Paizo Top Nav Branding
Welcome, guest! | Sign In | My Account | My Subscriptions | My Downloads | My Wishlists | Shopping Cart   Shopping Cart | Help/FAQ
About Paizo   Messageboards   News   Paizo Blog   Help/FAQ  
Search
Links
Shop

Messageboards

My feelings about 5E D&D, by Jason Ellis 350

MMO wish list, by Pagan

Preparing Kingmaker, questions from a GM, by Evil Lincoln

GM Advice: How do I make traps more interesting?, by Kthulhu

SWAT Kats, by Kalshane

Its not looking good for the fighter class in 5E, by Jason Ellis 350

Asheville Pathfinder Society Lodge, by dinketry

Help me protect my AC!!, by Joegoat

How could I release Rovagug, or even a spawn of Rovagug?, by Heaven's Agent

new dungeon terrain, by wellsmv

Fight: how to speed things up, by Booloo

Please Do Away With 7-Person Tables, by Myles Crocker

Why play a first world summoner?, by Kryzbyn

We Don't Need No Epic Content, by Kthulhu

Quick Help: Monsters in the Beginner Box Adventure, by Kthulhu

Online Campaigns

Left in Sandpoint, by Durgen Grimhelm

Valgrymr's Homebrew Two, by Gloisil Murigel

City of Nine Stars -- City of Twilight, by Waifrin Goddon

Goblins 2: The Wreckin'-ing!, by GM Goblin King

DM - Tareth's Modified Kingmaker Campaign Gameplay, by Aliana Do'Erren

Tales of Agartha: the Avalon Chronicles, by Agarthian Storyteller

Chapter 1: Just Beneath the Surface, by Charon Warblade

Sheik Voodoo's Katapesh Nights, by Sheik Voodoo

Jade Regent, presented by DM Hamied - Campaign Thread, by Almar Ashfield

SR's - Great Southern Isles (PbP), by Jayse

DM Caleth's Bronze Age: An Inheritance of Dragons, by Moredrel

Adventures to the Jade Regent, by Godfrey Warden

GM_Pace's Serpent Skull IC (Psionics / 3rd party friendly), by Adriano Fierro

DM Voice's Envoy of Geb - Game Thread, by Gathroc The Betrayer

Voodoo's Caravanserai, by Sheik Voodoo

   RSS Recent Posts Facebook Twitter Email

Paizo Publishing will be closed in observance of Presidents Day Monday, February 20.
We will reopen on Tuesday, February 21.


Search
Search this Thread:

301 to 350 of 351 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | next > last >>
(Male Human fighter 6)

All finished now, with the corrections added.

Andoran (Worthy Man-Thing Mutant lumberjack Redneck 2 / Intellectual 2)

Curaigh wrote:
The Eldritch Mr. Shiny wrote:


What would I have to do to recycle this character, other than leveling down and converting from PF flavor to Greyhawk flavor?
I will reread master thrower before approving (some PCs can ruin ST). I am not familiar with paragon, so what class is the 3.5 closest? I like the concept though. Relic hunting is a perfect reason to join an expedition to the forgotten lost savage Isle of Dread especially if one is too arrogant to recognize its dangers. :)

Cool, I'm glad that would work. Paragon classes are from 3.5 Unearthed Arcana (not to be confused with Monte Cook's Arcana Unearthed). I'd say the closest basic 3.5 class would be somewhere between rogue, fighter, and bard.

(Male Dwarf Warmage / 7)

In honor of the season I hope you enjoy this website.

