Paizo Top Nav Branding
Welcome, guest! | Sign In | My Account | My Subscriptions | My Downloads | My Wishlists | Shopping Cart   Shopping Cart | Help/FAQ
About Paizo   Messageboards   News   Paizo Blog   Help/FAQ  
Search
Links
Shop

Messageboards

{Fat Goblin Games} SHADOWS over VATHAK- $1 for the next 24 hours!, by Readerbreeder

Should the Synthesist be banned?, by Winterthorn

Animal Companion for an Urban Ranger?, by blackbloodtroll

Instant Fortress - The most powerful "weapon" in pathfinder?, by Ashiel

My feelings about 5E D&D, by Killer_GM

Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Player Character Folio, by Joseph Wilson

Augmented Eidelon Synthesist, by Hobgoblin Shogun

[Jon Brazer Enterprises] Book of the River Nations: Complete Player's Reference for Kingdom Building (PFRPG), by Dale McCoy Jr

Increasing intelligence retroactively grant bonus languages?, by MendedWall12

Sin Magic: How does it work?, by Zahariel

Pathfinder Campaign Setting: Distant Worlds (PFRPG), by Winterthorn

A compromise for friendly fire that should make EVERYONE happy, by Davor

[Frog God Games] LAST CHANCE TO ORDER SLUMBERING TSAR SUBSCRIPTION, by Greg A. Vaughan

Save or Die Spells: Keep Them Out of PvP Please, by Nihimon

Help me munchkin it up!, by Egoish

Online Campaigns

DM Aron Marczylo's Kingmaker - Part 1: Stolen Land, by TarkXT

DM-Tareth's Modified Kingmaker Campaign Discussion, by Warren Kingeagle

Shadowrun 4e Gangland Sports, by Slide

Unbinding the Fetters - Disciples of Master Gond, by DM - Voice of the Voiceless

Dm Zyren's Heart of Runes, by Karlan Bladetwist

Brains of the Dark World, by Xallihion

DM Corvus' Carrion Crown PBP, by Iesha Shadowstar-Petrosca

PF Shackled City SCAP, by Edrukk Thorvirgun

Tark's Council of Thieves: Rebels with a Cause, by TarkXT

Dungeon Master Heathy's Carrion Crown, by dungeonmaster heathy

Hunger and Darkness - Reclaiming Tar-Urkatha, by Cynara

The_Ninja_DM's Carrion Crown, by The_Ninja_DM

Kyrademon's Transnational PBP -- Discussion, Description, and Preparation, by liothonae cromvathar

Cap'n Voodoo's Freebooter PBP, by James "Madman Jim" Patterson

The Story of the Stone: Kyrademon's Jade Regent PBP, Part III, by Kyrademon

   RSS Recent Posts Facebook Twitter Email
Search
Search this Thread:


So I was looking over my summoning lists again and I realized I only have 3 creatures on the Summon Monster 8 list:

Barbed Devil -- Evil, Lawful
Elemental (elder) -- elemental
Hezrou -- Chaotic, Evil

Which seems a woefully short list to me... so I checked the data base on the off chance that something just got cut off on accident in the book. The database however has the exact same summoning list, which means good clerics looking to summon a monster off of this list are reduced to elementals only.

Was this intentional?


Look at Summon Nature's Ally IX- it's even worse (Storm Giant & Pixie if I remember). It seems intentional to me.


I guess the question becomes: Why? It's not like you have a level where there are only good aligned choices. It just strikes me as wonky.

Paizo Employee (Creative Director)

Abraham spalding wrote:
I guess the question becomes: Why? It's not like you have a level where there are only good aligned choices. It just strikes me as wonky.

The reason is that there just wasn't enough monsters in the book to fill out the list with lots of choices, honestly. We'll likely be providing guidelines on expanding the summon monster lists once Bestiary 2 rolls around.

Until then, though, yeah. It's elemental time. Fortunately there are four different flavors of elemental to choose from...


Sean FitzSimon wrote:
Look at Summon Nature's Ally IX- it's even worse (Storm Giant & Pixie if I remember).

Which calls to mind an ancient Dragon article, for those of us who knew Methusaleh personally.


How about throwing a few dragons on those lists?

Perhaps also summon a creature from the Monster 7 list, and throw the advanced template on it?

Wait. I can summon an Ettin, but not a Unicorn? I don't know what to believe in anymore...


Fergie wrote:

How about throwing a few dragons on those lists?

Perhaps also summon a creature from the Monster 7 list, and throw the advanced template on it?

Wait. I can summon an Ettin, but not a Unicorn? I don't know what to believe in anymore...

Yeah, the unicorn was the biggest blow to the SNA list in my opinion. I loved being able to port in any ally to kick off some healing and then proceed to gore and kick enemies until the duration expired.

Shame.


James Jacobs wrote:
Abraham spalding wrote:
I guess the question becomes: Why? It's not like you have a level where there are only good aligned choices. It just strikes me as wonky.

The reason is that there just wasn't enough monsters in the book to fill out the list with lots of choices, honestly. We'll likely be providing guidelines on expanding the summon monster lists once Bestiary 2 rolls around.

Until then, though, yeah. It's elemental time. Fortunately there are four different flavors of elemental to choose from...

What about summoning a genie? Is that a bit over the top?

All's I'm saying is, if I was a healthy adult male wizard, and I just hit level 15, I would be summoning a Marid, and I would have my Wizard Hat and robe PREPARED, if you get my drift. Scrolls of Transmute self to Rhinoceros would litter the floor.

