Paizo Top Nav Branding
Welcome, guest! | Sign In | My Account | My Subscriptions | My Downloads | My Wishlists | Shopping Cart   Shopping Cart | Help/FAQ
About Paizo   Messageboards   News   Paizo Blog   Help/FAQ  
Search
Links
Shop

Messageboards

7 Swords of sin, by Dreadnok

What is the point of Synthesist? (no this is not a synthesist slamming post), by StreamOfTheSky

Evocation optimization?, by Egoish

The Secret World of Arrietty, by Enevhar Aldarion

Imp Servitor, by jjaamm

Help with 4th level Alchemist, by Akasharose

The Tick(animated), by Shadowborn

If I were a despotic global dictator..., by Spanky the Leprechaun

What do people think of the sword saint?, by Tectorman

Paizo Blog: Pathfinder Battles Preview: Familiar Faces, by NoStrings

Sidhe Noble, by Saint Trickery

The Money Talk, by 0gre

Will there be Alignment in Pathfinder online?, by ElyasRavenwood

Dispute with DM over a unfair trap, by Waltz

Its not looking good for the fighter class in 5E, by memorax

Online Campaigns

Chapter 1: A Journey to Start a Story, by Xiao Feng

GM Fnord's PFS First Steps Discussion, by GM Fnord

Tales of Agartha: the Avalon Chronicles, by narrator

Of Battle, Wolves and Winter. Discussion, by GM Drachenfels

Gm Blood's AoW in Golarion, by Kelkzar Redjaw

Worldwound Adventures Discussion, by Monkeygod

Amgir's "Curse of the Crimson Throne", by Razule Yrrum

DM Barcas - Kingmaker: Rivers Run Red, by Akiros Ismort

We-Be-Halflings: Ringtail's Council of Thieves OOC, by Gordon the Whale

Tomb of the Emperor Gods -- PbP, by Korian Allande

Zoomackulas's Legacy of Fire, by Daumari

Xaaon's Curse of the Crimson Throne - Act III, by DM X

CrazyHedgehog's Serpent Skull Discussion, by Yekskya

Sfounder's Curse of the Crimson Throne PbP, by Gaius Lirsiiv

Of Battle, Wolves and Winter., by GM Drachenfels

   RSS Recent Posts Facebook Twitter Email
Search
Search this Thread:

1 to 50 of 110 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>

I'm surprised this hasn't been brought up here yet. I did a search and didn't see it anywhere, at least.

Source

It looks like WotC will not renew their license to produce Star Wars material. This means that their Star Wars RPG and minis lines will both be coming to an end in a matter of months. I never played either the minis game or the RPG though I know there are a ton of Star Wars fans who will be sad to see their games no longer supported. First WEG's game went away, and now WotC's. Who do you think will pick the license up next, if anyone does?

(Pathfinder Adventure Path, Tales, Battles Case Subscriber)

Ah the mysteries of Wizards.

(RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32)

yoda8myhead wrote:
I'm surprised this hasn't been brought up here yet. I did a search and didn't see it anywhere, at least.

It was. ;D

It isn't that "mysterious" though.

  • Lucas Arts, got a piece of every Star Wars RPG product that WoTC sold.
  • The US Economy, the primary market for the Star Wars RPG, is still finding its footing (outside of Wall Street).
  • If sales are not doing well, likely in the current market, then WoTC may be making little to nothing on the product line.

    So, not renewing the licence may be just good business sense. :(

  • Andoran (Pathfinder Superscriber)

    Well...., in my heart there was only one Star wars RPG, and it was played entirely with D6s.


    Crap! You know what this means. Book/Minis prices are going to skyrocket. I played a lot of the Saga edition game, and bought a decent amount of minis. If nothing else, I just like having a bunch of star wars minis around. Now the clock is ticking before these disappear, or go for insane amounts of money.

    I remember the revised edition books were going for over $100 before Saga came out. This really sucks.


    yoda8myhead wrote:
    I'm surprised this hasn't been brought up here yet. I did a search and didn't see it anywhere, at least.

    It was brought up in this thread. David Fryer beat you, but only by 8 hours.