World Pumpkin Throwing Championship

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

The Eldritch Mr. Shiny wrote:
Curaigh wrote:
The Eldritch Mr. Shiny wrote:


What would I have to do to recycle this character, other than leveling down and converting from PF flavor to Greyhawk flavor?
I will reread master thrower before approving (some PCs can ruin ST). I am not familiar with paragon, so what class is the 3.5 closest? I like the concept though. Relic hunting is a perfect reason to join an expedition to the forgotten lost savage Isle of Dread especially if one is too arrogant to recognize its dangers. :)
Cool, I'm glad that would work. Paragon classes are from 3.5 Unearthed Arcana (not to be confused with Monte Cook's Arcana Unearthed). I'd say the closest basic 3.5 class would be somewhere between rogue, fighter, and bard.

fighter is your other class right? Since paragon is not on the SRD (and I do not have a copy), choose rogue or bard (or *ack* some of both)

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

Halga Biir wrote:
All finished now, with the corrections added.

looks good, one down to to go O:)

Andoran (Worthy Man-Thing Mutant lumberjack Redneck 2 / Intellectual 2)

Curaigh wrote:
Since paragon is not on the SRD

Right here, bro.

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

The Eldritch Mr. Shiny wrote:
Curaigh wrote:
Since paragon is not on the SRD
Right here, bro.

hehe... Ok under races, I get it and I like it--its a go, but...

Spoiler:
The scarlet brotherhood is very conceited in their treatment of non-humans. I think it would be good for you to consider this affiliation and play it up. This is only if you want to. If interested, and you do not have the ST players guide let me know.

Andoran (Worthy Man-Thing Mutant lumberjack Redneck 2 / Intellectual 2)

Curaigh wrote:
** spoiler omitted **

Spoiler:
I have the ST player's guide, and I'm sort of interested. Just give me a little while to re-familiarize myself with Greyhawk, and I can start modifying my character and background.
(Male Human (Rhennee) Human Paragon 3 / Fighter 2 / Master Thrower 1)

Stats and description are done. Working on background right now.

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

Shariv the Skewer wrote:
Stats and description are done. Working on background right now.

Are those the stats from the other campaign? if so can you tell me where the boosts came from. i did not re-read master thrower yet (blush) otherwise it looks good.

Andoran (Worthy Man-Thing Mutant lumberjack Redneck 2 / Intellectual 2)

Curaigh wrote:
Shariv the Skewer wrote:
Stats and description are done. Working on background right now.
Are those the stats from the other campaign? if so can you tell me where the boosts came from. i did not re-read master thrower yet (blush) otherwise it looks good.

Formula for the Dex boost: 18 base + 2 from third level of paragon class + 1 at fourth level. As for the lessened attack penalties, they're from Two-Weapon Fighting, Improved Two-Weapon Fighting, and the Doubletoss weapon trick. I may have unintentionally min-maxed this guy--it's just that I couldn't pass up the character concept...

(Male Troll Expert 3, Warrior 1)

Here are the three sets of ability rolls.

Spoiler:
(set 1)
4d6=14\2,4,6=12
4d6=12\5,1,5=11
4d6=21\5,5,6=16
4d6=22\5,6,6=17
4d6=10\2,3,3=8
4d6=13\4,4,3=11

(set 2)
4d6=17\3,6,6=15
4d6=17\5,5,5=15
4d6=12\5,3,3=11
4d6=17\6,4,6=16
4d6=19\5,6,6=17
4d6=17\6,5,4=15

(set 3)
4d6=9\1,6,1=8
4d6=15\3,4,5=12
4d6=13\5,3,3=11
4d6=23\6,6,6=18
4d6=7\1,1,4=6
4d6=12\3,4,3=10

I'm going to go Barbarian, Human and I'm guessing I start level 6 as well.

My other rolls

Spoiler:
Magic Percentile (1)1d100=53
1d12=3
Magic Percentile (2)
1d100, 1d12=[82], [11]
Magic Percentile (3)
1d100, 1d12=[92], [1]

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

Terry Dyer wrote:

Here are the three sets of ability rolls.

** spoiler omitted **

I'm going to go Barbarian, Human and I'm guessing I start level 6 as well.

My other rolls
** spoiler omitted **

I am guessing you want the middle or the bottom one, but any of the three are fine. Yes level 6 (unless you want a random level (1d4). Oops if you are playing barbar can you even read the dance of my magic electonic ants?

shiny:

Spoiler:
I am mostly OK with master thrower, but there are two things that I do not like, the ranged touch attack, and evasion. I am trying to think of a way to nerf them without totally removing them though. If you have any suggestions let me know. One solution is the magic items I will create for you to replace the other abilities you would gain from Master Thrower.

