exponentially better....

My favorites
entangle & taunt

grease & gust of wind


Paizo / Messageboards / Paizo Publishing / Pathfinder® / Pathfinder RPG / Rules Questions / All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.

Recent threads in Rules Questions

Savant trait - class skills
Opalescent White Pyramid cracked Ioun Stone and guns.
Increasing intelligence retroactively grant bonus languages?
Spring Attack / Shot on the Run and Acrobatics
Augmented Eidelon Synthesist
Rod of Cancellation vs Eidelon
Fly-By Grapple
Two weapon fighting unarmed
Sneak attack from Stealth RAW
Instant Fortress - The most powerful "weapon" in pathfinder?
"Charm Person" and in-Group Fighting
Defending Weapon
some quick alchemist queries.
Can you cast `Surmount Affliction` whlie confused, dazed, or paralyzed?
Alchemist bombs and incorporeal things
Sin Magic: How does it work?
Somatic Components for Divine Casters
Bladebound Arcane Pool Enhancements.
Dragon Ferocity and DEX-based Monk
Splitting weapons bonuses.



©2002–2012 Paizo Publishing, LLC®. Need help? Email customer.service@paizo.com or call 425-250-0800 Monday–Friday, 10 AM–5 PM Pacific Time. View our privacy policy. Paizo Publishing, LLC, the Paizo golem logo, GameMastery, Pathfinder, Planet Stories, and Undefeated are registered trademarks of Paizo Publishing, LLC, and Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Pathfinder Adventure PathPathfinder Player Companion, Pathfinder Modules, Pathfinder Tales, Pathfinder Society, Pathfinder Battles, PaizoCon, RPG Superstar, The Golem's Got It, Titanic Games, the Titanic logo, and the Planet Stories planet logo are trademarks of Paizo Publishing, LLC. Dungeons & Dragons, Dragon, Dungeon, and Polyhedron are registered trademarks of Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and have been used by Paizo Publishing under license. Most product names are trademarks owned or used under license by the companies that publish those products; use of such names without mention of trademark status should not be construed as a challenge to such status.