    (Pathfinder Adventure Path, Tales, Battles Case Subscriber)

    Lord Fyre wrote:
    yoda8myhead wrote:
    I'm surprised this hasn't been brought up here yet. I did a search and didn't see it anywhere, at least.

    It isn't that "mysterious" though.

  • Lucas Arts, got a piece of every Star Wars RPG product that WoTC sold.
  • The US Economy, the primary market for the Star Wars RPG, is still finding its footing (outside of Wall Street).
  • If sales are not doing well, likely in the current market, then WoTC may be making little to nothing on the product line.

    So, not renewing the licence may be just good business sense. :(

  • See, if you say it's mysterious, you don't have to put the frowny face.


    Aaron Bitman wrote:
    yoda8myhead wrote:
    I'm surprised this hasn't been brought up here yet. I did a search and didn't see it anywhere, at least.
    It was brought up in this thread. David Fryer beat you, but only by 8 hours.

    Weird that that thread didn't show up when I searched "Star Wars" on the message boards. Move along, then. This is not the thread you're looking for.



    cyrusduane wrote:


    Well...., in my heart there was only one Star wars RPG, and it was played entirely with D6s.

    Word to the Wookiee

    Sczarni (Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Adventure Path, Companion Subscriber)

    cyrusduane wrote:


    Well...., in my heart there was only one Star wars RPG, and it was played entirely with D6s.

    +1. Star Wars D6 was my first-ever roleplaying game, and I still crack out the book once a year for a "holiday special" of my own (which is actually fun!).

    Cheliax (Pathfinder Adventure Path Charter Subscriber; Companion, Modules Subscriber)

    cyrusduane wrote:


    Well...., in my heart there was only one Star wars RPG, and it was played entirely with D6s.

    +1 It's been a long time since my group's played it, but oddly enough we just started up again last month; dang, those books are hard to find to replenish, shouldn't have given mine away back in the day (but at least I traded them with someone else in my group).


    I started playing Star Wars in Revised Edition, never had a chance to play the WEG version. I really liked Saga for helping gloss over some of the clunkier mechanics(using the Force should NOT use HP!), but still need to house-rule on occasion.


    What's puzzling to me about this is that Hasbro owns WoTC. Why that is significant is that due to the genius marketing and property deals Lucas wrangled out of Kenner for them to produce the Star Wars toys (For those unaware, Hasbro purchased Kenner and dropped their logo many moons ago.), Lucas now owns a double digit percentage of Hasbro. I guess he doesn't have control, but I would assume he has strong influence. It seems ideal for Hasbro to keep the license. I think the brand may be stronger than it seems, and Hasbro may want to sell the publishing rights for some big money.

    Andoran (Pathfinder Charter Superscriber)

    Talonne Hauk wrote:
    What's puzzling to me about this is that Hasbro owns WoTC. Why that is significant is that due to the genius marketing and property deals Lucas wrangled out of Kenner for them to produce the Star Wars toys (For those unaware, Hasbro purchased Kenner and dropped their logo many moons ago.), Lucas now owns a double digit percentage of Hasbro. I guess he doesn't have control, but I would assume he has strong influence. It seems ideal for Hasbro to keep the license. I think the brand may be stronger than it seems, and Hasbro may want to sell the publishing rights for some big money.

    I've not read the release from WotC/Hasbro, but I swore I read a few days ago either here or on starwars.com that Lucasfilm might decide not to renew the license or more accurately, let it lapse.

    Cheliax (RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16, 2011 Top 32)

    Okay, if anyone can help me understand: Lucas owns the Star Wars brand, but who owns the Saga system? Could WotC, in theory, use the Saga system to create a new sci-fi game using magic wielding monks using the same rules, but losing the intellectual property? Or could Lucas sell the whole system to a new publisher? Say, for example, Mongoose?

    Cheliax (Bella Sara Charter Superscriber)

    James Martin wrote:
    Okay, if anyone can help me understand: Lucas owns the Star Wars brand, but who owns the Saga system? Could WotC, in theory, use the Saga system to create a new sci-fi game using magic wielding monks using the same rules, but losing the intellectual property? Or could Lucas sell the whole system to a new publisher? Say, for example, Mongoose?