Andoran (Worthy Man-Thing Mutant lumberjack Redneck 2 / Intellectual 2)

Curaigh wrote:
Shiny: ** spoiler omitted **

Spoiler:
I didn't see anything having to do with a ranged touch attack, so that one can simply be ignored if it's there. And the evasion issue can be easily solved by just removing the ability? Also, why would evasion be a problem? The character would just be getting a second-level rogue ability at seventh level, if I chose to take another level of the prestige class.
(Male Troll Expert 3, Warrior 1)

Curaigh wrote:
[I am guessing you want the middle or the bottom one, but any of the three are fine. Yes level 6 (unless you want a random level (1d4). Oops if you are playing barbar can you even read the dance of my magic electonic ants?

I'll take the middle one. Don't really feel like playing something with two penalties on it. Just got through playing one with three so kind of looking for a positive for a change.

I'm still working on my character. Juggling a new school project that is due in a week and trying to find a new house in another town so my wife can start work on Monday.... Nothing like being rushed, eh?

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

The Eldritch Mr. Shiny wrote:
Curaigh wrote:
Shiny: ** spoiler omitted **
** spoiler omitted **

I am unsure how the ability works into the concept of a master thrower is all. IMHO many PC just cherry pick the coolest abilities and concept be d@#ed. This seems one of those cases. the Ranged does fit the master thrower concept (one of the tricks you can choose), but taking armor out of the equation could break some encounters. Not to worry about it in either case. I will nerf (not remove) the evasion somewhat, but otherwise I think Shiv is ready.

TD: sounds good. Start with the non-combat stuff, point in game gives us a little break on that part, and PBP is kind of slow. Post what you have and hopefully we'll not need the rest before your RL slows some O:)

Andoran (Worthy Man-Thing Mutant lumberjack Redneck 2 / Intellectual 2)

Curaigh wrote:
I am unsure how the ability works into the concept of a master thrower is all. IMHO many PC just cherry pick the coolest abilities and concept be d@#ed. This seems one of those cases. the Ranged does fit the master thrower concept (one of the tricks you can choose), but taking armor out of the equation could break some encounters. Not to worry about it in either case. I will nerf (not remove) the evasion somewhat, but otherwise I think Shiv is ready.

Cool. (Just my two cents: I think that that particular weapon trick is really broken, so I wasn't going to take it anyway. I try to be responsible about stuff like that.)

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

The Eldritch Mr. Shiny wrote:
Curaigh wrote:
I am unsure how the ability works into the concept of a master thrower is all. IMHO many PC just cherry pick the coolest abilities and concept be d@#ed. This seems one of those cases. the Ranged does fit the master thrower concept (one of the tricks you can choose), but taking armor out of the equation could break some encounters. Not to worry about it in either case. I will nerf (not remove) the evasion somewhat, but otherwise I think Shiv is ready.
Cool. (Just my two cents: I think that that particular weapon trick is really broken, so I wasn't going to take it anyway. I try to be responsible about stuff like that.)

woot

TD is all that is left. Is everyone else ready to be introduced to the game thread then?

(Male Human fighter 6)

I didn't get all dressed up for nothin'.

(Male Human (Rhennee) Human Paragon 3 / Fighter 2 / Master Thrower 1)

Definitely. I've got a plan, you know.

(Male Halfling Paladin 2)

Yep.

(Male Dwarf Warmage / 7)

[Insert Random Comment Here] :D

(Expert 3/Slacker 4/Layabout 2)

Pointed rebuttal to random comment.

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

therealthom wrote:
Pointed rebuttal to random comment.

"..."

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

Lacking any real motivation for new characters to unexpectadely join the a party who shipwrecked too far from civilization to have any help, the DM pulls out an obligatory tavern with prisoners tied up in the next room.

