City of Nine Stars -- City of Twilight (Inactive)

Game Master therealthom

Council of Thieves


1,151 to 1,200 of 1,236 << first < prev | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | next > last >>

Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Ooooohh! Scrying based on blood. That's a great idea! Very CSI! I never would have thought of that one. And I know just how to use it ....

Logan or Manchester?


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

I'll be out for the weekend and Monday. See you Tuesday.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

So, is anyone going to chip in on what you do next?

Even start a discussion of your next move?

I don't want to DM NPC the entire party! :)


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

So I feel like we're losing steam. Is there something I can change to get us back on track?

Liberty's Edge

Female Human Wilder 5th | AC13 | HP39 | Str 10 | Dex 15 | Con 13 | PP37/37

We're in a sneaky situation without Sneaky McSneaky, I think. We need a hint of where the attic/office is. I'm guessing South-West by the map.


For a PbP in a dungeon-delving situation like this, it's most convenient to just have one player say "we go here, we go there" instead of waiting for everyone to post. Or even better, the GM can just describe all of the uninteresting rooms that we pass through until we reach something interesting (assuming that we quickly scan each room for magic, traps, and other points of interest).

That's my two cents, anyways.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4
Waifrin Goddon wrote:
We're in a sneaky situation without Sneaky McSneaky, I think. We need a hint of where the attic/office is. I'm guessing South-West by the map.

I think I know the guy you need, but he's busy getting eaten by a sea serpent. You'll just have to brazen it out.

hogarth wrote:

For a PbP in a dungeon-delving situation like this, it's most convenient to just have one player say "we go here, we go there" instead of waiting for everyone to post. Or even better, the GM can just describe all of the uninteresting rooms that we pass through until we reach something interesting (assuming that we quickly scan each room for magic, traps, and other points of interest).

That's my two cents, anyways.

I agree the old "caller" concept does help move things along in PbP. Now that I've seen you guys sneaking around I can extrapolate a little bit while you're sneaking. But getting you back into the party, that's going to require your personal touch.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

'twill be a long silent Mother's Day weekend (I've got to do better than average for my wife, Chris, this year.) And MOnday I am traveling for work. COuld be Tuesday before I post again.


OK Folks I'm going away to Games Expo UK tonight and won't be back until Monday Evening my time. Playing 4 PFS games over the three days (and some Paranoia) so I won't be without my Pathfinder fix


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Well. That's a game changer! Nice post, Dabbler. I've been thinking on it since last night. I'll try to post at lunch.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Work kind of exploded.


This IS the internet you know ... Alegedly human Expert (IT) 5/Ninja 3/Witch 7

That was a good one....I mean, back-story is there to have an effect, to motivate and sometimes to stimulate. Waifrin's been hiding her name for a reason, so it's a secret.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

First line of comfortably numb?

hogarth, want to coup d'etat the party leadership and dictate what happens at the locked door?


Waifrin wrote:
No, I've just seen those lockpicks [in] that leather case [..]

Am I missing something? What set of lockpicks is Waifrin talking about?


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Just waiting for ya'll to thrash out what's happening at the door. Remember you have an auxilliary in Raven if you need him.


This IS the internet you know ... Alegedly human Expert (IT) 5/Ninja 3/Witch 7
Fiosa wrote:
Waifrin wrote:
No, I've just seen those lockpicks [in] that leather case [..]
Am I missing something? What set of lockpicks is Waifrin talking about?

I'm sure she got them out at some point when we were faced by a locked door...(scratches head)...maybe I completely got that wrong!


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

You called in Raven.

Kind of jammed today.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Dabbler, that was your first enervation failure, yeah? A pretty good run, but this is a tough time to be short on firepower.


This IS the internet you know ... Alegedly human Expert (IT) 5/Ninja 3/Witch 7

Naturally it happens at the worst possible moment! Waifrin still has half her power points, and her surge blast, and she's still buffed. She can function.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Work's gotten quite busy. It may be a few days before I post again.

Dark Archive

Some dude

I will be away from Wednesday morning until probably Sunday night. I may or may not have reliable internet access until then.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Thanks for the heads up!


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Should be able to post tonight!


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

So Tuesday didn't work out as planned.

I'm sorry guys. Lunch today is looking good.

I'll try to get back on track.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Away until Tuesday. Going to see my boy in upstate NY. Seven hours in the car with the wife and dog there and seven hours back. Best vacation of the summer.


I'll be on vacation from Sep 4 to Sep 11 with limited internet access. See you when I get back!


Happy 4th anniversary to this game!