    It really depends on the terms of the license between WotC and Lucas. It likely lays out who owns what and what the parties may do post-termination. Given the overlap between SAGA mechanics and 4e mechanics, it's very likely WotC has some claim to the underlying system. WotC's ability to create a new game with slightly different IP or Lucas's ability to license the Star Wars IP to a different publisher would also likely be governed by the license. There may be a non-competition agreement between the parties preventing such activities.

    In the absence of any terms in the license agreement, you're in the wild world of copyright law. In that case, WotC could likely create a new sci-fi game (and, Lucus could sue them if it's too similar to Star Wars). Similarly, Lucas could license the Star Wars IP to a new rpg publisher (and, WotC would likely have a much more difficult time claiming infringement, particularly if the new rpg publisher did something like use the OGL).

    Cheliax (RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16, 2011 Top 32)

    Sebastian wrote:


    It really depends on the terms of the license between WotC and Lucas. It likely lays out who owns what and what the parties may do post-termination. Given the overlap between SAGA mechanics and 4e mechanics, it's very likely WotC has some claim to the underlying system. WotC's ability to create a new game with slightly different IP or Lucas's ability to license the Star Wars IP to a different publisher would also likely be governed by the license. There may be a non-competition agreement between the parties preventing such activities.

    In the absence of any terms in the license agreement, you're in the wild world of copyright law. In that case, WotC could likely create a new sci-fi game (and, Lucus could sue them if it's too similar to Star Wars). Similarly, Lucas could license the Star Wars IP to a new rpg publisher (and, WotC would likely have a much more difficult time claiming infringement, particularly if the new rpg publisher did something like use the OGL).

    Okay, so hard to tell without the contract, then. Gotcha. Thanks for the clarification. It helps!

    Taldor (Pathfinder Adventure Path Charter Subscriber; Roleplaying Game, Modules Subscriber)

    Hey - - pretty plain to me that lightning doesn't strike twice.

    Look at the names Slavicsek and Perkins. See whose names are on both Starwars and 4e. Try to tell the games apart if you can?

    lol

    ...just sayin'

    Paizo Employee (Technical Director)

    Lord Fyre wrote:
    Lucas Arts, got a piece of every Star Wars RPG product that WoTC sold.

    Lucasfilm. LucasArts is their computer game subsidiary.


    Never really saw a lot of Star Wars games being run or the books selling off the shelves. Hopefully this will at least move some back inventory in the old FLGS.


    Vic Wertz wrote:
    Lord Fyre wrote:
    Lucas Arts, got a piece of every Star Wars RPG product that WoTC sold.
    Lucasfilm. LucasArts is their computer game subsidiary.

    Didn't LucasFilm eat up its baby LucasArts after SW:TFU?

    Osirion (RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32)

    James Martin wrote:
    Sebastian wrote:


    It really depends on the terms of the license between WotC and Lucas. It likely lays out who owns what and what the parties may do post-termination. Given the overlap between SAGA mechanics and 4e mechanics, it's very likely WotC has some claim to the underlying system. WotC's ability to create a new game with slightly different IP or Lucas's ability to license the Star Wars IP to a different publisher would also likely be governed by the license. There may be a non-competition agreement between the parties preventing such activities.

    In the absence of any terms in the license agreement, you're in the wild world of copyright law. In that case, WotC could likely create a new sci-fi game (and, Lucus could sue them if it's too similar to Star Wars). Similarly, Lucas could license the Star Wars IP to a new rpg publisher (and, WotC would likely have a much more difficult time claiming infringement, particularly if the new rpg publisher did something like use the OGL).

    Okay, so hard to tell without the contract, then. Gotcha. Thanks for the clarification. It helps!
    James Martin wrote:
    Sebastian wrote:


    It really depends on the terms of the license between WotC and Lucas. It likely lays out who owns what and what the parties may do post-termination. Given the overlap between SAGA mechanics and 4e mechanics, it's very likely WotC has some claim to the underlying system. WotC's ability to create a new game with slightly different IP or Lucas's ability to license the Star Wars IP to a different publisher would also likely be governed by the license. There may be a non-competition agreement between the parties preventing such activities.