No never mind.

Please ctrl R "survivors", "redshirts", and "rest of the party," with "Abe,Halga, Shiriv and the survivors", "Abe,Halga, Shiriv and the redshirts", and "Abe,Halga, Shiriv and the rest of the party," to the rest of the thread.

About familiarity: how much background does everyone need for the Savage Tide or more importantly Here There be Monsters? To get you caught up I mean?

(Male Dwarf Warmage / 7)

It be pretty easy all ya new comers. Thar be an island that summun, (Coughs and points at Amar) drove a ship into. Not sure how ya do that since an islands purty big, n stuff, but anyway's, he drove this ship inter this big ole island, and broke it. So then I findja and bee'in a bleedin' heart nice fella decided ter take ya across the island ter civilization. Now there was this big ole lizard that ate me, and a bunch of birds, and ta oogah boogah monster, but besides that its been a walk in tha park. A couple of ya lads died along tha way, and I'll hold a tankard ter yer names when we gets back, but tha most important thing tha you all kin remember is that i'm still alive so summun must be doin' sumpin right. Tha about cover it up Amar ole buddy?

(Male Troll Expert 3, Warrior 1)

Would it be better if I was a sailor that's been shipwrecked or would I just be a prisoner?

I was hoping for a mix of the two scenarios.

Spoiler:
Is there any chance I can substitute Profession Sailor for Riding? Just thought it wouldn't be a skill a sailor learned.

About finished with backstory and will post end of the night or tomorrow AM.

(Expert 3/Slacker 4/Layabout 2)

Urdok wrote:
It be pretty easy all ya new comers. Thar be an island that summun, (Coughs and points at Amar) drove a ship into. Not sure how ya do that since an islands purty big, n stuff, but anyway's, he drove this ship inter this big ole island, and broke it. ... Tha about cover it up Amar ole buddy?

It's not everyone that can break an island by driving a ship into it, but I'm an exceptional guy.

Actually Amar was just a crewman. He's had something of a revelation and discovered how to channel a motley collection of gods. Terry, or anyone, if you want to be crew, then we should know each other.

(Male Human (Rhennee) Human Paragon 3 / Fighter 2 / Master Thrower 1)

<- Background is finished.

(Expert 3/Slacker 4/Layabout 2)

Rimrock, FW is waiting on Zaid to post.

Andoran (Male Human Geek Level 10)

Thanks for the heads-up man,

Spoiler:

Curiagh, I don't know much about Savage Tide and nothing about Here be Monsters. I do have a book on the Greyhawk setting, so I'll think of a background and try to figure out what Abe would be doing on an island in the middle of nowhere.

(male human rogue- 2)

I know nothing of Savage tide or Here There be monsters.

Halga could definitely be one of the crew. A few levels of shipbuilding would make him useful.

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

EDIT: players guide to the savage tide is still available as a free download (I think)

Actually not knowing is fine, but here is the synopsis. keep to a single sentence, keep it to a single sentence, keep it to a single sentence...

Pirates killed Lavinia Vandeboren's* parents in the harbor, she hired some adventurers to reclaim the family's other ship (being held for taxes, but the tax guy worked for the pirates.) (There is no Honor)

Lavinia found out pirate was her brother Vanthus* and asked the party to find him. The trail led to Kraken's Cove where Vanthus unknowingly let loose a savage tide* and they found a ship they claimed as part of salvage laws.* (the Bullywug Gambit)

Lavinia discovered her parents were getting ready to mount a second expedition to the fabled Isle of Dread, an island full of wondrous creatures, vast resources and untold powers. If she had a second ship she would continue their venture and visit the colony of Farshore they left on the isle five years ago, and since the party has a ship agreed to make the journey with her. (Sea Wyvern's Wake)

The two ships were separated during a series of massive storms, one which ultimately led to the shipwreck of the Sea Wyvern. A few people on the ship managed to survive* and are being led overland to Farshore colony. (see urdock's post). (Here there be Monsters).

