This was brought up somewhere else, but where do YOU stand???

Cookies VS Brownies

Either one is good. Preferably before they have been cooked! ~munches on some cookie dough and some brownie mix~

PIE!

What kind of cookies?
Do the cookies have walnuts in them?
Are they freshly baked?
Are they buttery, made from scratch or are they from a dollupable package?

Do the brownies have walnuts in them?
Are they more cake-type brownies or fudge-like brownies?
Do they come with icing or not?
Are they still warm?

Can I have some milk?

PIE!

~shoves a apple pie into CourtFool's face~ Take that, knave!

Brownies, I love brownies, very special brownies.

~shoves a apple pie into CourtFool's face~ Take that, knave!

Num num num

Depends how old are the brownies? When they are young they are still tender and plump nicely when you cook them, after about 7 though you need to wait another 11 years, and they hit their second peak...

Brownies are much too fey for me...

Either one is good. Preferably before they have been cooked! ~munches on some cookie dough and some brownie mix~

Bless you, yes! A vote for either, uncooked, for me as well!

...Eat the brownie mix....With The Cookie Dough!

It depends on the type of cookie. And the type of brownie. Still warm, slightly undercooked Ghirardelli double chocolate brownies are always a win. But if we're talking the icky cakelike brownies with the icing, then I have to go with cookies. Peanut butter cookies. Or sugar cookies with a little lemon zest baked in. Or ginger cookies. Just not chocolate chip. Blech. I really can't stand chocolate chip.

Whose idea was this? ;)
gooey brownies, fresh made from scratch cookies both equal win. If they are special brownies uhm the question I guess answers itself.

All of the above, especially fresh out of the oven and with milk.

All of the above, especially fresh out of the oven and with milk.

Yes, agreed. :D

Lathiira wrote:

All of the above, especially fresh out of the oven and with milk.

Yes, agreed. :D

From the Mistress of Victuals herself! We have heard the gospel here first!

Lathiira wrote:

All of the above, especially fresh out of the oven and with milk.

Yes, agreed. :D

It would figure this thread would catch your attention.

Lilith wrote:

Lathiira wrote:

All of the above, especially fresh out of the oven and with milk.

Yes, agreed. :D

It would figure this thread would catch your attention.

** spoiler omitted **

You and me both.

You're in luck, I have a double batch of brownies in the oven right now. :P

You're in luck, I have a double batch of brownies in the oven right now. :P

And I can get my grubby little hands on these HOW exactly?

cookies b brownies.....hmmm......I choose.....Sin-a-Man Buns!

throws +5 Sin-a-Man Buns of seeking into everyone's mouths

You're in luck, I have a double batch of brownies in the oven right now. :P

That is just so cruel!

This was brought up somewhere else, but where do YOU stand???

Cookies VS Brownies

If I am presented with a plate of cookies I like and a plate of brownies I like, I choose the cookies, because, assuming they're both in varieties of their base class that I like, I like cookies more.

Chocolate cookies versus chocolate brownies? Cookies win.
Chocolate chip cookies versus chocolate brownies with chocolate chips? Cookies win.
Chocolate chip cookies versus hot fudge brownie smothered in hot fudge and topped with two scoops of vanilla ice cream covered in hot fudge? Brownie-ice cream amalgam dessert wins.
Hot chocolate chip chocolate cookies covered in hot fudge and topped with two scoops of vanilla (or chocolate) ice cream covered in hot fudge? Versus the previous brownie desert? Cookie-ice cream amalgam dessert wins.

Great. Now I'm hungry.

Baked goods are lame!!!

Mac Boyce wrote:

This was brought up somewhere else, but where do YOU stand???

Cookies VS Brownies

If I am presented with a plate of cookies I like and a plate of brownies I like, I choose the cookies, because, assuming they're both in varieties of their base class that I like, I like cookies more.