    In the absence of any terms in the license agreement, you're in the wild world of copyright law. In that case, WotC could likely create a new sci-fi game (and, Lucus could sue them if it's too similar to Star Wars). Similarly, Lucas could license the Star Wars IP to a new rpg publisher (and, WotC would likely have a much more difficult time claiming infringement, particularly if the new rpg publisher did something like use the OGL).

    Okay, so hard to tell without the contract, then. Gotcha. Thanks for the clarification. It helps!

    With the original Star Wars CCG made by Decipher, Decipher owned the rights to the system and liscenced the setting.

    After Lucas gave the rights to Hasbro (gee there's a shock) Decipher still retained the rights to the system rules.
    A few years later they released their Wars Setting using the same (well with a few alterations) rules as the Star Wars game(an awesome Setting with a d20 Modern RPG version done byt Mongoose) which unfortunalty got cancelled after only 2 releases (and the RPG was about to release it's 4th book when this was announced, which also never saw the light of day).


    flash_cxxi wrote:

    With the original Star Wars CCG made by Decipher, Decipher owned the rights to the system and liscenced the setting.

    After Lucas gave the rights to Hasbro (gee there's a shock) Decipher still retained the rights to the system rules.
    A few years later they released their Wars Setting using the same (well with a few alterations) rules as the Star Wars game(an awesome Setting with a d20 Modern RPG version done byt Mongoose) which unfortunalty got cancelled after only 2 releases (and the RPG was about to release it's 4th book when this was announced, which also never saw the light of day).

    There is a Wars RPG, where!?

    Osirion (RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32)

    Studpuffin wrote:
    flash_cxxi wrote:

    With the original Star Wars CCG made by Decipher, Decipher owned the rights to the system and liscenced the setting.

    After Lucas gave the rights to Hasbro (gee there's a shock) Decipher still retained the rights to the system rules.
    A few years later they released their Wars Setting using the same (well with a few alterations) rules as the Star Wars game(an awesome Setting with a d20 Modern RPG version done byt Mongoose) which unfortunalty got cancelled after only 2 releases (and the RPG was about to release it's 4th book when this was announced, which also never saw the light of day).
    There is a Wars RPG, where!?

    WARS RPG Core Rulebook

    or here, depending on where you can buy from
    WARS RPG Core Rulebook
    These are only .pdfs though sadly. You might be able to find Dead Tree on eBay.
    There were 2 other releases as well. Another Sourcebook and and the first part of a 2 Part Adventure (the second part was the cancelled book athat was never printed, although both are self contained and can be played on their own... they were just party of a bigger Story Arc is all). I can't for the life of me remember the names of them right now but I can go looking and get back to you (my FLGS might even still have a copy of the Adventure left... they accidently ordered 2 of them in when I asked them to get all the WARS stuff for me)

    Osirion (RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32)

    Studpuffin wrote:
    There is a Wars RPG, where!?

    So you're a WARS fan too?

    I loved that game and colected all of the Short Stories/Music/RPG/anything else affiliated with it.
    I was quite sad when they cancelled it.

    Andoran (Pathfinder Charter Superscriber)

    I feel bad for WEG and Decipher. Both lost their licenses to WOTC who didn't do anything impressive in either market.


    SirUrza wrote:
    I feel bad for WEG and Decipher. Both lost their licenses to WOTC who didn't do anything impressive in either market.

    IIRC, WEG didn't lose the license; WEG essentially died, and some years later WOTC obtained the license. Or it may be that WEG lost the license, then died, but I am pretty sure there was some lag between WOTC picking up the license. Don't feel sorry for WEG - they were a great company, and I remember calling them up to order books directly and enjoying talking to whomever the guy was there, but the company struck me as not having much organization.

    Still, now I want to dig out my cartons of source material and run some old school Star Wars. Hmmmmm...

    Paizo Employee (Technical Director)

    the Stick wrote:
    SirUrza wrote:
    I feel bad for WEG and Decipher. Both lost their licenses to WOTC who didn't do anything impressive in either market.