In essence the adventure as written is for the party to escort the survivors back to the colony. You can read the first few entries and randomly from there if you want. Knowing there was not to be any way to replace characters I have added a few "red shirts" who survived the wreck, but are not wholly aware. Wounded, dazed, and even unconscious these rag tag fleet of survivors awake as needed. As originally set up I only had two such red shirts and Amar became the first. however having lost all my table top people in the pbp there are plenty of spare bodies to go around.

Your character might have several reasons for being on the ship:
as a member of the adventurers group
as an adventure/scholar/expert wanting to see the fabled isle of dread (or not see something back home :)
a ships hand
a colonist with skills needed to make farshore viable.
a family member of a colonist from 5 years ago.
a noble whose partial funding made the trip possible.
something much more convincing than I have time to come up with while at work.

TD switch skills if you want, but if all the fabled creatures (dinosaurs) really do exist on this island, riding is a good option.

*each of these has lot of details, and i will add them as asked, anyone familiar with the AP or the characters, feel free to chime in and give you ol' DM a break--these might also be in the previous part of the thread if someone has time to search and link them for me... O:)

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

Shariv the Skewer wrote:
<- Background is finished.

woot looks good O:)

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

Any other questions? Shall we start?

(male human rogue- 2)

I'm ready.

Andoran (Male Human Geek Level 10)

I think Abe will be a colonist, if that's cool. I'm ready to start.

Andoran (Worthy Man-Thing Mutant lumberjack Redneck 2 / Intellectual 2)

I'm guessing Shariv's going to fall into the "adventurer with an ulterior motive" category. In any case, I'm ready.

(Male Human Barbarian 6)

Sorry for the delays. Been a busy and hectic time. Still going to be sporatic in posts but will try and get on every night.


And we are off!

Feel free to read as much of the thread as you want, but only the first page and the last page are necessary to know what is going on, and even then not all that necessary.

Click on my profile for the necessary links! (note Paizo has added a dice roller so invisible castle no longer needed but still OK.)

Welcome aboard!

Andoran (Worthy Man-Thing Mutant lumberjack Redneck 2 / Intellectual 2)

Just FYI, I'm pretty confused - are our characters just going to be retconned into having been shipwrecked there at the beginning, or are they going to be introduced?

(Expert 3/Slacker 4/Layabout 2)

The Eldritch Mr. Shiny wrote:
Just FYI, I'm pretty confused - are our characters just going to be retconned into having been shipwrecked there at the beginning, or are they going to be introduced?

There's a herd of shell-shocked survivors we're dragging around with us as we search for a way across the island. It's kind of like Battlestar Galactica that way. You're part of the herd. Up to now you've either been traumatized into total disfunction or you've been faking it.

(Male Dwarf Warmage / 7)

Ya just feel free to toss yourself in. One of the best mid-game introductions so far I felt was Amar's, scroll back and check out how he came in for some pointers if you like. Curaigh is pretty laid back so I think he will let you get away with almost anything, if you do cross the line I have always wanted to see him use his DM'S THUNDERBOLT FROM THE SKY!!!!!!!

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

Urdok wrote:

Ya just feel free to toss yourself in. One of the best mid-game introductions so far I felt was Amar's, scroll back and check out how he came in for some pointers if you like. Curaigh is pretty laid back so I think he will let you get away with almost anything, if you do cross the line I have always wanted to see him use his DM'S THUNDERBOLT FROM THE SKY!!!!!!!

REFLEX SAVE DC 137

Spoiler:
a lightning bolt from the sky pierces Urdok's presumptious, brown-nosing husk! Take 1083d12 brownies points *grin*

but yes, retconned in that you were ballooning with the party the whole time.

Is ballooning a common word yet? If not: when a player's absence necessitates a character following the party around like a balloon on a string (and nearly as fragile as Abe 'played' more deaths then he ever created characters :)

(Male Troll Expert 3, Warrior 1)

I'm not exactly sure what to do about equipment. Has it been with me this whole time or do I just get some later?