Paizo Employee (Creative Director)

Some monsters we wanted to leave off the list so that you'd need to use planar ally or planar binding to conjure them up. Genies are a great example of this.


NOM NOM NOM wrote:
James Jacobs wrote:
Abraham spalding wrote:
I guess the question becomes: Why? It's not like you have a level where there are only good aligned choices. It just strikes me as wonky.

The reason is that there just wasn't enough monsters in the book to fill out the list with lots of choices, honestly. We'll likely be providing guidelines on expanding the summon monster lists once Bestiary 2 rolls around.

Until then, though, yeah. It's elemental time. Fortunately there are four different flavors of elemental to choose from...

What about summoning a genie? Is that a bit over the top?

All's I'm saying is, if I was a healthy adult male wizard, and I just hit level 15, I would be summoning a Marid, and I would have my Wizard Hat and robe PREPARED, if you get my drift. Scrolls of Transmute self to Rhinoceros would litter the floor.

My only question is why you would only want one Marid when you could have 1d4+1 Succubi...

Qadira (Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Adventure Path, Campaign Setting Subscriber)

NOM NOM NOM wrote:

What about summoning a genie? Is that a bit over the top?

All's I'm saying is, if I was a healthy adult male wizard, and I just hit level 15, I would be summoning a Marid, and I would have my Wizard Hat and robe PREPARED, if you get my drift. Scrolls of Transmute self to Rhinoceros would litter the floor.

Sounds like a lot of work for 90 seconds of fun. ;-)


Abraham spalding wrote:

So I was looking over my summoning lists again and I realized I only have 3 creatures on the Summon Monster 8 list:

Barbed Devil -- Evil, Lawful
Elemental (elder) -- elemental
Hezrou -- Chaotic, Evil

Which seems a woefully short list to me... so I checked the data base on the off chance that something just got cut off on accident in the book. The database however has the exact same summoning list, which means good clerics looking to summon a monster off of this list are reduced to elementals only.

Was this intentional?

SM XIII just happens to be a poor summoning spell.

However, note (for those who can summon evil creatures) that the Barbed Devil and the Hezrou used to be on the SM IX list, and the monsters that used to be on the SM XIII list are all down there at lower level summonings.

For example:

3.5, Wizard uses SM XIII to summon one Vrock, or One Fiendish T-Rex, or one Celestial Triceratops, or one Fiendish Dire Tiger.

Pathfinder Wizard uses SM XIII to summon:
1d3 Vrocks
1d3 Fiendish or Celestial T-Rex's
1d4+1 Fiendish or Celestial Triceratops
1d4+1 Fiendish or Celestial Dire Tigers

Etc.

Though I do miss my Colossal Fiendish vermin though... ;)


James Jacobs wrote:
Some monsters we wanted to leave off the list so that you'd need to use planar ally or planar binding to conjure them up. Genies are a great example of this.

Poor Daivrat. Not only does he have a useless class ability, they're forced to imprison their friends.

:P

Genie's friend boosts caster level - irrelevant for planar binding. And planar binding is quite unfriendly, while summon monster only calls willing creatures.

(RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16)

Treantmonk wrote:
SM XIII just happens to be a poor summoning spell.

Yeah, if I were level 25 and my best spell only yielded 1d4+1 celestial dire tigers I'd be pretty pissed.


delabarre wrote:
NOM NOM NOM wrote:

What about summoning a genie? Is that a bit over the top?

All's I'm saying is, if I was a healthy adult male wizard, and I just hit level 15, I would be summoning a Marid, and I would have my Wizard Hat and robe PREPARED, if you get my drift. Scrolls of Transmute self to Rhinoceros would litter the floor.
Sounds like a lot of work for 90 seconds of fun. ;-)

Yeah, but every day.


Sean FitzSimon wrote:
Look at Summon Nature's Ally IX- it's even worse (Storm Giant & Pixie if I remember). It seems intentional to me.

LOL - I was just looking at the Animal Domain for Clerics. (More specifically for Druids taking a domain - but hey - it's listed under Clerics)

The level 8 slot is: Summon Nature's Ally VIII (animals only)

Guess how many animals are on the SNA VIII list?

if you guessed one, you guessed too high.

yeah - he HAS to use it to summon lower level critters - because there aren't ANY animals on the SNA VIII list...


Paizo / Messageboards / Paizo Publishing / Pathfinder® / Pathfinder RPG / General Discussion / All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.



©2002–2012 Paizo Publishing, LLC®. Need help? Email customer.service@paizo.com or call 425-250-0800 Monday–Friday, 10 AM–5 PM Pacific Time. View our privacy policy. Paizo Publishing, LLC, the Paizo golem logo, GameMastery, Pathfinder, Planet Stories, and Undefeated are registered trademarks of Paizo Publishing, LLC, and Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Pathfinder Adventure PathPathfinder Player Companion, Pathfinder Modules, Pathfinder Tales, Pathfinder Society, Pathfinder Battles, PaizoCon, RPG Superstar, The Golem's Got It, Titanic Games, the Titanic logo, and the Planet Stories planet logo are trademarks of Paizo Publishing, LLC. Dungeons & Dragons, Dragon, Dungeon, and Polyhedron are registered trademarks of Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and have been used by Paizo Publishing under license. Most product names are trademarks owned or used under license by the companies that publish those products; use of such names without mention of trademark status should not be construed as a challenge to such status.