    IIRC, WEG didn't lose the license; WEG essentially died, and some years later WOTC obtained the license. Or it may be that WEG lost the license, then died, but I am pretty sure there was some lag between WOTC picking up the license. Don't feel sorry for WEG - they were a great company, and I remember calling them up to order books directly and enjoying talking to whomever the guy was there, but the company struck me as not having much organization.

    Still, now I want to dig out my cartons of source material and run some old school Star Wars. Hmmmmm...

    West End Games lost the license after they went bankrupt due to financial issues related to imported Italian shoes.

    Yes, really.


    This was actually a really good, well designed game. Its too bad. Now I have no reason to get anything WoTC


    Vic Wertz wrote:
    ...related to imported Italian shoes.

    ???


    ChrisRevocateur wrote:
    Vic Wertz wrote:
    ...related to imported Italian shoes.
    ???

    I just looked it up, true story. Wow.

    WEG's parent company did shoes. They went under and took WEG with them apparently.


    Mikaze wrote:
    ChrisRevocateur wrote:
    Vic Wertz wrote:
    ...related to imported Italian shoes.
    ???

    I just looked it up, true story. Wow.

    WEG's parent company did shoes. They went under and took WEG with them apparently.

    Jeez, to get stomped out that way......


    Talonne Hauk wrote:
    Lucas now owns a double digit percentage of Hasbro. I guess he doesn't have control, but I would assume he has strong influence.

    Do you have a reference or link which shows that Lucas owns a double digit percentage of Hasbro's shares?

    According to a list of Hasbro's largest shareholders,

    http://finance.yahoo.com/q/mh?s=HAS

    no one person or institutional shareholder owns more than 10% of the outstanding shares.

    Compared to a company like Microsoft,

    http://finance.yahoo.com/q/mh?s=MSFT
    http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=MSFT

    these days Bill Gates doesn't even own more than 10% of the outstanding shares in Microsoft.

    Silver Crusade (Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Adventure Path, Campaign Setting, Companion Subscriber)

    Mikaze wrote:
    ChrisRevocateur wrote:
    Vic Wertz wrote:
    ...related to imported Italian shoes.
    ???

    I just looked it up, true story. Wow.

    WEG's parent company did shoes. They went under and took WEG with them apparently.

    Linky ? Can't really believe this ...

    (Pathfinder Superscriber; GameMastery Maps Subscriber)

    Gorbacz wrote:
    Linky ? Can't really believe this ...

    Don't have a link off-hand, but it's a true story.

    Kinda similar to how TSR tried to branch-out into rugs.


    flash_cxxi wrote:
    Studpuffin wrote:
    There is a Wars RPG, where!?

    So you're a WARS fan too?

    I loved that game and colected all of the Short Stories/Music/RPG/anything else affiliated with it.
    I was quite sad when they cancelled it.

    Yeah, it was a great card game with a very good background. I read through all of the Stackpole materials and collected most of the cards but I didn't know they made music or an RPG. That's great. I'll have to get this now.


    Meh. There's enough Star Wars stuff out there now that I wouldn't be the least bit surprised to see "Not-Star-Wars" RPGs arising. Hell, you can still find the old WEG minis if you hunt around.

    Surprising to see Wizards dropping the line, though. Not profitable? Even with the Clone Wars cartoon and so forth? I'd figure as long as you could still find the toys at Wal-Mart, you could still sell the figures and games...

    (Pathfinder Superscriber; GameMastery Maps Subscriber)

    James Martin wrote:
    Okay, if anyone can help me understand: Lucas owns the Star Wars brand, but who owns the Saga system? Could WotC, in theory, use the Saga system to create a new sci-fi game using magic wielding monks using the same rules, but losing the intellectual property? Or could Lucas sell the whole system to a new publisher? Say, for example, Mongoose?

    4th Edition Gamma World comes out this year.


    Gorbacz wrote:


    Linky ? Can't really believe this ...

    Another reason to be glad Paizo is privately owned.


    Pax Veritas wrote:

    Hey - - pretty plain to me that lightning doesn't strike twice.

    Look at the names Slavicsek and Perkins. See whose names are on both Starwars and 4e. Try to tell the games apart if you can?

    lol

    ...just sayin'

    Saga and 4e are completely different games. Ignoring settings, the mechanics are completely different. If 4e was half of what Saga is, I would be playing it.