(Male Dwarf Warmage / 7)

Curaigh wrote:


REFLEX SAVE DC 137 ** spoiler omitted **

1d10000=4401

OH YA!! made the save what happens now

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

Terry Dyer wrote:
I'm not exactly sure what to do about equipment. Has it been with me this whole time or do I just get some later?

there is very little treasure in this AP as written. While you are not wearing any, the party did manage to scavenge a lot from the ship. So yes you start with equip, it might be a little out of game, but I can not see people surviving long without it *touches nose* exceptin a lizardfolk monk of course.

Urdock you made that save? what a waste of a good save. Now when I throw a sleep spell at you, you will fail. ahem I mean FAIL.
Karma: its a funny thing. O:)

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

Heading on the road tomorrow. I do not know what internet access I will have, but feel free to post and keep each other up to date.

Fang: I am heading your way after all.

Dinner? Game? I'll be calling you soon.

Andoran (Worthy Man-Thing Mutant lumberjack Redneck 2 / Intellectual 2)

Why does this always happen to me? As soon as I join a new PbP, RL starts running me into the wall. I'm going to keep posting in the two or so PbPs I've been in for a while, but I'm going to have to put my new ones on hold for at least the next week. Sorry about that...

Taldor (simply M Draco Electricus Wannabeus Expert 1, Armchair Expert (PrC) 8,)

The Eldritch Mr. Shiny wrote:
Why does this always happen to me? As soon as I join a new PbP, RL starts running me into the wall. I'm going to keep posting in the two or so PbPs I've been in for a while, but I'm going to have to put my new ones on hold for at least the next week. Sorry about that...

no worries. if you change your mind, you know where to find me. :)

Thanks for the notice though (usually have to track someone down to find out they are out :) Good luck Kickin Butt in the RL

301 to 350 of 351 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | next > last >>

Paizo / Messageboards / Paizo Community / Online Campaigns / Play-by-Post Discussion / All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.

Recent threads in Play-by-Post Discussion

Voodoo's Caravanserai
DM Heathy's Saltmarsh Discussion Thread
Worldwound Adventures Discussion
cynarion's Carrion Crown PbP Discussion
Nightflier's Blackdogs in Absalom - Discussion Thread
The Enemy Within And Other Tales Of Mud, Blood And Mutation Discussion
DM Sinvel's A Pound of Flesh in Freeport! discussion
CrazyHedgehog's Serpent Skull Discussion
SR Sport OOC
DM Aron Marczylo's Kingmaker OOC
Megan's Curse of the Crimson Throne OOC Thread
Wellards RotRL OOC thread
GM alientude's Shackled City Discussion
DM Fflash's Shackled City Campaign OOC
Fait Accompli IC Discussion
Sean's Fallen Fortress Discussion
Rev's Lost City (4e Paragon) - discussion thread
4e Tomb of Horrors discussion thread
Wounded Earth Players' Guide and Discussion Thread
Zyren's luxurious campfire... this time with marshmallows...



©2002–2012 Paizo Publishing, LLC®. Need help? Email customer.service@paizo.com or call 425-250-0800 Monday–Friday, 10 AM–5 PM Pacific Time. View our privacy policy. Paizo Publishing, LLC, the Paizo golem logo, GameMastery, Pathfinder, Planet Stories, and Undefeated are registered trademarks of Paizo Publishing, LLC, and Pathfinder Roleplaying Game, Pathfinder Campaign Setting, Pathfinder Adventure PathPathfinder Player Companion, Pathfinder Modules, Pathfinder Tales, Pathfinder Society, Pathfinder Battles, PaizoCon, RPG Superstar, The Golem's Got It, Titanic Games, the Titanic logo, and the Planet Stories planet logo are trademarks of Paizo Publishing, LLC. Dungeons & Dragons, Dragon, Dungeon, and Polyhedron are registered trademarks of Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and have been used by Paizo Publishing under license. Most product names are trademarks owned or used under license by the companies that publish those products; use of such names without mention of trademark status should not be construed as a challenge to such status.