Chocolate cookies versus chocolate brownies? Cookies win.
Chocolate chip cookies versus chocolate brownies with chocolate chips? Cookies win.
Chocolate chip cookies versus hot fudge brownie smothered in hot fudge and topped with two scoops of vanilla ice cream covered in hot fudge? Brownie-ice cream amalgam dessert wins.
Hot chocolate chip chocolate cookies covered in hot fudge and topped with two scoops of vanilla (or chocolate) ice cream covered in hot fudge? Versus the previous brownie desert? Cookie-ice cream amalgam dessert wins.

Great. Now I'm hungry.

But what if the brownies come searved on Jessica Alba?

Oatmeal cookies FTW. Those are my favorite cookies!

Baked goods are lame!!!

*Sneaks up behind MT and whacks him with the civility club*

Oh Hush!!

Brownies. It's the uniform. I got tossed out of boy scouts for eatin' a brownie. :P

Brownies. It's the uniform. I got tossed out of boy scouts for eatin' a brownie. :P

Niiiiiiiice.

Lilith wrote:

You're in luck, I have a double batch of brownies in the oven right now. :P

And I can get my grubby little hands on these HOW exactly?

Uhh...show up at my place before my hubby eats them all?

I am eating a brownie right now. Coincidence?

Either one is good. Preferably before they have been cooked! ~munches on some cookie dough and some brownie mix~

Yes! My favorite.

COOKIES!

C is for cookie and that's good enough for me!

Why choose? =D

PIE!

Exactly.

Brownies. It's the uniform. I got tossed out of boy scouts for eatin' a brownie. :P

I got tossed by a boy scout once.

I am eating a brownie right now. Coincidence?

Yoda is Lilith's husband?!?!!??!?

Fake Healer wrote:

Brownies. It's the uniform. I got tossed out of boy scouts for eatin' a brownie. :P

I got tossed by a boy scout once.

Well played, sir.

This was brought up somewhere else, but where do YOU stand???

Cookies VS Brownies

Neither... molten-chocolate cake.

Uhh...show up at my place before my hubby eats them all?

I am not falling for that again. Well, not until you drop the restraining order.

Worst cookie ever: Skittles cookies.
Worst brownie ever: Skittles brownie.

I feel so honored...Lilith posted on one of my topics!

Bows before the mighty cookie goddess

PIE!!!

I vote for Alice B. Toklas Brownies!

I vote for Alice B. Toklas Brownies!

"I love you Alice B. Toklas... and so does Gertrude Stein..."

A question deserving deep thought.

I am so down with a good brownie, but even given their variations, such as blondies, they're pretty much just one type of thing... a chewy dense pan cake. Cookies have a thousand varieties, so I'd have to vote cookies. As they said about me back when I kept the largest Harem in all the Middle East, Rone likes variety.

I'm far more likely to make brownies myself and buy cookies from a bakery, and so I probably consider brownies a more special fare in that I had something, though minor, to do wih their outcome. However, that only reveals that a fresh baked brownie is a my preference to what I can find in stores. When I buy cookies I like an assortment, and since I'm not going to litter my kitchen in an array of messy ingredients and soiled mixing bowls trying to make complex recipes for twenty different cookies, I trust the pros.

Wow, now I really know how I feel on the subject.

As they said about me back when I kept the largest Harem in all the Middle East, Rone likes variety.

It's like you have this whole other life!

Cookies Vs Brownies...

Pah I laugh at your cookies and brownies...make mine

A Tunnocks Teacake

The Jade wrote:

As they said about me back when I kept the largest Harem in all the Middle East, Rone likes variety.

It's like you have this whole other life!

And I still find the time to be an Indian Ocean sea monster!

Celestial Healer wrote:

The Jade wrote:

As they said about me back when I kept the largest Harem in all the Middle East, Rone likes variety.

It's like you have this whole other life!

And I still find the time to be an Indian Ocean sea monster!

Still running that smuggling ring out of Nova Scotia?