    In Saga, you could customize a character til your hearts content. It actually encouraged multiclassing, to get the ideal Star Wars character you want to play. 4e went the complete opposite direction.

    I hope you were kidding, because this license issue has nothing to do with game mechanics. There's much bigger fish fryin'.

    Grand Lodge (Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Adventure Path, Campaign Setting Subscriber)

    James Martin wrote:
    Okay, if anyone can help me understand: Lucas owns the Star Wars brand, but who owns the Saga system? Could WotC, in theory, use the Saga system to create a new sci-fi game using magic wielding monks using the same rules, but losing the intellectual property? Or could Lucas sell the whole system to a new publisher? Say, for example, Mongoose?

    Ask yourself this.. if the original game with all the Star Wars goodies couldn't sell well enough to make it's print run justifiable, why would a generic game stripped of all the goodies sell any better?

    (RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32)

    Mikaze wrote:
    Gorbacz wrote:


    Linky ? Can't really believe this ...

    Another reason to be glad Paizo is privately owned.

    The Agony of DeFeet?


    Cheliax (RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16, 2011 Top 32)

    LazarX wrote:
    James Martin wrote:
    Okay, if anyone can help me understand: Lucas owns the Star Wars brand, but who owns the Saga system? Could WotC, in theory, use the Saga system to create a new sci-fi game using magic wielding monks using the same rules, but losing the intellectual property? Or could Lucas sell the whole system to a new publisher? Say, for example, Mongoose?
    Ask yourself this.. if the original game with all the Star Wars goodies couldn't sell well enough to make it's print run justifiable, why would a generic game stripped of all the goodies sell any better?

    Didn't say anything about wanting to see such a system. I was asking because I'm curious what Lucas owns: the system, the intellectual property that is Star Wars, or both.

    (RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8)

    Mikaze wrote:
    Gorbacz wrote:


    Linky ? Can't really believe this ...

    Another reason to be glad Paizo is privately owned.

    And to wish Vic and Lisa a long and happy life! ;-)

    (Pathfinder Adventure Path Charter Subscriber)

    Brian E. Harris wrote:
    4th Edition Gamma World comes out this year.

    Gamma World has alreay had 6 editions.

    Paizo Employee (Technical Director)

    Talonne Hauk wrote:
    Lucas now owns a double digit percentage of Hasbro. I guess he doesn't have control, but I would assume he has strong influence.

    Lucasfilm had "warrants" that gave them a *right to buy* Hasbro stock; Hasbro spent $200 million in 2007 to buy back those warrants.

    Here's a filing that showed more than 21% of Hasbro shares going to Lucasfilm: 8.3%; George Lucas: 8.3%; and Lucas Licensing: 5.2%.


    Interesting, now that the license is freed up... how about Star Wars Paizo style? That would be epic.


    WarEagleMage wrote:
    Interesting, now that the license is freed up... how about Star Wars Paizo style? That would be epic.

    Twi'lek Seoni.

    1 to 50 of 110 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | next > last >>

    Paizo / Messageboards / Paizo Community / Gaming / D&D 3.5/d20/OGL / All Messageboards

    Want to post a reply? Sign in.



    ©2002–2012 Paizo Publishing, LLC®. Need help? Email customer.service@paizo.com or call 425-250-0800 Monday–Friday, 10 AM–5 PM Pacific Time. View our privacy policy. Paizo Publishing, LLC, the Paizo golem logo, GameMastery, Pathfinder, Planet Stories, and Undefeated are registered trademarks of Paizo Publishing, LLC, and Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Pathfinder Adventure PathPathfinder Player Companion, Pathfinder Modules, Pathfinder Tales, Pathfinder Society, Pathfinder Battles, PaizoCon, RPG Superstar, The Golem's Got It, Titanic Games, the Titanic logo, and the Planet Stories planet logo are trademarks of Paizo Publishing, LLC. Dungeons & Dragons, Dragon, Dungeon, and Polyhedron are registered trademarks of Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and have been used by Paizo Publishing under license. Most product names are trademarks owned or used under license by the companies that publish those products; use of such names without mention of trademark status should not be construed as a challenge to such status.