4 years and we aren't into book 3 yet? This needs to speed up a bit.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Yeah, it does, Wellard. My ill advised foray into DMing 3 PbPs slowed me considerably, and there have been changes at work. I do appreciate all of you sticking around though.

We are closing in on the end of book 2, however.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

I'll give hogarth til lunch, then post for Fiosa to get this moving again.


Well it looks like this game doesn't need speeding up now as it's about to come to a sorry end

Fiosa is paralyzed,Marius is paralyzed and it's likely that Zarabeth will be too..even if she isn't it's unlikely that Zara and Waif can win this Archon or no Archon.


It does look grim, although Zarabeta's save is a ray of hope.

We have options.

1. Let the dice fall as they may. This could be a TPK.
2. Retcon mildly to let Fiosa do something more aggressive on her round 1.
3. Retcon more actively -- I'm open to suggestions.
4. Play it out and then decide.
5. I have two possible back doors for a deus ex machina, with some story justification. Either one could provide you with a timely ally.

Dark Archive

Some dude

I don't own Council of Thieves, and have avoided reading about it online, but I thought for sure we were in book 3 or 4 already! (I thought the bastards were book 2 and the play book 3, which is why I was so disappointed to get 55 gp. for what I thought was 1/6th of the entire Adventure Path!)

(If we don't make it, at least Zarabeta will never learn the dark secret that daddy never came home because he resettled in Westcrown and has a new wife and family, having abandoned his family in Katheer along with some outstanding debts he didn't want to repay!)


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

And per my post in the game thread

Option 6.

Treat the ghoul's first round as a charge, giving them +2, but only one attack apiece.

Liberty's Edge

Female Human Wilder 5th | AC13 | HP39 | Str 10 | Dex 15 | Con 13 | PP37/37

Playing "by the book" one shot apiece is appropriate. That means Zara's definitely not paralysed, as she hasn't been hit, but Marius and Fiosa are. Waif's second shot should destroy the ghast, and that leaves 2 ghouls vs 2 of us. Not great, but we could still pull it off - especially as being paralysed may not prevent Fiosa from channelling.

Another possibility is that Blastinator Waifrin may be able to catch all the ghouls in a 15' cone aimed high to avoid the fallen party members. If so she can max her surge and dish out 7d4+2 damage to all three.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

I am surprised that we haven't had more discussion about what to do.

Dabbler, good idea, but Waifrin's in the middle of the group. She can target 2 ghouls or a ghast. All of whom are in melee.

Hey, is that energy ray subject to -4 to hit due to the ghoul being in melee?


This IS the internet you know ... Alegedly human Expert (IT) 5/Ninja 3/Witch 7

Yes, but if Marius was paralysed would he no longer count? But if he's not, she would have made it a 1-point blast. Up to you I guess.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Hmmm. I've always imagined 'paralyzed' left you standing still if you were relatively stable when it took effect.

In any event Marius' first save was enough save v paralysis. So he could deal with it on his own. Waifrin can keep the power points; the shot is not needed.

That encounter didn't even register as a problem in my mind. I knew the shadows were brutal, but when I looked this one over I looked at BAB, damage, AC and HP. It didn't occur to me that they'd land so many hits and you'd fail so many saves, but in retrospect with three attacks each it's a pretty sure thing that 1 PC will be paralyzed and two isn't beyond possibility.

On the other hand, we faced more in RotRL at Foxglove's manor. But we knew what we were hunting there.


I'll point out that the RotRL party is more combat capable than this one.You walked that encounter even with my doubling the ghouls.


I'll be on vacation until Oct 30, so I may not post very often until then.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Sorry, guys. Took a long weekend with the wife. I meant to let you know Thursday before I left, but work was too busy. Today or tonight won't work well. Wednesday -- probably night -- before I post.


This IS the internet you know ... Alegedly human Expert (IT) 5/Ninja 3/Witch 7

When ever's good for you.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Heads up: I'll be away for the weekend with no internet access until maybe Sunday night.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Set, there's a PM coming your way!


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Rustlin gof paper behind Dm screen as I search for room description.

Post tonight.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Guys, RL is getting in the way. It may be Sunday before I can post.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

AFK til Monday night.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Sorry posting has been slow, guys. End of the year rush at work has had me swoggled. And with the holidays here, I think I'm going to officially put the game on slow mode until after Christmas.

I wish you all a Merry Christmas!


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Back and ready to roll.


Cookie Jar Pilferer 9 ; Dimensional Explorer 4

Just out of curiousity, where does Waifrin lie PP-wise?

1 to 50 of 1,236 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Online Campaigns / Play-by-Post Discussion / The Real Counsel of Thieves All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.